Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Relative tool costs/prices

Posts

Relative tool costs/prices

#1

Relative tool costs/prices

Peter Evans

>In 18th century Britain a dovetail saw cost around twice as much as a try plane. By the end of the 19th century the cost was around the same. Today a (wooden) try plane costs around twice a dovetail saw (of similar handmade quality).

Now why is that so? Are any of the following valid?

1. spring saw steel was very expensive in 1750 and has been getting cheaper ever since,

2. quality timber for planemaking has been getting relatively more expensive, and hard to find, over time,

3. there is more labour in a wooden plane, and labour has become more expensive over time,

4. more skill is required to make a plane than a saw, and skilled labour is harder to find.

Or is it all of the above? Or are there other reasons? Is it marketing perceptions?

Interestingly a good dovetail saw appears to be a little more expensive than a good try plane of c. 1850 in the 2nd hand market - reflecting price relativities when new.

Peter in Sydney

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#2

not #2

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am presuming by "timber" you mean beech. In the US there is almost no market for Beech. When some market opens up (usually rail ties) it promptly gets flooded. Typically beech trees are just left standing, unless the boundary being logged is a clear cut, in which case the beech gets chipped for paper. So there is no shortage of logs from which to make lumber that could be used for planes.

Last time I was at IWF show there was a German company pushing the sale of their "plantation grown" beech lumber of high quality. So, apparently there is no shortage of Beech in Europe either.

However, the size of the market for beech to make planes is microscopic so there may well be some issues getting a mill and kiln to bother supplying it.

Beech is a worrisome wood to dry. I would be curious how the large volume plane makers of their day processed their lumber for plane stock. I have heard tales of small makers boiling their beech stock ( a process that would relieve stress and make drying easier) but I don't know if these tales are true.

One wonders if a blindfolded woodworker would notice a difference if the plane was made from maple, but then I suppose people that currently buy wood planes are wedded to tradition. A plane maker I met in Canada seemed satisfied with making his planes from maple.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#3

hmmm, Woodfinder

Larry Williams

>What you're saying, Bill, is in some ways true. The majority of lumber today moves through the commodities market. The commodities traders are like Wal-Mart, into price and volume. Also like Wal-Mart, it's not where knowledgeable people should turn when it comes to quality and suitability.

I've been enjoying developing a relationship with a great supplier who I found through Woodfinder. These guys are good and they're most concerned with quality and getting what I want. I'm delighted to get away from the commodity market. A good example of what commodity traders do to products can be seen in what happened to mortgages when they were turned into a commodity. The less I buy from the commodities markets the better off both me and the Nation will be.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#4

Re: hmmm, Woodfinder

Peter Evans

>Larry, do you have any ideas on why the price relationship between saws and planes changed?

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#5

nothing more than a guess

Larry Williams

>Improvements in steel making and roller mills would be my guess. As the number of steel mills grew and efficiency increased, the price of steel should have dropped.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#6

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

ThomD

>>1. spring saw steel was very expensive in 1750 and has been getting cheaper ever since,

I don't know about that, there really isn't any such thing as saw steel, there is hardened steel feeler stock, and if that serves the purpose it is cheap. I don't think the hand forged, or forge made steel saws blades are all that cheap these days, unless one has many thousands burning a hole in one's pockets.

>2. quality timber for planemaking has been getting relatively more expensive, and hard to find, over time,

Well maybe so, but there is about 2 board feet in a jack plane, say, so it can aford to be pretty expensive wood before it becomes a factor. If buyers of planes were as willing to be materials flexible as buyers of saws, there wouldn't be a problem, even if there is now.

>3. there is more labour in a wooden plane, and labour has become more expensive over time,

That would suprise me I think a saw would take me longer, but I don't really know, been making planes for nearly 30 years, and saws hardly at all.

4. more skill is required to make a plane than a saw, and skilled labour is harder to find.

I doubt that also. Filing teeth seems the equal in time and skill of anything required in making a plane. Plane making is pretty simple. The materials are not oddly shaped or particularly difficult to form accurately. Many of these businesses are one person shows, so training personel is not an issue.

I think you pose an interesting question, but we probably aren't at the root of the mater yet. One thing, it seems to me, is that there are more advertised makers of saws at the moment than planes, though new names pop up every moment, so I can't really say for sure. I think the saw business is pretty competitive.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#7

Re: let me offer a thought...

Glenn Madsen

>Consider the cost and capabilities of alternate goods to the hand saw. Bandsaws, circular saws, table saws, reciprocating saws and many others of the like have become available, actually ubiquitous, and only a select few in industrial economies buy and use hand tools of high quality. Good used handsaws go for (went for) very little in the resale market.

