Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Posts

Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#1

Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Tom Colligan

>A very knowledgeable friend, who's a machinist and works with heat treating companies, said the reason a new chisel will chip is probably because it was sharpened and then sent for heat treating, when the sharpening should be done afterward.

Does this seem correct and is likely the reason a new chisel's good steel isn't for another 1/2" or so back? TIA, Tom.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#2

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

ThomD

>That's a well known phenomenon, though it isn't absolutely necessary that it occur that way. There can be a differential heat treating that occurs during the quench most commonly. The geometry is finer at the edge and furthest from heat that may be retained in the body of the tool that would draw some of the temper after the tool is removed from the quenchant. There can be chemical changes due to oxide formation in the steel not properly ground back. There are a lot of potential things that can happen.

I doubt any tool maker sharpens the tools before heat treatment though, or even grinds them particularly fine. It is a well known fact that the edge has to be ground back after heat treatment, otherwise the edge will spilt or burn up during HT. In fact the grinding back can cause HT to happen in the post grind phase. most tools are ground by hand, and that can lead to inconsistency, so mistakes can happen.

Another thing to keep in mind is that the back of the chisel is there for good, so it never gets ground back, only the bevel. Or at least it doesn't get substantially ground back in the early going so the phenomenon of the tool improving in early use is not fully explained. though even removing the bad steel from the bevel side would help.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#3

no.

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Thom is right. I don't think anyone would do that. And I don't think it's the reason why chisels chip.

The fracture mechanics of an edge tool is really really complicated. I wouldn't trust a machinist to understand a woodworking tool because what we do with our tools is so different enough from what machinists do.

BTW, lest anyone misunderstand me, I don't understand the fracture mechanics of a chisel edge and don't know anyone who does. It's not like a cure for cancer, but it's close. If your neighbor the butcher said he knew how to cure cancer, you'd probably be skeptical and that's where I am on this issue.

Decarburization could explain the phenomenon you describe. The exact technique used for quench could as well.

Possibly not unrelated, I've heard many many folks complain about their LN chisels chipping. From what I've read on the internet, I think a few sets were sent back. But suspect had folks just been patient and ground a bit more off (or better yet, just used them and sharpened them) they would have found better performance.

Here's what I can tell you about edge chipping:

-The degree of polish makes a big difference.

-The orientation of the scratches (side honing versus front to back) makes a difference on paper. Scratch sizes being equal, front to back should be better. But the level to which most of us hone may make this issue moot.

-Bevel angle makes a big difference

-Beyond the bevel angle, the shape of the bevel should, on paper, effect edge retention. A rounded smooth, elliptical shape should be best. Again, we may have trouble seeing this in our shops.

-Usage makes a big difference. Obviously avoid certain prying and malleting techniques will effect edge retention. But also I think a guy like Warren Mickley is more sensitive to his edge than I am. I think he stops and hones sooner, and retains his edges better.

Assigning specific metallurgical properties to "solve" edge chipping is more art than science. If it were science, everyone would do the same thing and all chisels would be made of the same alloy and would be tempered the same.

As it is a soft chisel can chip or a hard chisel can chip. A chisel between hard and soft can chip. Low C steels chip, but so do high C steels. The chief advantage of super high C steels is that they can achieve higher hardnesses. The questions I have are:

1) Is harder really better (by harder I mean over 62Rc)?

2) If you temper a super high C (1%+ of C, to 60 Rc, does it offer any advantage over a lower C steel?)

So Tom, this is a complicated subject with no easy answers. I hope what I've offered here is more help than hurt.

Adam

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#4

Re: no.

Bob Demers

>The more I learn about this stuff the more I reach for my aspirin bottle :-)

Seriously, Adam is bang on, metallurgy is a very complex subject, full of conjectures.

All I know is that I like my edges sharp, some seems to last longer than other, but nevertheless, I stop and stop often.

Chipping never seems to be a problem for me, except when someone else uses my tools....grumble grumble, now where did I put that bottle again?

Bob

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#5

more no, and why

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>After heat treating the tool will be black, or at least anything I have sent out comes back black. So if it was sharpened before heat treating the bevel would not be bright. See example in bottom two chisels that were heat treated before sharpening.

There are a multitude of reasons why sharpening first would be fatally flawed. I was told by the heat treater that about 0.003" of steel is compromised by the heat treat process and this amount must be removed from both sides of the tool to get to steel of uncompromised properties.

