Listen to Thom and John
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Tom and all,
Here's a hard-earned lesson (several times over): If one is new to something, do it the way it is always done until experience is gained. What I have learned the hard way is that things are done as they are for a reason, and this is true for the details and ornament as well as the main joins, Usually more than one reason.
Specific example: You might do OK with soft maple, bleached. But my experience with thin strings of soft maple is that it got like mush, and quickly, when driven into the hot glue; also was prone to breaking if not handled very carefully. Because the wet strings did not have much strength, I really only had one shot, and if the fit was a little off, pulling it out and rehandling it was very high risk. I will admit in that project I was not using a thicknesser--which is a must by the way--and sometimes my micrometer checking overlooked a fat place which balked on me at a critical moment. Also my strings were slightly under 1/16"--if you're using heavier strings the strength issue might not be there.
The reason I was using the soft maple was that I had some really white-looking pieces on hand for drawer sides and the like. Soft maple will tend to be whiter than hard maple (IME). But. Once the strings were installed, I noticed that there were fine streaks of color surfacing here and there. I didn't notice those flecks before the strings were installed and the glue and finish hit them. The strings did not finish out nearly as clean as I expected.
I shoulda used holly. It is stronger, finer grained, and a cleaner white. If your overall methods are better than mine, you might get soft maple to work. But I suspect the bleaching will weaken it, and I wonder if the bleach treatment will last, and also if it will finish out as clear as you hope. Small color variations jump out more at you in a thin string than they do in a larger board.
I think if I were going to bleach something, it would be hard maple, hoping that at least it will handle well, and hoping that I could get the yellow out of it. But. With holly you don't have to hope.
Just my 2 cents Tom. I know this sounds preachy, but I just want to convey one of my (many) screwups, so you and others can be guided by it.
Wiley