Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

tenon correction

Posts

tenon correction

#1

tenon correction

chichi

>If I follow all of the good advice given below and still screw up, what is the best method for correcting uneven shoulders?

Thanks,

Bob

Re: tenon correction

#2

Re: tenon correction

MikeW

>Hi Bob,

Ideally, the rail or apron is of consistent thickness at the area of marking out the tenon. However, if you carefully measure from the end of the tenon for marking out both faces where the shoulders are and connect the two marks across the thickness, you should be fine as regards a line which goes around the workpiece.

If the workpiece is of reasonably consistent thickness, using one edge to mark out will result in a fairly accurate set of lines around the piece if the square is used as per the other thread.

Having a square which is square enough is a plus. Check yours. Use some scrap to test the method(s) mentioned. If you measure down from the end--which itself is cut square or shot square--and you cannot connect the lines, either your stock is not square or the square isn't.

Creating the V-groove will provide a place for the saw. More importantly is that if the saw cuts at a slope away from the shoulder onto the tenon face, the delineated shoulders from the V-groove will provide the reference to pare down to the tenon face.

Using a shoulder planes can work, but is much too fiddly and depends to a greater degree on square stock.

Take care, Mike

Re: tenon correction

#3

Re: tenon correction--Long, Boring

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bob,

"What is the best method to correct uneven shoulders?"

First off, we've all been there, Bob. Nobody was born making perfect tenon shoulders. Even the demo people.

It sounds like this is the first tenon you're putting on that stick--is that right? Is the stick long enough that you can move up the stick a little ways and start over, or is the stick the exact length you require, and you have to save this tenon as close to your marks as possible? I ask this, because I've been where you are, and most of the time it's best to start over, get the taper out of the stick, and do it again. Saving an uneven tenon is nasty work. First thing before proceeding is check your square.

FIND OUT WHAT IS WRONG

The stick likely has a taper or very slight convexity/concavity along the length. You don't necessarily need to untaper or square the stick--the problem may or may not affect your ability to use the stick--but you do need to know what's going on with the stick before making a decision what to do. For me, the problem usually is that there is taper along the length of the stick, or else there is ever so slight of a narrowing or widening at the end you're tenoning.

Do 2 tests. First, take a combination square or a hook rule and check the stick's width along the length, and see if you have a taper that is throwing your marks askew. It doesn't take much to throw off tenon shoulders. Second, take the stick and put it edgewise on something flat. Often a level will do, if you have nothing else flat (granite plate is best). See if the stick rocks on its edge along the length, or else has a concavity (check for daylight). Also, just check whether the stick is square in section, and check by sight whether it is twisting.

DECISION TIME

At this point you will know what the problem is. You also know what your application is. If this is a rail in a frame and panel, then you better four-square the stick--take out all taper, curvature, out of squareness, etc. On the other hand, if this is an apron tenoned into two legs, you may be able to let a little taper go, by placing the taper on the free edge (at the bottom, and squaring the shoulders against the top edge which will mate with the case top. Mark the reference edge and face and proceed with that knowledge. Either correct the stick, or else live with the stick as is and correct the tenon only.

CORRECTING THE TENON

If you have enough length in the stick, just move up stick and start over.

But suppose you have to save this particular sawing as best as possible. Then you have to find the lowest corner of the tenon. Bring new marks from the reference edge down both faces to discover which is the low corner. Use the technique that Mike Wenzloff described. Once you find the low corner, and have brought new lines from the reference edge to that corner, then it is a matter of trimming 3 or 4 sides of the stick back to your new marks. Caution: if you have left taper in the stick, then any check made from the non-reference edge will be cattywompus to the 'correct' marks--make no checks whatever from the non-reference edge.

Clamp the stick in a vise or on the benchtop so that it is coming out of the bench at you. Take a shoulder plane and start trimming back to your new marks. Rest the shoulder plane on the existing tenon for support. Pitfall: You will spelch the exit side of the shoulder. So work the plane from both edges in to the middle. If you insist on planing off the edge of the shoulder, then clamp some support to the edges. A spelched shoulder is more visible than a small gap (after you undercut).

Don't do one face 100%, and go to the next. Make corrections progressively and work around the stick. If you recheck for square, make sure you are doing what Mike said, and always coming from the reference edge, with the stock of the square in the same orientation.

NOTE: On small sticks, it is possible to do the above with a chisel instead of a shoulder plane. If you are truly good with a chisel, OK. But remember, if you make a full length chisel cut on a face, you are also cutting into one or both edges--this can lead to overnibbling. DAMHIKT. That's why I suggest shoulder plane. BTW, no problem with a big shoulder plane--the mass is good. Just rest it on the tenon as you work.

VIRTUES OF STARTING OVER

Because of the misery of doing the above, it is usually better IME to either correct taper and move up the stick and start over, or else prepare a new stick and start over.

Wiley

Re: tenon correction

#4

Re: tenon correction--Long, Boring

chichi

>Wiley,

Thanks for the comprehensive reply.If I dont figure out the cause and solution,I may go electric.

Bob