Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Heretical post. I apologize

Posts

Heretical post. I apologize

#1

Heretical post. I apologize

roninkokomo

>I am 63 years old. I will never get to be as good a craftsman as I want to be. In an effort to make a little step forward I ask, is in not redundant ( in most shops) to have a shooting board and a Lion Miter trimmer. I am thinking it would be better to become expert with one than mediocre with two??

Am I missing something?

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

#2

Ellis Walentine

No heresy there

Ellis Walentine

>My two cents is that you can live without the Lion Trimmer. I've owned a couple of them and the instant the blades get the slightest bit dull -- which is promptly -- they ride out of the cut, especially on harder woods and thinner passes. A shooting board is much more versatile. As long as you know how to put a keen edge on your plane irons, you can usually count on accurate results from a well-made shooting board.

Also, I wouldn't think of this dilemma of yours as a craftsmanship conundrum. Both options fall more into the category of jigged operation as opposed to skilled. The skill is in learning to use the fixture correctly. And, don't sell yourself short. With ambition and some practice, you can most certainly learn to be a good craftsman or at least a much better one. You'll be surprised, and the reward is worth the effort. These folks here are an excellent resource for your quest.

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

#3

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

Ace Karner

>I use my Lion trimmer for gross adjustments and the do the final fit with a shooting board. This way I can set my plane to take the finest of cuts.

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

#4

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

MikeW

>"A" shooting board? I find it difficult to live without at least two fixtures for shooting edges.

I use the typical shooting board for flat 45 deg. miters on items like picture frames, or straight 90 degree edges of stuff not too wide. I use a miter jack for 45 deg. face edge miters for say a mitered box or wide straight boards on the opposite face.

As for the miter trimmer? If you have the means to sharpen the blades reliably by yourself, the ones I have used do work well for small adjustments. I wouldn't ever purchase one, however. I think for myself that the above shoot boards/jigs take care of my needs.

Take care, Mike

PS. I also do not think of this decision as a craftsmanship issue. Nor do I think of either choice as a means to becoming more proficient (an "expert"). Both are simply the means to an end. For me, that means doing repititive tasks more quickly than I could "freehand."

It takes a certain degree of "skill" to make one's shooting devices and the necessary future tuning, the sharpening of the plane, etc. etc. Take your time to get the board(s) correct and the payback is less time fiddling around later.

fwiw, either solution depends on accurate layout and stock prep.

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

#5

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have several shooting boards and a miter jack which I use on a regular basis. However I also own an Oliver 9 1/2 miter trimmer. It was given to me by a friend that said he could never get the thing to work.

I took the blades off and sharpened them, put them back on and the tool works great. I would imagine a dull blade would ride out as Ellis suggested. But with sharp blades it does trim off the nicest thin shaving and produces a very smooth miter (or other angle cut).

So after I trim them on the Oliver, I put them to the shooting board, miter board or miter jack and tooth the joint with a toothing plane. This does a good job of preparing the surface for gluing.

Stephen

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

#6

Re: Heretical post. I apologize

MikeW

>Yes, the good ol' heavy metal Oliver trimmers are tops. Not at all like the Lion-type except in principle and operation. The mass and rigidity adds a lot once the blades are sharp.

Don't get me wrong. While I wouldn't go buy one, I would take a heavy metal version if someone gave me one or I saw one at the scrap yard.

Speaking of heavy metal, time to put some on the shop radio...I'm feeling in a Sabbath mood right now.

Take care, Mike