We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>below is a picture of a mantel whose front is shaped in 2 different planes, i.e. the front of the mantel bows out in areas and in in others, along with the curved shape along the bottom edge of the piece. I've seen an original, as in from the late 1700's, in person, so I know that the moldings along the edge framing the opening of the firebox were applied. I've successfully created a blank that fits to the piece I'm working on, but obviously can't just use a router or a molding plane to shape the face because of the curves in the 2 different planes. I've considered a scratchstock, but this molding requires removal of quite a bit of material and have been advised against this route. Hand carving is a possibility, although I don't know how I'd get a straight-enough line using just some carving tools. So, how do I make this? Have I misinterpreted the construction of this thing? Does anybody have any idea how the French did this in the 18th century, without benefit of power tools or even electric light for that matter? I'm stumped!!!! By the way, in real-life, my mantel is being constructed of 8/r walnut which was cut into thirds, mitering the center section at 4 degrees on each side, then the whole thing put together and chopped,shaped,carved, and had a lot of bad words thrown at it.
>It looks like it was sawn from a solid piece of wood. The grain line in the guitar shaped molding look continuous, so they may just have sawn it with a bowsaw from a larger block. Where the molding wraps around and out of the picture on the left, the wood looks darker as though it was endgrain. One option would be to saw the lower edge curves, and the face out of a solid block, then work the molding profile while the upper segments were still parts of the block and solid, then saw the contact surfaces and upper edge last.
I would probably do it as a carving combined with some scraping for the final forming. I'm not much of a carver, and carving it doesn't daunt me all that much. I would probably use carving mostly to get rid of the waste. I would probably use fenced cutting and scratch tools to remove some waste to get it down to square dimensions, then I would rough rounds with gouges, and possibly use a scratch stock or a series of scrapers to clean up. However, if there is all the endgrain I believe that I see, then scraping/scratching would be harder to do.
I don't think the kind of carvers that were around in the days of yore would have broken a step on this. It is certainly a nice simple (not Shaker "simple") piece, but it appears relatively crude compared to a brace of realistic game birds I saw hanging by their necks by a lace tied to a spike in a wall, all carved from one piece of wood.
They may not have had modern power tools but, as we all know, they did have long days with little time off for anything other than church. I remember seeing this card from an early 20th century bookstore in Belfast that described the hours of their employees. They had to work all day everyday, including the evenings. The only exception was that if they were properly courting a lady, they could take off one evening a week for that purpose. They also got mornings off on Sundays when they would have been in church. I believe they worked Sunday afternoons, which I found verging on shocking considering Sunday shopping is relatively recent addition in my part of the country. I remember when we did this historical project in the investment industry that we found minutes of association meetings from the 30s in which owners were bemoaning the fact employees expected to be allowed to take breaks to go to the bathroom. Something one hears about in immigrant labour industries like chicken processing, today. If I worked those hours and conditions I would get something done!
>Given the unevenness of the fluting on the bottom edge, I'd say it was hand carved.
That said, there's a wide range of ways to do it. I'd bet dollars to donuts that it was roughed out with other things first. If I were to do it from square-cornered stock, I'd probably concoct a procedure like this:
-Lay out the shape of the field, and the lower fields, and chop/finish them with a router plane. Do this for the face, and the other field that's "around the corner." Bring these two surfaces out to the corner.
-Rabbet out the bottom edge as best you're able before fluting, with a router plane, rabbet plane, or something similar.
-lay out the curve on the bottom edge. lay out a 45 degree angle cut that's tangent to that, and saw off the bulk of the waste. Continue sawing off corners as best you're able, until you're able to finish the curve with chisels.
-re: curves in general, there's a rough proportion of that you can lay out from the center lines of 2 adjacent faces. Just less than half from each center line toward the corner is keeper wood. the remaining more than half is the part that gets sawn away. You may see this when you lay out the block to be sawn off. If you can get a good handle on this proportion, you can use it to lay out your carving on the remaining parts that are left to be carved Instead of a bead, it should be left square-edged, so you can lay out a center line, and then the rough ratio lines. Carve away the corners with a straight edged chisel, and you'll get a bead that's half an octagon in cross section. Knock the corners of that down, and it'll be half of a 16 sided polygon, and so forth, until you're close to having something like a bead that you can continue to scrape down. The fluting underneath is harder to get right... and it shows in the example.
-Chasing the bead around the corner is an exercise in getting the round, but still square edge rough stock first. And the inner section you can cut straight down from the upper edge. If you look closely, it looks like there's an odd vertical line... maybe it's just the end grain transition... but it looks to me like the artisan involved got his sides finished first, and then did the corner transition.
Try not to get your head too bent around this, thinking of it as a carving project. It's not. It's a cabinet-making project. This is not premier carving done by a professional carver. It's a decently made edge decoration that was (my opinion) roughed out by a competent cabinetmaker, and then finished up with carving tools.
