Re: not normally the case unless forge made
ThomD
>"Unlike at a forge, the metal heats to the furnace temperature and the stuff is left to heat until everything gets to the furnace temperature."
Forge is basically the same, if the steel needs to soak at a given temp it can be held there. No doubt that for certain complex steels with complex heat treating profiles, some requiring long periods at a given heat it is more efficient to do those kinds of things in an electric oven than a forge. But it's also true that those steels aren't all that common in the hand tool world. I know some of the folk around here don't like the mythologizing about the black arts, but we can be equally guilty of mythmaking on the science front. Consider the following:
- There seems to be a tendency to talk about "forges" vs. temperature controlled furnaces, like there are two extremes. Joe blacksmith vs. Joe labcoat. The average guy making say swords, might have a forge for welding, a forge for drawing out, a forge for hardening, and a barrel forge/saltpot etc... for hardening and one for tempering. For instance I have a propane forge specifically built for hardening plane blades. I have wanted to make a 6" wide Japanese plane blade since I saw one in NH in the 70s. If I ever get around to it I will probably build a custom forge for that. Coal forges also vary a lot, but they can also be varied simply by repiling the coke, etc...
- Also the whole "temperature controlled" thing sounds great but it isn't a big deal. There are instructibles on building electric furnaces for heat treating, on the web; they can be bought relatively cheaply either new, but craigslist has tons of temperature controlled kilns from 50 bucks up, that I have seen people get in and out of pottery fairly regularly. There are also home made contraptions, like super heat salt solution pots that are extremely refined in effect and are regularly thrown together by Joe blacksmith. Propane forges can also have heat controls installed, on them. Now that the cost of Asian K thermocouples is basically zero, one can accurately measure heats up to 2000 degrees in a gas forge also. This has always been possible with cheap stuff like temple sticks and cones.
- There are also reliable blacksmith tech things that allow careful heat control. This becomes steel and project specific, but there are lots of trick to the trade that are very reliable. There are also some clever quality control tricks for assessing exactly what you got, the brass rod trick being one such example.
- Knife makers do use heat treating services, particularly for stainless. But the modern heat treatment facilities are not designed to supply woodworkers or even knifemakers, and the results aren't always encouraging. For instance, when I bought some Barr chisels, I managed to get in on a deal where he sent some of the chisels out for chryo treatment, very high tech. Guess which chisels broke in the ferule! The key to quality is someone with the right objectives, and a relentless desire to improve their product through realistic testing. I had mixed emotions on the Chryo thing when I signed up for it, because I knew it wasn't always that wonderfully successful with knives. Interesting test though, and I think it speaks volumes that knifemakers had bought the gear to try it out themselves and that I had heard about those tests decades ago. It speaks volumes that they will try whatever it takes, but the answers generally don't come from the lab coat sector which is designed to serve wider industry. I'm not a Luddite, The better equipped heat treating labs could probably wax the home shop blacksmith if they wanted to, but that is not their role. They are the amateurs in the custom cutlery and tools field. If they wanted to burn up all their money pursuing quality blades they could probably show us all something, it just isn't what they do. It's like asking Ikea to take the leadership in the Federal furniture reproduction game. Given ten years they could probably show us something.