Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Molding planes - where to start?

Posts

Molding planes - where to start?

#1

Molding planes - where to start?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

Bjenk's cupboard has me wanting to build something similar, primarily with hand tools. Egad. One piece of the project that I'm completely unprepared for is the molding. I have no molding planes, and I don't know where to start.

Anyone want to suggest a good starter set of molding planes I should start trolling for? Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks!

Scott

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#2

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

ThomD

>You can find lists of basic types, I think Mike Dunbar has one in his books, but I have always been guided by specific projects. Like router bits, one just acquires them as required. A set, or several hollows and rounds is very useful. Molding planes are expensive to buy new, so it becomes a mater either of what you can make, or what comes up at decent prices second hand. I've gone to tool sellers looking for window frame planes and come away with hollows and rounds.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#3

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Chuck in cent il

>I've been interested in some moulding planes myself, and just haven't gotten to it yet. I did notice in the last issue of the Fine Tool Journal several lots in the auction section of some gathered assortments. I would guess the FTJ as good a place as any to start.

chucbkeck

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#4

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Hi Scott,

It depends what you want to do and where you want to go!

If doing moldings is something you think you will do on much of your projects, there is a small tool hunt to do.

There are many simple moldings plane for edge treatment, ovolos, simple cyma planes, beads and such. I use those very often. However, for crown moldings, you could find a nice cornice planes but you have to get a really good one or it wont work well.

I am using a full set of Hollows and rounds and a moving Fillister plane to make moldings. Its not that hard to master, you just need to get your head around the process.

So, I would say that getting a nice moving fillister and a set of H&Rs might be something to look for if that stuff is attractive to you. Or just go for a good cornice planes.

I like reproducing profiles using the tools and methods of old so I went the full monty.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Buy as you need

Jim in Burlington On

>I bought a bunch of different one's perhaps 30 or so. I've really only used 6. The small bead, a few ovolo, or ogee hard to tell the difference. I've also used 2 hollow and rounds. It's another sub handtool arena between finding them, purchasing and tuning them up your going to eat up alot of time. So shorten the curve and try to buy them off people that have actually used them. Whole set's that match are collectors dreams and the prices match. I bought a few matched set's and just because they are pretty doesn't mean they don't need loads of work. Good luck it's another very slippery section of the slope.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#6

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

wilbur

>Where to start?

Don McConnell's DVD "Traditional Molding Techniques: The Basics" to get the, um, basics on how to plan out and make a molding.

Also, Larry Williams' DVD "Making Traditional Side Escapement Planes" to learn how to make these planes, but even better is learning how they work.

Then go plane shopping. :@)

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#7

Re: Buy as you need

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I say make as you need, much easier than waiting to purchase. And Todd Herrli and Larry Williams have dvds to guide you. I also plan to try making some Japanese versions since I've got a big hunk of plane iron for cutoffs.

Pam

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#8

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Bjenk Ellefsen

>If you want to buy a set of H&Rs, its a small investment in itself but in my opinion, its well worth it. My set cost me around 1500$.

You have to find a very reliable tool dealer who knows what he is doing. I highly recommend Tony Murland. Just contact him and let him know what you need.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#9

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Dave Anderson NH

>Don't start at all Scott. It's another slippery slope that gets immediately very very very steep and is extremely good at emptying your wallet.

Seriously though a good half set of hollows and rounds and small set of the smaller sizes of beads is where I began. A pair of snipe bills is also very useful. Beyond that you get into what are considered the "complex molders".

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#10

Re: Larry and Don...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>teach two courses at Marc Adams School of Woodworking each year. The full workweek course, July 13-17 "Traditional Wooden Plane Making with Williams & McConnell," involves important design considerations and actual building of a hollow and round. They'll be staying around the following weekend for a shorter course on using them.

I've taken only the weekend session, and it was wonderful. It also included such helpful design information that I hope to attend the full week class in 2010.

Best, Ted

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#11

Depends

roninkokomo

>If you are the typical home woodworker, I would suggest that you can do very nicely with 4 pairs of hollows and rounds and 3 beading planes.

I'd get 3/8. 1/2, 3/4, and 1 inch H and Rs Might not solve every need, but you can design a lot of molding with those planes.

Ron

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Scott,

I build reproduction clock cases as well as repair old cases. I need to create many different molding profiles,most of which are hand tool shaped. I can't afford to buy molding profiles as I need them and the time to build planes becomes a whole other project.I pick up hollow and rounds of various sizes as I find them at flea markets.I can make alot of profiles using these. Sometimes I will create a scraper in the profile of the molding I want to reproduce and after roughing in I'll scrape the final shape.I do have an ovolo I found that I was able to use to create a particular molding I wanted.I'm always looking for new profiles that may be useful.I imagine I could end up with alot of planes.

Incidentally,the need to do so much improvising is the reason I got into clock cases.I enjoy the challenge of figuring out how to recreate(or invent)the many different details that make up a clock case.

If you can afford it,get hollows and rounds. Anything else,supply it as the need comes.You never know what you're going to need.---Jack

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#13

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Start with a small side bead plane, you will use that a lot. Then find a molding plane (cove & bead, ovolo, ogee, etc.) that you like for more complex moldings.

Then think of moldings instead of molding planes. You can make complicated moldings for furniture without any molding planes. Many traditional moldings are made up of pieces of wood of various shapes put together to produce the final moldings.

Stephen

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#14

+1 on the DVD's.

Chuck Nickerson

>I'm set to take their two classes in April at Kelly Mehler's school. I'm more excited than a puppy with two tails.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#15

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Well just hurry up....

>The bank.

Bill

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#16

Re: Larry and Don...

Doug Reynolds

>I took Larry and Don's Hollow and Rounds class and the weekend molding class last year at Marc Adams. We made two common profiles using a rabbet, H & Rs, and snipes bills. Seems to me there are very few profils that cannot be made with a nice, say half-set of H & Rs and a couple of rabbet planes. This summer, Larry and Don are back at Marc Adams and we are making a pair of snipes bills during the week long class. They are doing the molding weekend class following as last year. Last year we left with a completed pair of number 8 hollows and rounds with the first coat of finish and sharpened blades to boot. Doesn't get better than that.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#17

Don is amazing

roninkokomo

>Don used to travel over from Ohio for the Hoosier Galoots meetings in my shop in Kokomo which at that time was the epicenter of Hoosier Galootism. Don is also a wealth of information on old tool history, and he is a rare gentleman on top of all that.

Don is a wonderful craftsman, and a tremendous teacher.

Ralph Brendler used to have a page on his web site with step by step production of molding that was quite useful and pretty easy to learn.

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

#18

Re: Molding planes - where to start?

Jim O'Neal

>Unless you have patience and talent, I'd buy good, used old molding planes from a reputable dealer rather than try to make your own. I like buying old planes that were originally used by folks 100+ years ago. I live in the south so it's harder to find old wooden planes because many of them were abandoned to garages and sheds and have been destroyed by the humidity and bugs over the years. Try "The Best Things". I bought a very nice half set of Varvill skewed H&R's for @$650. I've also bought a moving Fillister and a couple of Ogee planes from Lee for reasonable prices. Lee is very knowledgeable and I have found Lee to be very fair to deal with. He handles old US and English molders. Check his site regularly and you can find what you need. You might also check Jim Bode's website - he has some nice molding planes for reasonable prices, too. I have also splurged over the years and bought a 3/16" side bead and a raised panel plane from Clark & Williams - man those are very nice planes. The only problem with the C&W planes is that I'm almost embarassed to use them, being the hacker that I am.