Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

Posts

Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#1

Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

Bill Houghton, sun/cold in Sebastopol, CA

>I finish my consulting gig next Tuesday, and am thinking about one last extravagance with the last check, to celebrate being done (after that, I'll be conserving the remaining money I saved from "my" part of the income, for wood and stuff, to actually build things with the extra time I keep believing I'll have).

I love rasps, and have picked up, over the years, some older Nicholson cabinet rasps - not patternmakers rasps, though they do cut very smoothly. I'm looking to complement those with a couple of additional buys.

I am considering two rasps from Tools for Working Wood:

a) a Nicholson patternmaker's rasp, since I've heard positive things about them in the past. Lately, however, I've seen a couple of comments that quality isn't what it was. Has anyone purchased one lately who can comment?

b) a small Gramercy rasp. I'm wondering here about the difference between the short cabinet rasp - 5" - and the modeler's rasps. I'm attracted by the narrowness of the modeler's rasps, but wonder if they're too specialized.

Comments appreciated.

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#2

Hi Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>My Nicholson's 49 and 50 were purchased a few years back. Their good rasps. If the Gramercy's are hand made, I'd go for them instead. The main reason being the teeth on a Gramercy rasp should go all the way to the edge of the rasp, unlike Nicholson.

Sorry to hear about you rot problem.

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#3

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

Brent Smith, Montreal

>Hi Bill,

I would go with the Gramercy over the Nicholson's. I've only used one of Joel's rasps for a few minutes, but was very impressed by it. My Nicholson's are older also, but as Scott said the teeth going to the edge is a big plus on the hand cuts.

As far as a 5" cabinet makers rasp versus a modellers rasp, I would go with the modellers in that size. I have quite a number of Aurious in both cabinet and modellers style and really can't see what a 5" cabinet could do that a modellers couldn't. On the other hand, the narrow profile of the modeller rasps will allow you into places that the other won't. They are especially good for delicate work going into tight areas on carvings and any kind of curved work. Also great for final shaping of Lamb's Tongues.

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#4

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

I agree with Brent, both on the hand cut vs. Nicholson choice, and on the modeller's vs cabinet in the small size. In fact, with this special money, just get a handcut rasp, regardless of which one it is. You won't be sorrry.

The advantage I see in the modeller's, in addition to what Brent said, is that it is a little larger, which I think you may appreciate once you get it in hand. In fact, if it were my money (and it ain't) I would wait for the 8"/25tpi modellers, for $10 more, and get Joel to put in an order for it. I have an Auriou modellers in that size, and it is really a great favorite of mine.

Wiley

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#5

GREAT discussion *LINK*

paul womack

>I hope this link doesn't breach any forum rules, but the "rasp question" got discussed by some well informed people over on woodnet.

BugBear


link to discussion

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#6

Re: Gramercy, Nicholson rasps - another brand?... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ...

>Bill, et. al.,

You might want to consider spending your cash on yet another brand of hand-cut rasps, yes, I said it right, ANOTHER brand of these woodworking wonders - the Herdim Precision rasps. I've included the link to Dick Fine Tools below. I own a few of these and like the quality of the rasps. $$ to buy and ship from Germany, but...

Food for more thought...

John


http://www.dick.biz/dick/product/704505/detail.jsf

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#7

Yet another Frnch hand cut rasp *LINK*

MikeW

>As the subject says.

The Best Things is carrying French hand cut rasps, the equal of Auriou and available in the US without incurring higher shipping charges from Europe.

Top two links at the TBT linky below...

Take care, Mike

18" of snow and counting...


The Best Things page on rasps

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#8

Counting the horse's teeth.......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

One of the points of comparison among rasps is the fineness of the stitching (teeth per inch). Out of curiosity, I started to count the teeth on my Auriou rasps (Note to self: you really need to get a life).

I don't really know what a number like 25 tpi means--maybe Joel can interpret if he comes by.

Here are some data on two Auriou grain 15 rasps. One is a 6" modeller's rasp; the other is a 10" cabinet rasp. The rasps are stitched on the diagonal. There are lines of teeth set on the diagonal. So one can count "lines per inch", and then "teeth per inch" along each diagonal line.

DATA (each number is avg. of 4-5 repetitions)

6" modeller's rasp, grain 15........ 44 lines per inch.......36 teeth per inch (along line)

10' cabinet rasp, grain 15........... 36 lines per inch.......36 teeth per inch (along line)

I'm curious now, and will do the grain 13 and grain 14 later today. This is if anyone wants to try to compare teeth counts among rasps, to get an idea of relative fineness.

Wiley

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#9

Re: Counting the horse's teeth....now the G14 *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I counted two grain 14 modeller's rasps, a 6" and an 8":

6" modeller's rasp....... 36 lines per inch......32 teeth per inch (along the line)

8' modeller's rasp........ 30 lines per inch..... 28 teeth per inch (along the line)

Note that both the tooth and line count depend on the length of rasp, even for a particular Grain rating, in this case 14. The shorter rasp will be finer, even at the same rating.

Why do I have two? The 8" was my original purchase from Joel, and a huge favorite. When Auriou shut the doors a year ago, or whenever, I called Joel again and bought the 6" in case they never came back. Fortunately they did.

Incidentally in the previous post, the 10" Grain 15 cabinet rasp is "new Auriou", and it has all the same look and feel and cutting characteristics of the old Auriou. The wrapping for that rasp came signed by both Michel Auriou and Denis (the stitcher), with a cheerful greeting--so I found the customer service prompt and very warm and personable. That rasp was a custom order, and was delivered to my front porch in 5 weeks, which was well within the lead time indicated on the Auriou site. See link below for site info.


Auriou website (new)

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#10

Re: Counting the horse's teeth.......

joel

>25 tpi is tooth per inch going vertically (diagnolly you get a much higher number.)

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#11

Re: Counting the horse's teeth.......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Joel,

I'll update my Auriou numbers to reflect the vertical count, and then maybe we can get a database together for the different grains and grades. I realize there is more to it than that, but the tooth count should be useful.

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#12

Ellis Walentine

When I saw Michel...

Ellis Walentine

>... he was punching a sample rasp. He told me the process is all done by hand and eye, so the actual pitch of the teeth may vary depending on the state of mind of the worker that day. Apparently, after umpteen millions of punch strikes, you get a feel for the depth and spacing of the punches. They told me there is currently only one craftsman making their rasps at the moment. I'll bet they have a big insurance policy on him. :-)

Ellis


img

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#13

Re: When I saw Michel...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Probably such insurance costs about the same as it would have to have given the old employees their August vacations; but then he could have had a full complement of employees.

Pam

Re: Gramercy rasps, Nicholson rasps

#14

Hey Bug Bear...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>WTF.

I'm still waiting for a re-post of Preston beaders/scrapers that you missed. Why not post your feelings?