If the tool is chipping the steel is not tough enough for the angle at which it is ground. (toughness is a measure of whether the steel breaks or bends under load). Steel varies in toughness (a lot) depending on its composition and heat treat history.


img

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#6

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Todd Hughes

>...Pretty simple and no mumbo jumbo... The reason is because the edge is to hard. The reason it is to hard is because it got to hot. The reason it got to hot is that it wasn't hardened or tempered correctly. I doubt if it was sharpened befor it was heat treated but even if not sharpened it is easy for the outside edge to get to hot because less mass. Think about it...when somthing like this is heated up the outside edges and surface heats up first and then the heat moves inward. If heated up to fast and to hot the outside edge will get over heated befor the center gets hot enough. Put a frozen burrita in the oven for 5 min. and the outside edges and ends will be hot while the inside is frozen still

I imagine these chisels are heated up in mass and automaticaly and if not carefull and done to fast they get to hot on the ends. The reason that you can grind back to good steel is because you are grinding back into the steel that was heated to the proper temperture in the heat treatment.

... If the chisel maker has a quailty control process this problem probably wouldn't show up because they probably harden the entire chisel the same [or should say they are thinking they are!] and then just check the center of the chisel...Don't know but just speculating on this now....Todd

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#7

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>How did you avoid these edge heat treating problems when you were making tools?

Pam

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#8

Re: Heat treating in a forge

Dave Mount

>Hi Pam--

Not to answer for Todd, but you can control the heating of a workpiece in a forge by where you place it in the fire. If you thrust a cold piece with a thin edge into the hottest part of the forge right off, you can imagine what happens. However, you can bring temp up more evenly by heating initially toward the perimeter of the fire and working the piece closer to the center more gradually.

Tempering brings the opposite problem as it is easy to over-temper (soften) thin edges. In traditional smithing this was sometimes managed by applying heat primarily on the thicker part of the tool, then quenching after the heat chases down to the thinner parts. The hardness of a tool thus tempered may vary across its length because it reached different temperatures in this process. I recall having heard mention of joiners bringing their tools back to the smith to have them re-tempered, which I think is related to this.

For most woodworking tools, the tempering temperatures for O1 are within the range of a home oven, so that's where I do mine. This is easier to manage in that since you set the oven at the desired temperature, you can avoid tempering problems at the edge by letting the whole piece come to the same ambient temp, as compared to achieving the tempering heat by shorter application of a much higher temp. I believe, but don't know for certain, that professional heat treaters also use well-controlled ovens and rely more on equilibrium than kinetics. However, since time is money, they may round some corners as Todd suggests (just speculating).

My $0.02, we'll see if Todd agrees. . .

Dave

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#9

And you can do cryo treatment

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>just by putting a tool on your front porch, right - at least in Minnesota in January?

Ducking and running...

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#10

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Todd Hughes

>You need to heat the piece up slow, keep it under conrol and watch that it doesn't get to hot in the wrong places. Take in account what the item is and then manipulate it in the fire so that the right parts get the right temperture....Modst Important...Think about what you are trying to accomplish

I would forge a knife blade to about 95% to shape, so it had a thin cutting edge and a thick back befor I heated it up to harden it...OK,now you might think I would put the blade in with the back to the fire so it would heat up first since it is thicker,..right? NO. Since I wanted a blade with a soft back and a hard cutting edge I would put it in edge down and heat it up slow watching that the edge doesn't get to hot and turning it a little to heat the back up just a bit and to control the edges heat which was the part I was worried about. I used to paint clay on my blades with the heavier clay on the back which accomplished the same thing. Became to tedious and learned if careful and with experance I didn't need the clay to do this ...to get a soft back and hard edge...if I just manipulated the blade in the fire bringing it to the correct color

Now machines can be wonderful things and Im a slow head for sure but Im still waiting to see one that would be able do this. At a factory they have to heat the entire blade up and get it to an even temperture since they can't give it the individual attention I could.

This is simple common sense stuff for the most part and no mumbo jumbo mystery. Just need some experance and get out and try it. Believe me if I could do it anybody could.....Todd

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#11

Re: Never thought about that. . .drifting OT

Dave Mount

>Now Bill, despite how California has thinned your skin, you should remember that even here in MN most of the nitrogen stays in gaseous form all winter.

In the winter of 1995-1996 most of Minnesota set all time low temps (for any day, not just one day). The lowest of the lows was set an hour or so north of here in Embarrass, MN at -60 F (that's actual temperature, not wind chill; word was it was -70 F in a low area not far from the official recording station). The lowest I saw on our thermometer was -52 F, but I have no idea if the thermometer is even accurate at that temp (I had to extrapolate beyond -40 F where the gradations on the thermometer ended). As you know, Minnesotans generally take some pride in being rather stoic about the cold, but this was different -- people just started getting goofy. The day before, they were saying it was possible the record could fall. Bunches of people packed up their winter camping gear and headed toward all the known cold spots to so they could say they slept outside on the coldest night in Minnesota history (like that was something other than a badge of documented lunacy). The local weatherman put a banana outside and pounded a nail with it during his newscast. Others put tomatoes outside and then smashed them on the concrete to watch them shatter like glass. All those 7-grade acetone/dry ice tricks except you could just do them with the ambient air.

