Re: Heretical post. I apologize
MikeW
>"A" shooting board? I find it difficult to live without at least two fixtures for shooting edges.
I use the typical shooting board for flat 45 deg. miters on items like picture frames, or straight 90 degree edges of stuff not too wide. I use a miter jack for 45 deg. face edge miters for say a mitered box or wide straight boards on the opposite face.
As for the miter trimmer? If you have the means to sharpen the blades reliably by yourself, the ones I have used do work well for small adjustments. I wouldn't ever purchase one, however. I think for myself that the above shoot boards/jigs take care of my needs.
Take care, Mike
PS. I also do not think of this decision as a craftsmanship issue. Nor do I think of either choice as a means to becoming more proficient (an "expert"). Both are simply the means to an end. For me, that means doing repititive tasks more quickly than I could "freehand."
It takes a certain degree of "skill" to make one's shooting devices and the necessary future tuning, the sharpening of the plane, etc. etc. Take your time to get the board(s) correct and the payback is less time fiddling around later.
fwiw, either solution depends on accurate layout and stock prep.