Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Posts

OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#1

OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>mechanical edition.

I bought myself some new tool storage for Christmas (I can get away with storing tools in mechanic's rollaway cabinets here on California's north coast, and I hit the Sears website when just the right one was on deep sale), so I'm rearranging the shop, and realizing that, in the past 10-15 years, I've acquired all the tools I (would) need for things I don't think I'll ever do again, like rebuild a car motor (life list: two or three VW motors, one Studebaker Champion, one Datsun; plus head work on another Datsun. Partial on a BMW motorcycle motor. A lot of work accomplished with vise grips, hose clamps for ring compression, etc.) Time to thin - I've got calls in to my sons, so they can have the tools when they need them, instead of when they don't.

When I needed the resources to keep old machines/equipment going, I was too young and broke to afford the tools to do it right; and now that I have the money to get right tools, I also have the money to get things new enough that I don't need the tools. The silver lining, of course, is that I learned a lot about creative tool use. And this may be a generational thing...I don't talk to too awfully many youngsters who will put up with the clapped-out vehicles and stuff I did in my youth.

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#2

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

ThomD

>It's certainly the case that cars have improved to the point where they last decades with virtually nary a tune-up. But there is lots of other stuff out there that is worse than ever, clothing just for example. I assume Saville row still originates a good suit, but the majority of today's clothing wouldn't have been fit for the help sleeping in the barn in days past, and there are countless similar examples. Most obvious to us would be furniture. Toronto is like many NA cites a place with hardly a house under 1 million, and hardly a stick of furniture (unless antique) that is anything other than a joke.

The younger generation may or not want to mess with stuff. Maybe some would rather wave their hands in the air playing with their Wii (interesting name if you have a British background). My kids seem completely uninterested in my craft interests, but they have plenty of their own. What they really need to get interested in is selling the old man's junk on Craigslist when the time comes!

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#3

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm happier with the clothes from Land's End, very fine cottons and the like, than I've ever been with any other brand.

Pam

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#4

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

ThomD

>Happiness is certainly a point. I find McDonalds occasionally pleasurable, but it isn't Cordon Bleu or mom's home cooking. I remember getting tailored suits when I was a kid, little tweed shorts and jackets. My Dad used to get all his suits tailored and somehow managed to never buy anything off the rack while he was working. This was not a phenomenon of wealth, poor people got tailored clothing, which is more or less what we were, earlier on when this stuff remained available. People talk about quality frabics, but the stuff he got lasted a lifetime, virtually never wore out.

I'm not sure I buy modern claims of quality. Both my mother and particularly my mother in law (who is a retired embroidery writer and the kind of person who travels to evaluate museam collections), are real needle women and knitters in my mom's case. It's like living with a wood person talking about the declining availability of Brazilian Rosewood, hearing about mills that are closing and the complete unavailability of quality threads and fabrics.

Modern manufacturing makes certain new miracle materials available, like carbon fiber; certain high quality processes like CNC machining; But it hasn't made the picking of potatoes a higher quality process. The yields are uneven: Some products are entirely revolutionary like telecomunications advances; some are improved like engines; and some are degraded like fabric and food. Though there are fabrics like kevlar or processes like goretex coated frabrics that represent advances in certain technical areas. The yields just aren't uniform. The end result is that tools and home made stuff remain viable in certain areas (to get back to the OP).

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#5

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hmmmph! I hate eating American fast food (except for some pizzas), those miserable french fries, synthetic cheese, huge prices for what nutrition you do get.

Lands' End, one of a very few, seems to have got most of it right. They do have the plastics; but if you stick to cotton and cashmere, it is quality stuff.

I once, about 20 years ago, had a suit tailor made, beautiful fabric, wonderful fit, I still have it and would wear it if I worked in an office. I think the price well worth it, amortized over 20 years, much cheaper than buying cheap, ill fitting, suits.

I guess I see little point in bemoaning what's no longer there, unless you're (impersonal) going to do something about it.

Pam

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#6

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

ThomD

>I would agree there is probably little point in bemoaning such loss. I do note it though. I find the way the trends unfold is fascinating. Progress isn't uniform, it has given us a lot more convenient phones that quality shoes. I just find it interesting.

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#7

"more convenient phones"

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>but even these come at a price. We have a major service, and live in what is essentially a suburban town of 7,000 people, not terribly hilly country just west of a city of 150,000 or so people (the rural and hilly parts are west of us) - but our cell phone does not work up at the Longs/Lucky's/etc. shopping center, two miles from our house. And it's not uncommon to lose a phone call because of signal issues, or to overhear others having the same problem.

In some ways, cell phones return us to the early 20th century, and remind me why it was common at one time - I'm told - for a Briton to answer the telephone with, "Are you there?" (I have always loved that - the ultimate existential question, with just two possible non-sarcastic responses, "yes" and silence.)