It was only -15 F here this morning, but the wind was blowing so it was a little raw. It's amazing to see the horses stand out in that (albeit in a sheltered area) even though they have free access to the barn (and if there were flies out, they'd be in the barn in a second). Much colder/windier and we shut them in against their will, but I've become convinced that they don't feel the cold in the same way that we might imagine. Long as they're not wet, you can stick your fingers down in their coat and it's pretty warm in there. You wonder though about their feet, noses, and lips, though we've never had a horse have any frostbite-type problems, even from that record cold night in 1996. We did just adopt a stray cat though that has one ear considerably shorter than the other, which has the characteristics of a previous case of frostbite.

Got off work early today and I'm rambling at the mouth. Pretty soon someone from Winnipeg will chime in and tell us about real cold -- that's where our cold air comes from.

Best,

Dave

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#12

not normally the case unless forge made

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If it was heat treated at a commercial establishment it is done in a temperature controlled furnace. Unlike at a forge, the metal heats to the furnace temperature and the stuff is left to heat until everything gets to the furnace temperature.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#13

drifting further OT...in warmer climes

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>like southeastern Michigan, where I also lived for a while, we used to put apple cider jugs on the porch. Something about the alternate freezing/warming cycles encouraged the fermentation, while keeping it from turning to vinegar quite so quickly. Great stuff, when I was young.

I have to say, though, a cold Detroit area day is COLD - the moisture from the lake drops the temp considerably, compared to dry St. Paul.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#14

Thanks, Dave.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#15

Re: drifting further OT...in warmer climes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>And all our friends wondered why we moved from MA to Texas. :)

Pam

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#16

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Very interesting. Blacksmiths are magic.

Also interesting to hear that you back hard tool steel with soft steel, just like the Japanese. :)

Pam

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#17

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

ThomD

>The simple answer, Pam, is that you forge (or heat treat) thick and grind thin. You can forge in the bevel and do a lot of shaping, but enough thickness has to be left there to be wasted during the final grinding process. How much will depend on the process and steel.

Modern heat treating ovens probably don't control the heat any better than a blacksmith does. Heat control is only part of it anyway. A modern advance is the ability to do the heat treating in a controlled atmosphere with an inert gas piped into the forge so that oxidation is impossible, and that would be more effective than heat control, which is not a difficult issue for many steels.

There are all sorts of ways of doing the same thing in the forge from thick to thin where the outer layer of steel is the shield, to using stainless foils, clay slips, etc... One thing I do is use a reducing flame in the forge. I set the propane burner so it has slightly more uncombusted propane in the flame than I could, this creates heat without abundant oxygen, and it tends to pull oxide out of the steel, rather than "burn" it. I imagine there are similar combustion conditions in a coal fire.

This is all pretty baby stuff. It might be analogous to first learning that a wood surface is not at it's most perfect when finished over the ripples left by the planer, or a sanding. A person might experiment with a hand planed finish. You can take that experiment very far, but once exposed to the possibilities, it doesn't take any great skill to get aboard the train. It isn't a master's turn to avoid the most gross errors in a craft.

Worth thinking of knives on two fronts:

1) they are very thin compared to tools; hardened over a wide area not just the end, as can be done effectively on woodworking tools; yet the whole knife can be well heat treated, few knives are ground back to get to the good steel, they are rarely sharpened that much.

2) Also worth keeping in mind that of the greatest blades made, the vast majority would have been made, and continue to be made entirely over an open forge.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#18

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Thom, all sorts of tricks to employ, very clever.

Pam

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#19

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

ThomD

>"few knives are ground back to get to the good steel, they are rarely sharpened that much"

Just to be clear, they are forged or HTd thick and ground back to final dimension, what I was getting at is they need to work from the get go. There are some chisels that get better as they are ground back from how they were delivered from the factory, but few knives ever get that much altered in the users hands. I am gobsmacked to read that guys on the knife boards are sending them back to the factory/distributor to get them sharpened!

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#20

Re: drifting further OT...in warmer climes

David Cockey

>I'll take cold over heat any day, particularly heat and humidity. In the winter I just put more clothes on, in the summer there is a limit to how much I can take off, even if modesty/decency isn't an issue.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#21

Well, OK. Enjoy shovelling that snow. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#22

Re: not normally the case unless forge made

ThomD

>"Unlike at a forge, the metal heats to the furnace temperature and the stuff is left to heat until everything gets to the furnace temperature."