My new shop is just about up and running, if y'all want, I can do a brief photo-essay in a week or two.
I don't know a thing about period practice, but I do have a question. Phil said he knew for sure that a true Period example he had seen had its molding applied. Not stuck or carved in the solid.
So. Is there a possibility that the maker (1) started by making a straight piece of molding on a sticking board; (2) removed some unneeded wood from the back of the molding; (3) steamed the (now-thinned) molding to make it soft and pliable; (4) pressed the flexible molding into place using hot hide glue (with a fast tack); (5) and took care of the highly- curved end piece by making a miter fit to the run of molding across the face.
I think I would try to do something like the above, before I tried to carve a mold from solid. At the least, I would make a miter fit of the end piece to eliminate the extreme curve. Perhaps that is what was done, which would account for the color change where such a miter might be made.
>Wiley, I don't think you would have much success bending a molding like this. It is just too tight a curve for the width and thickness of the molding. I think you can see on the right side of the curve that the grain is going crosswise like it was cut out of the solid. Moldings like this are surprisingly easy to carve.
I think the challenge lies more in coming up with a procedure for laying it out and shaping it in a predictable way, than in carving it. Successfully planned, there would really be very little "carving" involved. It would be more for the purposes of refining the final shape than anything else.
I'm sure it's possible that there are examples with applied moldings, but I have to agree that successfully bending such a molding in more than 2 directions is begging for trouble. Bending a semi-circular cross section such that the flat defines the inner radius of the circle is pretty straightforward. Bending it "sideways" would be a lot more work than carving it out, I think.
Give me a few days, I'll show you guys what I mean. This is easier than it looks, it's just a question of procedure.
>"Successfully planned, there would really be very little "carving" involved. It would be more for the purposes of refining the final shape than anything else."
Phil, After studding teh pic the outside carving is applied to the core piece. Grain matching excels here, I've had to do it myself. If I can copy/get a pic of a G&G frame I made a while back I can show u...
>Here is how I think they constructed this mantel. There are two molded side posts perhaps 2 inches wide and 3 inches deep. A full width 1X4 top rail is mortised into the posts flush with the back. Possibly two tenons. Moldings are attached along the bottom of the rail and the inside edge of the posts. Then the assembly along with two 2x5x10 corner blocks are given to the carver who saws the profile on the bottom and carves the molding and s curve on the face, all out of the solid. He has to match the moldings up with the frame. The molding is mitered where it meets the back post. The corner blocks might be mortised into the posts in front of the rail as well. The shelf is scrolled and a molding is carved on the edge.
The carving is a good part of the work, but I think it is worthwhile because it makes for a sculptural interest. I am on my way to Williamsburg today.
>Are there other pictures from other angles, or showing more of the piece in question? It looks (from looking at the grain lines) like there's not just a rounded corner, but a concave part between the corner and the leg. But with a full on 90 degree view like this, it's not fully clear.
I looked again, and noticed that it looks like there's not just the rounded corner, but it's probably also concave between the corner and leg.
I still think that the molded section would be simple to lay out. But I have a feeling that the concave section was done with a curved sole plane. And after it was carved, I'm guessing that there was some resawing of the piece, and that the thin, removed section was then pierced to make the relieved design above the molding, before being reapplied, and thus matching the grain lines up so well. It makes some sense... the edges are chipped out on one of the reliefs, as if sawn that way, and the relieved areas aren't perfectly parallel, so maybe the saw wandered just little bit. In the end, I think the easiest way to make sure an applied molding is going to fit perfectly, and get the grain lines to line up so well, is to cut it away from the block to begin with.
It would be easier to see if we could get a better look at the bottom edge. But who really knows.
I'll still see what I can do to replicate the thing next week, and bring the results in here.
>Yes James, the piece is not only curved on the front plane, but also on the front-to-back plane. I have successfully created blanks whose backs fit tight against the main piece, using templates that I had been using all along, and cutting a big chunk of wood as I would a cabriole leg. The only difference is that I had 2 completely different shapes to cut, and I did a lot of finessing so the blank would fit tight before cutting the rounded shape along the bottom edge. I've now created a scratchstock which I will use, if necessary, after I've carved out the basic shape. I have a bunch of molding planes and found one that would be quite suitable, so the straight pieces were done with that, and I'm now trying to copy that shape with carving tools. As I said, I will use the scratchstock where/if necessary to get the final shape.
>I appreciate the help. I guess I always knew that carving was the way to go, and I wasn't really looking for a faster method, but one I'm more confident in. So, I'm just gonna plunge in with the carving tools, work slow, and hope for the best. I'm not doing this for a living, so I can spend all the time I need on doing this. Thanks again for the suggestions (and the confidence-building)