Relative tool costs/prices
Peter Evans
>In 18th century Britain a dovetail saw cost around twice as much as a try plane. By the end of the 19th century the cost was around the same. Today a (wooden) try plane costs around twice a dovetail saw (of similar handmade quality).
Now why is that so? Are any of the following valid?
1. spring saw steel was very expensive in 1750 and has been getting cheaper ever since,
2. quality timber for planemaking has been getting relatively more expensive, and hard to find, over time,
3. there is more labour in a wooden plane, and labour has become more expensive over time,
4. more skill is required to make a plane than a saw, and skilled labour is harder to find.
Or is it all of the above? Or are there other reasons? Is it marketing perceptions?
Interestingly a good dovetail saw appears to be a little more expensive than a good try plane of c. 1850 in the 2nd hand market - reflecting price relativities when new.
Peter in Sydney



