Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

tenon shoulder problems/correction

Posts

tenon shoulder problems/correction

#1

tenon shoulder problems/correction

chichi

>I cannot seem to get the shoulder of my tenons in alignment. If the inside shoulder shows a slight gap, I may let it go but not the face shoulder. I try to be careful in layout. I use a marking knife and a machinist sq.. I score the shoulder line on the face, keep the knife in the scored line to register the square for the line across one edge, I repeat at the other edge then flip the board and join the two edge lines across the second face. Even during layout, I am sometimes the width of a score line off and try to fiddle all four sides into alignment. I then make a deeper score line across a face, pare out a slight shoulder on which to rest to start the saw. I start at the far end on the face, lower the blade into the score line using the shoulder for alignment. Flip piece over and do same. After the cut, about 50% of the time one shoulder higher than the other, maybe the thickness of the saw blade or slightly more.

Until I get this rigt the first time, what is the best way to correct? I have seen demo's doing it correcly but none showing what to do to correct errors.

I could score two new face lines slightly lower than the first set of shoulders and do both shoulders again hoping for better results .If tooclose to the first shoulder, very difficult to saw. Or, I could attempt to pare the high shoulder down. Should I score a line across the face with the high shoulder,(hard to get a blade to score a line close to the old shoulder)and then use a thin chisel to pare?

I bought a good shoulder plane and could use that , but with only say a 1/4in. deep shoulder, the sole of the plane has little bearing surface on which to ride and taking a precise amount across the length of the shoulder is no easy task. Plus, it seems like you can only do half the length and then you must plane from the opposite edge to avoid blowing out a piece of the edge if the plane travels to the outside(opposite ) edge. Or, I could try kerfing in the shoulder but I have never had much success with that technique plus the set on the saw chews up the face of the piece with the mortise.

This should not be so hard. I am reasonably well coordinated and can be careful in my procedure.I actually think I do better just sawing down the scored line without first making a notched shoulder to guide the saw. I am going to recheck my square, I have dropped it several times.I believe the stock is square. I was using 7/8 thick stock so I do not think any deviation from square would cause that much error?

Thanks for any advice. Sorry for long message.

Bob

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#2

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Marc planing on cold and dry Christmas

>Hi Bob,

It sounds that you're pretty near. Just one thing I'd check. You say:

"...I repeat at the other edge then flip the board and join the two edge lines across the second face..."

You should finish the shoulder marking by using a square on the reference edge. This last marking must join the opposite edge's marking line, the square held on the edge. If it doesn't your stock isn't square and you will have a gap.

Marc

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#3

Addition

Marc in Luxembourg

>Or if the stock is square - just look with a light under a straightedge, a bump in the length of the stock can make a square pivoting and make the shoulder lines not meet.

Marc

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#4

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I mark all the way around with a knife, going very lightly to non-existent on the top and bottom, use a chisel to cut a V in the waste for the saw to sit in, then cut. The other thing I do is to undercut the shoulder line very slightly, which seems to let it snug up nicely.

Pam

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#5

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Charlie

>Try undercutting the shoulders very slightly - only a few degrees.

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#6

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Charlie

>Edit: I misread your problem.

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#7

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

MikeW

>Good Christmas morning to you Bob.

I was taught to use the reference edge to mark both faces. And, to have the square's body facing the same direction down the stock.

As I generally suck at illustration, I'll try a description.

Tenon to be defined to my right at all times. Square's body always to my left. Reference edge towards me for the first face, scribe the line acroass the reference face. Scribe the line down the reference edge (which is nearest to me). Flip the stock over. With my square on the far side, scribe the back face. Bring the square to the last edge and connect the lines.

Hopefully that is clear...

Take care, Mike

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#8

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Howard Pollack

>Having struggled with this problem myself I've found that the most common problem, assuming that you work off of a reference face as described above, is that the stock is not truly square. -Howard

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#9

I second this notion

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>If the stock isn't truly square, the gap can look like the grand canyon.

Bruce, who just finished fitting tenons on a pair of mission night stands

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#10

Re: I second this notion

William R. Drylie

>Assuming your stock is square, I use the following mental trick to keep myself out of trouble. Thumb on body of square against near edge, scribe face. Rotate stock scribed face facing you. Again, thumb on body of square aginst near face, scribe edge. Rotate stock scribed edge facing you. Fingers on body of stock against far edge, scribe face. Rotate stock again, same direction. Fingers on body of stock against far face, scribe final edge. I try to follow this method each time. I also set my knife in the previous scribe each time and bring the square's blade to it each time.

Bill

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

#11

Re: tenon shoulder problems/correction

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Chichi,

The trick is to pick one edge or corner and reference off that corner for all four sides.

If the stock is not square, it will be the other two lines that will be off. The amount they are off will show up at the diagonal corner from the reference corner.

Without making lines on the other two sides, just make a fine mark on the diagonal corner where the last two lines would have come together. Now pick the center point between those two marks and then make your line from that center mark back to the lines on the first two lines you made.

Now if your square isn't exactly square, none of the above will work.

Marv