A new gift from santa
Mark Perkins
>Hi all I just received a lovely set of mortise chisels. They are ground at 25 degrees and I want to use them on oak. I'm about to give them a final hone. Is this an ideal angle to start off with?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
A new gift from santa
Mark Perkins
>Hi all I just received a lovely set of mortise chisels. They are ground at 25 degrees and I want to use them on oak. I'm about to give them a final hone. Is this an ideal angle to start off with?
sash mortise chisels?
roninkokomo
>That's what they look like to me, and nice ones at that. 25 should work if you are doing light work. I believe the more beefy mortise chisels are ground at 30.
Re: A new gift from santa
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Mark,
Those are beautiful chisels, and excellent steel in my experience from using Two Cherries gouges.
The general principle is that you are after two conflicting objectives: You want a thin bevel to get a deep strike for the force applied, but then you want a high enough angle that the edge doesn't fold. To resolve the conflict, what is frequently recommended is to grind, including hollow grind, an acute primary bevel at 25 degrees or so, then use a very small microbevel to protect the edge.
As this applies to you, I suggest you use the 25 degree bevel as delivered, hone to 25, and observe the results. If the edge isn't taking the load, put on a very small microbevel at 28 or 30 and try that. Then repeat.
Folks may argue with me on this, but my experience is that the simple act of driving the chisel down into the wood is not what folds or chips good steel. Rather, it's how much heavy levering and bottom scraping you do to clear the waste. I use a technique which involves getting deep penetration on every strike, and not a lot of heavy levering--so I use about 27-28 degree single bevel.
In general, whatever rule anyone quotes to you will relate to their particular methods. I suggest you experiment, starting with the 25 degree bevel you have right now. If you get edge damage, then go to a little higher microbevel.
Wiley
Re: A new gift from santa
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I would also stay with what you have until you have tested the waters. It is likely that you will need to add a higher secondary bevel (I'd rather not call this a "microbevel" as it is more substantial and designed to beef up the edge, not simply change the cutting angle).
The "traditional" setting (ala oval bolstered mortice chisels) is a 20 degree primary (for penetration) and a 35 degree secondary bevel (for strength). On vintage chisels this will hold an edge for a reasonable time in Australian hardwoods.
Regards from Perth
Derek
contrary observation- 3V meets it match
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I was dovetailing some white oak yesterday. It was some stuff I cut from some 2 Common to make a rolling cabinet to hold lathe tools and other lathe stuff. (Resting things on the lathe bed has become intolerable.) This was recalcitrant, exceptionally dense material. First whack on the chisel and the edge folded over, no prying involved. The bevel was ground around 25 degrees and had done fine even on a previous red oak project. Being very tough 3V I was able to straighten the edge, without it breaking, on a piece of flat ceramic and I honed a secondary bevel at about 30 degree. At 30 degrees the edge didn't deform upon bashing.
Data is the greatest stuff....
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Bill and all,
Excellent data point! Do you have any idea why some blocks of wood are harder, denser, meaner than their peers? I ask in light of your numerous past reports of experiences in the lumber business. Slower growth? Tree was located in a drier place on side of hill?
My observations about the 27-28 degree single primary bevel all relate to pretty tame woods--flame birch, figured cherry, curly soft maple. I can visualize having to go to 30 in hard maple.
Wiley
...tropisms
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>There are many things that can cause wood to be different among the same species.
Geo-tropism, if it is located on a hillside and which exposure which leads to photo-tropism where the trees grow toward the light. Also wood on different sides of the tree have different density. Wood on the north side of trees is harder than wood from the south side of the tree (opposite in the southern hemisphere).
Mineral uptake during growing can also effect the quality of the wood, climatic conditions such as drought can cause much finer growth rings.
Air dried wood is much different than kiln dried wood of the same species.
Stephen
Re: ...tropisms
Dean J in MN
>Air dried wood is much different than kiln dried wood of the same species.
I've heard this stated before -- I'd like to ask both you and Bill T. for data regarding this statement. If we eliminate the case of a mistake at the kiln resulting in case hardened wood -- is there really a difference? Another way to state this: all things being done properly (not too fast drying, no kiln mix-ups causing case hardening, etc) if you are handed two pieces of lumber at the same moisture content (cut from the same tree) one air dried and one kiln dried is there any way to tell the difference. (Let's also skip Walnut/Beech for the moment, I realize the color may be different). In my experience there is no difference in the resultant lumber, all things being equal. Hoadley and the Forest Products Lab seem to agree. Am I missing something? I'm afraid I'm embarrassed if I missed something some claim is much different.
-Dean
yes
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>If white oak grows quickly (3 rings to the inch) or the part you are chopping is near a knot, the stuff is "harder than the hubs of hell", to quote an old timer. On the other hand, white oak that has 20 rings to the inch is as mellow as poplar and about as light. It all has to do with the ratio of spring wood (soft and porous) to summer wood (dense). I have "stalled" flooring nails on especially dense white oak (and that becomes a problem). Some of this oak was so hard I could not push a chisel through it to pare it.