Having said all that: I'm NOT nostalgic for the past. When we first moved back to California in the early 1970's, we were planning to be back to the land purists. After a few years of doing EVERYthing by hand, we modified our purity. I continue to think that some "obsolete" technologies are still more efficient than modern ones, but the modern world does have its benefits.

As I wander ever further off topic...

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#8

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thom and all,

There was a professor a few years back, I can't think of his name at the moment, who won a Nobel prize for detailing the consequences of the fact that goods may be divided into two classes: (1) Those which are subject to declining unit prices due to technological breakthroughs and scale economies of production, versus (2) Those whose professional and labor content is pretty much fixed, and technology gains will make only marginal differences. Class (1) goods will experience falling real prices in a competitive environment, but Class (2) goods' costs (and therefore prices) will continue to escalate with inflation, and competition cannot affect price very much.

So. Cell phones and computers and automobile engines and factory furniture and polyester clothes, to take a few examples, continue to be affordable (he laughingly said). But Class (2) goods like a college education, or a quality grade school education; handsewn shoes or western boots; a close reproduction of Period furniture museum pieces; a traditionally-crafted canoe; or a ticket to an Angela Hewitt Bach concert--the price of all these things will climb and climb because there is no way to reduce the skilled labor content (man-hours) of the folks who produce them, or simply the hours of time required.

You can still buy extremely good shoes. The problem is the price. I love my Danner boots--they're cheap at the price. But the price is high. Like a good many planes, saws, and chisels we're all familiar with.

Wiley

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#9

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Always amazes me how little it takes to win a Nobel prize in Economics (shouldn't they all involve true breakthroughs like Stigliz's creative destruction and Keynes gov't spending?). However, very good point, until and unless we have so many unemployed that people are willing to work for a lot less, often called deflation, in which case all bets are off.

Pam

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#10

Yeah.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#12

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Todd Hughes

>I buy all my clothing at second hand shops and at the flea market...can't think of the last time I bought somthing new for myself. I am very picky about what I get and only buy quality name brand clothing, most saw only very minimal wear if any.I have bought many times stuff like LL Bean shirts or jackets for under $5 somtimes still with the tags. I wear lots of older vintage stuff too and have a weakness for Stetson Fedoras and 1940s hats.

...I have a hard time understanding why people would pay more, tell you the truth I wouldn't enjoy wearing them knowing I paid more then I had too.

A little funny but I do buy new stuff for girlfriends and it doesn't bother me. Bought a friend a new Abricome & Fitch coat off of ebay for her birthday [ then she had it stolen a month later at a party !], also got her a new pair of converse Grateful Dead sneakers for christmas after much looking in many shoe stores. Then of course theres Victoria Secret.

But when it comes to me I guess quality and price is more important to me then it being new....Todd

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#13

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Modern manufacturing makes certain new miracle materials available, like carbon fiber; certain high quality processes like CNC machining; But it hasn't made the picking of potatoes a higher quality process. The yields are uneven..

Sounds to me like the Industrial Revolution continueth. Only ever more refined. With labour costs a dominating factor in increasing overall profit, the focus is still on what may be manufactured with less labour. And then there is the increasing sophistication of targeting your audience. Give them what the target audience wants (or convince the target audience that this is what they want) - unfortunately, the this target audience does not happen to share our/my values of what is considered desireable. This is likely to encourage an ever increasing cycle of planned obselescence since there is no place for long term ownership in this scheme of things.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#14

Hmmm... It appears Todd's...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Showing his wings!

Scary, If ones mind wonders...

:^)

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#15

I do love these wandering discussions

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>I have observed before - possibly even here* - that those of us who frequent thrift stores particularly, and also garage/estate sales, get the great deals we do primarily because of the many people who buy new and don't "make do." LOML, who works in the local Hospice thrift store, comments regularly on the number of clothing items that come in brand spanking new, often with the store tags still on them. Now granted, some of these are estate cleanups, donations from families who are clearing out the house after someone passed away, and whose deceased relative bought with unwarranted optimism about his/her life expectancy. But many are donated by people who bought clothes, never wore them, and are not about to wear last year's item. We get last year's item for $2-3, and wear it until it's ready for the rag bag. However, if everyone were more like us, we wouldn't be getting those deals - and prices new might be higher, since the manufacturers would be making fewer units of whatever.

To some degree, the same issue exists with hand tools, though the argument gets more complex in this realm, since there are arguably differences between older and new tools.

*With age comes intermittent memory, with mixed results: joy to the possessor (like me), who can find new delight in telling the same story each time; despair to the listeners, who are condemned to hear the same tedious stuff over and over again. If I've made this observation before here, I beg forgiveness.

Re: OT - the irony of tool acquisition

#16

Correction

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>On the off chance that someone here may quote me, it was Joseph Schumpeter, not Joseph Stigliz, who won the Nobel for his theory of creative destruction.

Pam