Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

Posts

Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#1

Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Attached drawer backs? DT's locked rebates?

This inquiry needs to know. So he can continue with his project.

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#2

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene... *LINK*

Stew Pharis

>I believe that the only example of dovetailed drawers can be found in the Thorsen House furniture. I think the most common joint was a rabetted tongue and groove. Bob Lang has a discussion of drawer joinery in his excellent book of Greene & Greene shop drawings. I included a link to Bob's book below.


http://www.craftsmanplans.com/GreeneAndGreene.htm

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#3

Beckerdite article *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Scott,

These details are tough to find, because the docents usually aren't going to let you look.

It may be that Bob Lang's excellent Greene & Greene shop drawings book covers this, and I'll check when I get upstairs.

In the meantime, the link below is to what is known amongst Greene and Greeners as the Beckerdite article. He discusses numerous details. If you will scroll down to the 11th long paragraph, which starts out "The chiffonier for the Gamble master bedroom...", the author is discussing some joinery details. In regard to the famous chiffonier's drawer construction, he says that the drawer backs were simply butted against the inside of the drawer sides, and screwed. Inelegant but effective. Now that's just one piece of furniture out of many. I'll look at Bob Lang's book after a while and see if it discusses the original details.

Wiley


The "Beckerdite Article"--Greene & Greene

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#4

Wandering OT

Bill Houghton, California cold in Sebastopol, CA

>I'm always intrigued by how much get-it-out-the-door construction there is in some of these things now held up as brilliant.

We went to see Hearst Castle some years back and went on the tour. In the dining room, the tour guide pointed out to us the carved panels covering the ceiling about 12 feet up, imported from Europe, hugely expensive, etc., etc. I noticed that they were fastened to backing boards that looked like they were made from wood rejected for use in packing crates as too cracked and filled with knots. For me, at least, it did not add to the attractiveness of the ceiling; but I guess the contractors were meeting a price.

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#5

Re: Beckerdite article *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>The Hall Bros used a lot of screws, so that shouldn't be surprising. Under much of the pyramid plugs, is a brass screw.

Dovetails are not used much at all in all of their work, rather the joinery was accentuated, most often with soft finger joints.

Yeah, the docents don't let you touch the furniture, but they have a special tour that takes you behind the scenes and gives more details about the joinery, I think the tour is given by Jim Kappecian (sp?). Here's a link...below.

They don't allow you to touch any of the furniture in the Gamble House (the only open display of Greene & Greene work), but if you lag behind at the back of the pack, you can easily cop a feel on much of it! *DAMHIKT*

No pictures either, you can only buy pictures in the bookstore. Some great stuff on the bookstore.

Remember that the Hall Bros used a LOT of power tools, most of the work was done with some. IMO, it was the Greene's tie into the wood industry that allowed for such work to be done to begin with (Blacker, Thorenson, and the owner of the home in Ojai, Pratt, was heavily involved in trading wood. Of course the Ultimate Bungalows are the best example of their work. No expense cutting on those homes...

For anyone that has never been to the Gamble House, if your in Pasadena, CA, you should try to go there. Hang out at the back of the pack! *lol*


Behind the Velvet Ropes Tour

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#7

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

Bob Lang

>Not dovetails, either a rabbet, a rabbet with an included tongue and groove or a shallow dado with the sides extending past the drawer back would be considered "typical". Often rabbets and dados would be reinforced with screws, sometimes hidden behind plugs, sometimes not.

The Greenes and Halls were eccentric about drawers, and door hinges too. It really isn't possible to say who was responsible for deciding to use these details, but it is an interesting thing to ponder. In any case, what they did worked.

There is some discussion of this in my book, but by the time I got to the backs of drawers I was pretty well exhausted.

Bob Lang

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#8

Thanks Bob!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I was hoping you'd chime in. I love your other books. Looks like you'll be seeing another order from me;^)

Have a Merry Christmas!

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#9

Craftsman design

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Bob, I love the basic lines of most Craftsman/A&C/Mission furniture; but I hate the ponderous wooden handles, tenon ends, things like the Gamble drawer with completely superfluous rounded over extrusive half laps. Why did they do that sort of thing? It would seem much more in keeping with the basic design tenants to have very simple handles, etc. My best guess is that they wanted an overly obvious trademark so there could be no mistake about whether a given piece was Craftsman or Shaker. How am I wrong here?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#10

Hi Alan do you or anyone else for that matter...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Have any more info on the Hall Brothers. I did a search and all I found were racing team/car builders and greeting cards.

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#11

Re: Craftsman design

ThomD

>I can't say about the hardware, unless it simply fit into the style. I saw many non-G&G pieces from that period in family collections and heavy details were the norm. Some of it, though, seems to mirror timber joinery displayed in the houses.

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#12

There's not a lot available... *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

There is not a lot of info available on the Hall Bros, there is some on one of the DVDs I have, but it's mostly in comments from the historians and other docent types.

They worked exclusively with the Greene Bros, and their shop was also in Pasadena. Some of the earlier work, such as the Adelaide Tichenor house (1904), started out using other craftsmen, but the work was not up to the quality needed by the Greene Bros, and the Greene's found the Hall Bros. Some of the style in the Adelaide Tichenor house were taken from some of the Ming Dynasty style furniture, as I understand. You'll find some info on the Hall Bros if you search around the net, and Maybe Bob Lang has more. In fact, Bob's book might have some info, I don't have it in front of me at the moment.

The person that would know the most is Jim Ipekjian (I mis-spelled his name previously). He is without a doubt the leading "expert" on the furniture that was put in the Greene & Greene homes, and he was responsible for restoring the Blacker home, which spared no expense. Some good video footage in some of the DVD with Ipekjian.