The same is true of walnut. A very slow growth tree will yield less dense and more easily worked wood than a fast growth tree.
the air dried vs KD debate rages on
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>In the case of walnut most of the commercial stuff is steamed and indeed steaming does affect properties because of the high temperature involved. There is some decomposition of the wood in steaming because the smell of furfuraldehyde is readily apparent around the steamer. A good friend that worked millions of feet of walnut at his factory said the steamed walnut machined better. In the case of walnut it is a common mistake for amateur woodworkers to confuse the results of steaming with kiln drying.
For what it is worth, I don't believe there is any detectable difference between KD and air dried wood presuming each is carried to the same moisture level and the KD is done properly. An exception are the conifers where the higher KD temperature sets the sap. It seems to me that the main advocates of air dried wood are those that don't have access to a kiln.
Re: the air dried vs KD debate rages on
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Kiln drying changes the wood chemically by burning or carbonizing some of the sugars that are inherent in wood. The fatty acid constituents of lignin also begin to melt and chemically change as wood is heated above 185�. This is a permanent change to the wood making it harder and more brittle. The excess heat and pressure can also polymerize some of the naturally occurring phenols and other extractives that may alter how the glue will adhere to the wood. Excess heat can cause changes deep within the surface of the wood.
The heating effects some chemicals in the wood causing polymerization or polycondensation (chemical condensation leading to the formation of compounds of higher molecular weights) reducing the ability of the glue to make a good adhesive bond.
Stephen
What are your sources?
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>What are the sources for the material in your response?
The information you provided is at odds with wood engineering data to be found in "The Encyclopedia of Wood, Wood as an Engineering Material" Chapter 4, a publication of the Forest Products Lab, Madison Wisconsin...... presuming the hardwood is dried under typical conditions for the production of commercial lumber. It is clearly stated in the book that property changes with temperature are reversible so long as the wood is not heated well above normal KD temperatures. That is to say, that while many properties of wood degrade at elevated temperature, these changes return to the initial state upon cooling, so long as the wood was not raised to excessive greater than KD temperatures .
Wite Oak
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I have had great success working white oak with a high carbon steel chisel tempered in a home oven. I question the wisdom of using ever more brutal sharpening methods to work ever more nasty steels just to work wood of questionable quality. Some stuff just is not worthwhile for hand work.
As regards white oak, there are more than a half dozen North American species that are marketed as such, some higher quality than others. And even within one species, the differences in individual trees dwarf the differences between kiln dried and air dried.
The same is true for walnut; differences in density and grain are much more pronounced than drying differences. In recent weeks I have used both kiln dried and air dried walnut without worrying about the difference, but I have been very aware of density and other qualities. I have never had steamed walnut.
Re: What are your sources?
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Bill,
What are KD temperatures? Do they vary with different woods?
It is written that Disston seasoned their Applewood for their totes for at least 3 years out in the open. I would guess it was covered though. Then after 3 years the wood was kiln dried. I don't see the advantage for such a long seasoning period if the wood would be kiln dried. Any thoughts on this?
Thanks,
Marv
Re: What are your sources?
Dean J in MN
>Bill
I read that same section, one of the reasons I asked the question. In addition there is a small report* on Air Drying which states:
"In air drying green lumber, the fibers in the outer zones of a
board dry below the fiber saturation point, but their shrinkage
is restrained by the core. A tension set, that is, a permanently
stretched condition, develops in the outer zones. Some com-
pression set�a permanently compressed condition�can
develop in the core. Later when the board is uniformly dry
through its cross section, the drying stresses have reversed.
The outer zones are in compression, and the inner fibers are
in tension. This is a condition known as casehardening. It is
the normal behavior of lumber to undergo stresses as it dries
and to develop tension set. In air drying, a considerable
amount of tension set can be developed in the outer zones of
a board. In air drying, the development of casehardening is
normal and is not considered a defect because it is normally
relieved after kiln drying. "
So it seems to me, if anything air drying is more prone to producing difficult lumber. The assumption above is this initial air drying defect will be fixed in a kiln. I suppose this does contradict my initial statement, it seems if anything KD lumber is more apt to be workable than air dried. I wonder how pronounced this casehardening is in the typical lumber used in the 18th C? (Walnut, Mahogony, white/yellow pine, chestnut, &c)?
-Dean
*General Technical Report FPL-GTR-117 -- page 51
Re: What are your sources?
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>Bill,
First, I don't believe anything that Forest Products Lab reports, it is a governmental agency afterall. And they are largely interested in commercial work and is bias toward the trade. They publish conflicting information all the time. I have references from them, that roughing before gluing works and also that it doesn't. They have no credibility in my eyes.