There are fewer alternatives, IMO, to a good handplane, and none quite as simple as an electric saw. Or as cheap.

(please throw no rocks at the recovering economist/hand tool user...)

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#8

Re: let me offer a thought...

Peter Evans

>Thom, as you cast pretty reasonable doubt on points 2-4; that leaves us with point 1. Good quality steel (needed for quality saws) was expensive, and Huntsman did not invent crucible cast steel until the middle of the 18th century.

Glenn, the major change in price relativity came about before the arrival of electric saws. I agree that today power tool users are more likely to own a plane than a saw. At the bottom end of the market, planes are cheaper than saws, including hardpoint saws. At the top end (eg C & W, Wenzloff) this is reversed. Why?

People buying top end hand tools are not influenced by power tool pricing, so the pricing differences are interesting.

One factor that supports the steel argument is the range of saw qualities "in the age of hand tools", when at the same time there were at most 2 grades of plane from a manufacturer, usually one (until well into the 20th century). I note that the differences in saw prices were all metal related - brass or iron back, and grade of steel (there were 4 grades in early 19th century); I have not seen a choice of handles in catalogues; filing would have been the same for all saws.

--------

Peter in Sydney

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#9

Re: let me offer a thought...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Peter,

Just an observation..... But I think it's a factor, along with the others that have been cited in this thread.... For some reason, most of us moderns are prepared pay more for a plane than a saw. Not talking about any particular person, but just the collective behavior. Think about $300 for a new bench plane versus $300 for a new saw. Myself, I think great saws are magic.

For the future, I see saw prices going up. But for right now, there's the magnetic pull of the see-through shaving.

Wiley

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#10

Re: let me offer a thought...

Peter Evans

>Yes Wiley, I think there is something in market perceptions, for example people pay more for a metal plane than a wooden plane, and have done so for a long time, probably since they were first introduced.

The 1930 Buck & Hickman Catalogue prices - a 22" double iron Try plane was 13/8; a Millers Falls metal plane was 30/9; a Norris was 79/-. All did the same job, and many think the wooden plane did the _best_ job. Even today a LN metal plane costs more than a C & W wooden plane; of course an infill costs a lot more still, but does it do a better job?

Cheers

Peter

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#11

Re: let me offer a thought...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Except for the first Japanese plane I bought, I've paid much more for Japanese wooden planes ($300-750) than for western metal planes. And even the ones I've built were about $200 for dai and blade, just about the same as the LN LA Jack, the most expensive metal plane I have.

Pam

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#12

Re: let me offer a thought...

wilbur

>"For some reason, most of us moderns are prepared pay more for a plane than a saw. Not talking about any particular person, but just the collective behavior. Think about $300 for a new bench plane versus $300 for a new saw."

As has been mentioned, my guess is also that it's due to the availability of powered tools to do the same job. A bandsaw with a tilting table can easily take the place of a dovetail saw. I'm having a hard time thinking of a machine that can do the same thing as a well tuned bench plane (and no, a ROS doesn't count), except maybe that Hitachi Super Surfacer that I've only seen pictures of, and those things are pretty pricey.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#13

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Peter,

I think you are correct in your assessment. The price of a dovetail saw and try plane are about the same in 1816 in Smiths' Key.

Also quarter sawn beech, the cut preferred by plane makers is also the most costly method of log conversion. More handling and less yield per log. Beech like other nut and fruit woods does not season well in the round. One year per inch of thickness to air dry, tool makers needed to plan in advance to have sufficient dried stock to match demand.

Labor in Europe was cheap, materials expensive, just the reverse in America. The price of iron and steel dropped throughout the entire 19th century as production improved.

Stephen

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#14

Re: let me offer a thought...

Peter Evans

>Pam, I was discussing Western tools, however as you say the Japanese market is quite different again (and one I know very little about, except as a, sometimes amazed, observer). My rough impression is that handmade saws are as expensive as planes. Can you comment on whether the cost differences are always steel related?

I am not in the stratospheric markets, except perhaps for an old 603 Bedrock in perfect condition (for which I paid US$200), my purchases of saws and planes have been at the economy, needing refurbishment, end.

Re: Relative tool costs/prices

#15

Re: let me offer a thought...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Saws in general seem a bit less expensive; but I'd bet a plane blade has more steel in it than most saws. However, saws probably require a lot more labor.

As to western wooden planes, it seems the price is dependent on who the maker is and what wood is used. For example, boxwood generally costs a lot more than beech.

Pam