The Gamble House was built in 1908 to give you some reference, and the Ultimate Bungalow work was finished by early teens...Not a lot of info, as I said, the work is the best info available. Lots of pics all over the net. There is a video on the Gamble House restoration (I do have), and a book of the Blacker House (which I don't have).

I was a bit surprised to find they put brass screws under a lot of the plugs, but they are effective. I found that out in one of the tours, the first tour I went on the docent was not that helpful at providing too much info, but the 2nd tour was. There was a Greene & Greene home on the market for sale not long ago, about $1.8M. Check this link.

Sorry I can't be of more help on the Hall Bros, but there is not a lot of info out there, that can be found, and a lot of folks looking for it...


Greene & Greene home for sale (Last Feb.)

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#13

Re: Hi Alan do you or anyone else for that matter.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Scott,

There isn't much to be found on line, as you've discovered. There are two books which present pretty much what is known about John and Peter Hall. The first book, in time of publication, is Randell Makinson's book, "Greene & Greene--Furniture and Related Designs", 1982. The second reference is Bob Lang's book, which we've already discussed, entitled 'Shop Drawings for Greene & Greene Furniture', which is in current production.

Bob has a whole chapter "The Other Brothers", presenting biography on the Hall Brothers, along with a discussion of their joinery techniques.

Here is a very brief summary. Peter and John Hall were born in Stockholm, Sweden in the 1860s. By 1871, the Hall family had moved to Illinois and settled in Rock Falls. Makinson states that neither Peter nor John had any formal training in woodworking; that both were self-taught; but then he goes on to say that "...Peter came to Pasadena in 1886 and within a few years had won recognition as the best stair builder on the West Coast." Bob Lang says that the lack-of-training/self-taught statements don't square with the best-stair-builder statement, since the stair builder was the most highly skilled of carpenters in those days (and probably still is). And that Peter had achieved that status while still in his 20s.

Stating that the brothers were 'carpenters' does not quite capture the truth. John Hall was a very creative person, using drawings he had done when he was 16 as the basis for carvings performed for Pasadena mansions in his 20's and 30's. John was somewhat retiring and preferred to work for his brother, who handled the business matters. This somewhat mirrored the Greene's themselves, where Charles was the creative force, and Henry oversaw the business dealings. I'm sure that is an over-simplification, but is generally correct.

Charles and Henry Greene met Peter Hall, when Peter had been retained (by someone else) to perform modifications to the Bolton house, which had been designed by the Greene's. Impressed with Peter, the Greene's apparently induced him to start his own company to oversee construction and do the skilled carpentry on G&G's commissions.

Their first contract with the Greene's was in 1904. Bob Lang states that Peter Hall was general contractor for most of the 'ultimate bungalows', while John Hall ran the millwork shop, where the interior elements of the house were fashioned, along with the furniture.

The Halls built a 5,000 square foot work floor, with several stationary machines driven by a line shaft, and powered by gasoline engine. The brothers sought (of necessity) to machine everything they could, such was the amount of wood to be milled on each commission, and the details to be wrought.

There are more details in Bob's book, which I recommend. The other book to know about is Darrell Peart's. These two books are the only book references I am aware of if you are seeking construction and joinery details.

Wiley

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#14

Re: Craftsman design

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Thom, it seems very heavy and bulky and clumsy to me. Mimics the timber framing in the house? Maybe so.

Pam

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#15

The numbers are astounding...

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

That link I sent in the previous reply mentions they spent $8,000 to build the home in 1906. They were selling the home for $1,800,000 back in Feb.

In contrast the Gamble House, built in 1908, at a cost of $50,000.

They spent $10,000,000 to restore the home back around 2000.

When I moved back to the states from Japan around 1987, I setup computers for the executives of Security Pacific National Bank, and I would go out to Pasadena to work on the CEO's computer at his home. He didn't have a Greene & Greene, but an outrageous Craftman style home. After I left the bank, I was doing consulting and had a client in home health care, they had an office in Pasadena. I used to drive up this one street that was lined with Greene & Greene homes. This pre-dated me getting back into woodworking, which was after I moved up north. I grew up in the San Fernando Valley, about 20 minutes from Pasadena.

The other thing I did want to point out to you is that Charles Greene is most likely responsible for much of the design and style. It was his home that he built in Pasadena, which he experimented on, and details can be found in that home that were used in the Ultimate Bungalows. Charles would personally work on furniture in their shop, and his home, which was deployed by the Hall Bros.

On one of the videos they talked of a letter from Pratt, asking why the costs were running so high, and Charles sent a reply that he personally was responsible for the placement of each stone outside the front of the home, to ensure that they were placed in just the right position to reflect the style he wanted.

Much of the joinery was creative, stemming from ideas that were experimented with by Charles, who seemed to be more of the artist, where Henry was more handling the business side.

After he retired, Charles built a home in Carmel, which was more of an art studio, where he continued to experiment. The architecture of Greene & Greene was created by them, and much of the furniture joinery matched. There is continued themes with the Torii gates, Cloud Lifts, pyramid plugs, and most certainly finger joints, which was the most common joinery used.

The walk through the Gamble home is a pure treat, it is like walking through a large woodworking project where most every facet was crafted by hand, even much of the iron work was forged by hand. With my love of blacksmithing, and woodworking, these represent the ultimate woodworking project, and I hope to do one of my own when I build my timberframe wigwam up at Clear Lake. Some day...some day...

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#16

Thanks Wiley, I think...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Boy, that's some small text! Had to cut and paste it into a word file so I can read it...

Good read none the less.

Thanks!

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#17

Thanks John!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Nice article and very nice pic too.

Re: Anybody know how the brothers Greene...

#18

Thanks for link Alan...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The pics on Flicker are great.