Forge is basically the same, if the steel needs to soak at a given temp it can be held there. No doubt that for certain complex steels with complex heat treating profiles, some requiring long periods at a given heat it is more efficient to do those kinds of things in an electric oven than a forge. But it's also true that those steels aren't all that common in the hand tool world. I know some of the folk around here don't like the mythologizing about the black arts, but we can be equally guilty of mythmaking on the science front. Consider the following:

- There seems to be a tendency to talk about "forges" vs. temperature controlled furnaces, like there are two extremes. Joe blacksmith vs. Joe labcoat. The average guy making say swords, might have a forge for welding, a forge for drawing out, a forge for hardening, and a barrel forge/saltpot etc... for hardening and one for tempering. For instance I have a propane forge specifically built for hardening plane blades. I have wanted to make a 6" wide Japanese plane blade since I saw one in NH in the 70s. If I ever get around to it I will probably build a custom forge for that. Coal forges also vary a lot, but they can also be varied simply by repiling the coke, etc...

- Also the whole "temperature controlled" thing sounds great but it isn't a big deal. There are instructibles on building electric furnaces for heat treating, on the web; they can be bought relatively cheaply either new, but craigslist has tons of temperature controlled kilns from 50 bucks up, that I have seen people get in and out of pottery fairly regularly. There are also home made contraptions, like super heat salt solution pots that are extremely refined in effect and are regularly thrown together by Joe blacksmith. Propane forges can also have heat controls installed, on them. Now that the cost of Asian K thermocouples is basically zero, one can accurately measure heats up to 2000 degrees in a gas forge also. This has always been possible with cheap stuff like temple sticks and cones.

- There are also reliable blacksmith tech things that allow careful heat control. This becomes steel and project specific, but there are lots of trick to the trade that are very reliable. There are also some clever quality control tricks for assessing exactly what you got, the brass rod trick being one such example.

- Knife makers do use heat treating services, particularly for stainless. But the modern heat treatment facilities are not designed to supply woodworkers or even knifemakers, and the results aren't always encouraging. For instance, when I bought some Barr chisels, I managed to get in on a deal where he sent some of the chisels out for chryo treatment, very high tech. Guess which chisels broke in the ferule! The key to quality is someone with the right objectives, and a relentless desire to improve their product through realistic testing. I had mixed emotions on the Chryo thing when I signed up for it, because I knew it wasn't always that wonderfully successful with knives. Interesting test though, and I think it speaks volumes that knifemakers had bought the gear to try it out themselves and that I had heard about those tests decades ago. It speaks volumes that they will try whatever it takes, but the answers generally don't come from the lab coat sector which is designed to serve wider industry. I'm not a Luddite, The better equipped heat treating labs could probably wax the home shop blacksmith if they wanted to, but that is not their role. They are the amateurs in the custom cutlery and tools field. If they wanted to burn up all their money pursuing quality blades they could probably show us all something, it just isn't what they do. It's like asking Ikea to take the leadership in the Federal furniture reproduction game. Given ten years they could probably show us something.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#23

custom heat treating sources readily available

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you move in the knife making circles I am surprised you have not heard of Paul Bos.Heat Treating. His facility will heat treat any steel. I could only find my old price list, but for example, in 2003 his rates were $70 for up to 20 pieces and $3.50 for each additional, or $14 for just one piece.

Additionally, we have used two other heat treaters and their charge was about $50 for 20 pounds (again somewhat dated prices). In all these cases we could submit any steel and have it heat treated according to any schedule we selected. Such service is not unexpected. While Bos caters particularly to knife makers, the other places are there to provide custom heat treating to machine shops making dies or what ever. For them, a plane iron is not different than what they might get from a machine shop. Any machine shop will have a place to get heat treating done.

The bottom line is that getting steel heat treated is no impediment to making custom tools, or knives, or machine parts. When we described what the parts to be treated were the treater volunteered that the product would need to be straight and that they would straighten the material as part of the process (what ever that entailed). In any case, stuff came back flat and at the hardness we specified.

Re: Chipping At The Edge of A Tool

#24

Re: custom heat treating sources readily available

ThomD

>I've heard of Paul Bos, and as you say, at least for people doing a certain minimal volume of HT it's reasonably cheap and easy to send their stuff out to him. This raises the obvious question of why if that service is skilled, widely known and cheap, doesn't everyone send their stuff out? At one end of the scale the HT is simple, so simple it wouldn't be worth the packaging up, and at other extreme they can't do what is wanted.

To take a similar example from the wood finishing field, I can't really compete with the factory that sprays a hard finish on pre-finished flooring or plywood. But they can't compete with the small shop guy doing French polishing or decorative painting. At the end of the day there will probably be more collectors pursuing hand finished pieces by George Nakashima, than collecting pieces of pre-finished ply from Home Depot, no mater how fancy the factory that produced it.