As for my references, here are a few:
Advanced Wood Adhesive Technology by A. Pizzi - Marcel Dekker, Inc. NY 1994
Handbook of Adhesive Technology by A. Pizzi, K.L. Mittal (ed.) - Marcel Dekker, Inc. NY 1994
Adhesion and Adhesives (ed.) R. Houwink & G. Salomon Vol. 1 & II - Elsevier Publishing Co., Amsterdam 1965 (A. M. Kragh & J. Wootton)
As a luthier about KD v AD.
Stephen
lots of opportunity to screw up.....
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>...either air or kiln drying. That said, what I have seen locally is that KD operations have grown more sophisticated in terms of control of moisture removal and conditioning at the end of the drying to remove any stress that may have crept in. I have been told that our picky European export customers are responsible for this added care (thank you) . Drying is all about precise removal of a certain amount of moisture per unit of time. Question, can that be best done in a temperature and humidity controlled uniformly circulated sealed container (kiln), or outside in the weather?
I've seen air dried oak severely checked and stressed and I've seen KD oak honeycombed. And I have seen fine furniture made from air dried wood and KD wood. So in reality out in the world there is every permutation of "my drying is better than yours".
*****However, lumber dried in a modern kiln operated properly (and with $100,000 of lumber at risk it is a good bet it will be operated properly) is going to be uniform and stress-free and suitable for anything you want to do with dry lumber. ***** It would seem impossible to improve on this claim with any air drying process.
We sold KD lumber for nearly 30 years and never had a board returned because it was unsuitable for use. We purchased from reputable kiln drying operations that sold the bulk of their production to furniture factories. The lumber was good enough to make furniture that had to survive shipping, and use, in all manner of climates. On the other hand, I have seen lots of lumber screwed up in every imaginable way in small custom kilns, but these are not the standard by which to judge the kiln drying process.
As far as Diston, the statement is so rife with BS I don't know where to begin comment. There is no place on earth where it takes 3 years to equillibrate 4/4 lumber to its surroundings (air dry). 3 months will do it in TN.
As far as "days of old" if you have visited museums you will have seen lots of busted up furniture that resulted from its maker not using sufficiently dry wood. And you will have seen stuff that survived fine because it was properly made with properly dried wood. The most common woods used-mahogany, cherry and walnut- are very easy to dry (KD or air) with out problems.
disclaimer and some philosophy for beginners
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>The comment that it was #2 common (30 cents per bd ft at the mill) for something to hold lathe tools should have been a clue that this was not fine furniture. I don't make fine furniture for the shop. In fact I was tempted to buy a tool cabinet but frugality suppressed the urge.
Making something utilitarian is a good place to practice one's skills or test new techniques. My objective, other than getting something to hold tools, was to practice some dovetailing techniques I learned in the Headley shop class I recently took before I forgot what I had been shown. I also wanted to see how fast I could get a case assembled, but some 3 ring per inch boards thwarted that objective.
For the record, 3 ring per inch oak didn't pare easily with a Swan chisel either. On the other hand, soft texture white oak is a joy to work. I have about 1000 bdft cut from veneer logs for my "fine furniture" projects.
Re: What are your sources?
ThomD
>On the touchy feely level, colour certainly changes, with some woods. One can argue that such subtle variations will fade away so fast they are of little concern, but I guess that depends on the user. One also has to be on the lookout for differences. That is an artistic or crafty thing. Let's say one is selling some crudely made crap, it is always possible to find some lowest common denominator upon which everything is the same, and hope that closes the sale. On the other hand, if one's sale depends on finding little distinctions that set one's work apart, then one's mindset will tend to emphasize distinctions. Either approach could be equally preposterous, but when appropriately applied they represent different outlooks. I remember reading this article on Japanese and American cars at the time the K-cars came out. The authors view was that K-cars really were reliable, not unlike better Japanese cars, but that it was too late anyway. He went on to describe all the work the Japanese had put into tuning the exhaust on (I think) the Miyata (?). So sure, on some level the Japanese and American cars were the same, but on another level the Japanese cars were still ahead.
On the more "scientific" front, statements that claim that nothing changes need to be accompanied by statements of what parameters are under consideration. Obviously water content changes, or there would be little reason to dry the wood. That parameter changes several other things like tensile strength, modulus of elasticity, glue absorption, etc... In some formats these are critical factors, to processes, and materials. So broad claims need to be carefully defined. Once these claims are carefully defined it will become clear they are limited, and not comprehensive. The likes of the highly respected FPL have an industrial mandate, and anything they have printed on hand tool working or artistic attributes of wood is likely to be pretty thin. Anyway, government science is hardly the last word these days in the trail of Vioxx, Trovan, et al., or FreddyMac. One has to do more work than site it's existence, and claim it's major conclusions.
Within the technical community it is often conceded that KD affects subsequent capacity to steam bend wood, though some disagree.
KD wood is certainly highly useable for many things. I won't kick it out of bed for leaving sawdust. I have determined through 30 years of empirical evidence that wood air dries more quickly than I can use it up, so KD is not essential to my needs. If it isn't essential it offers no decisive advantage either, uses up resources, and I believe does limit some parameters.