Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

Posts

The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#1

The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

If you will walk up one flight of stairs, you will find the spacious and well-lit WoodCentral library, overseen by knowledgeable librarian Barb Siddiqui. Among the valuable manuscripts there, you will find the Book Reviews.

There is a new review: 'The Art of Joinery', by Joseph Moxon. This is the Chris Schwarz edition, published by Lost Art Press, with permission of the Early American Industries Association to use the EAIA's excellent plates. This book reprints the Joinery chapter of Moxon's 'Mechanick Exercises' of 1703, and augments the Moxon text with Chris' editing and commentary.

Chris Schwarz has done a great service to our wood working community by publishing this book. And truly, at $!7 it is a public service. Please navigate to the Book Review if you wish to find out more, or just click the link below. Navigation chart: On left side of page, click Departments, then Book Reviews.

Wiley Horne


Review: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Schwarz)

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#2

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Stuart Hough

>Spot On, Wiley! I am only about twelve pages in on my copy ( another Secret Santa gift) and already I feel as as though I'll be able to do better handwork when I start my next project. Chris does an excellent job of "letting us in on the secrets". Thank you Mr. Schwarz!

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#3

A question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The question relates to whether there was any evolution in hand tool techniques between the time this book was written and later in the age of furniture making with hand tools. Or to ask a different way, if the book had been written XXX years later from the same perspective of a guide to techniques used in a British trade shop, would there be any changes?

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#4

Re: A question

Joel

>yes, lots.

First of all the book is really about joinery - not fine furniture making.

tools have gotten better.

But certain better ways of doing things - like chopping mortises and paring to the line are mostly not taught today which I think is a real loss.

The best practical part of Moxon that resonates today I think is it's focus on a few basic important skills that must be mastered if you want to use hand tools.

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#5

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Bob Demers

>Thanks for an excellent review Wiley, very well written.

I really like your 'Why read Moxon' description of us modern WW, hit the spot :-)

Bob, awaiting Xmas anxiously to read it :-)

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#6

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Bill Sams

>Thanks Wiley, just ordered a copy!

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#7

Very well done, Wiley. Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#8

Thanks; Wiley, Chris & Lost Arts Press!

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>You're all treasures in my book.

greg

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#9

What he said.....:>)!!!

Frank Mutchler

>

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#10

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I received a copy of this book along with a copy of Moby Dick by Herman Melville for a Christmas present this year. I am glad no one attempted to correct the sentence construction and meaning of things in Moby Dick. While it may be a bit difficult to read, it is what the original author intended, I like that.

As for the Moxon book, I read it yesterday and was disappointed, but I was warned in the introduction that it wasn't an academic work. I hope to find a copy of the book that is not altered and is as originally intended.

It was great to have the text (I just wish I had the whole thing). It is too bad that the original text wasn't included, it is a small book.

As for the analysis, some of it was wrong and having modern tools, a wristwatch, references, etc. was distracting. The new parenthetical additions were laborious and in some cases inappropriate and inaccurate.

I do like the plates and the enlarged parts of the plates.

Stephen

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#11

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Paul Kierstead

>As for the analysis, some of it was wrong..

Such a general an absolute assertion, without a single example containing supporting evidence is thoroughly unfair, IMO. If you say something is "wrong", you should offer evidence as to what and why; at least a couple examples.

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#12

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Paul,

Page 44 'Bird Cage Awl', that was a later term.

Page 55 'unreliable adhesives', What?

Pages 56-57 Miter square 'less accurate', I don't think so.

I also have questions about comments relating to the workbench, molding planes and the plow.

With the original text corrupted it is difficult to determine what Moxon had in mind.

Stephen

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#13

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

MikeW

>Stephen,

I have both an "accurate" reprint (1703 ed.) and Chris' edition. There is nothing "corrupted." To use terms common of today to relate to uncommon ones of the past is a right proper way of explanation. The making the unknown known.

As regards the pricker = birdcage awl? I might have also noted in the discussion that one leg of the compass was also referred to as a pricker. No idea which shape the leg was. But the pricker of the discussion is square terminating to a point.

So if the modern reader was to desire to go buy or make a Moxonesque pricker, what would you tell him to purchase or make? What words would you use? I seriously doubt you would insist on using the work "pricker" without tying in the "modern" term of birdcage awl.

Geez.

Take care, Mike

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#14

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

john jesseph

>Given that Moxon was not a woodworker anyway, I think one could just as easily criticize the original. Maybe Moxon got quite a bit wrong?

BTW just got my copy today... :)

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#15

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Michael Rogen------WebKitFormBoundaryAAiEAAxMAAf+A

>I would like to say thank you to Wiley for his excellent review.

The book was not intended to be a "Scholarly" work, it is a book for the masses for the "every man and woman" which describes many of the people who visit here. The biggest problem that could result from Chris's book is that more people will be introduced to Moxon which could only be seen as a positive and those that are curious as to how it compares to original will seek out a copy and find out for themselves.

As I see it there is nothing but good that has or will come from Chris's book and for that I I applaud him.

Michael

------WebKitFormBoundaryAAiEAAxMAAf+AA82

------WebKitFormBoundaryAA8SAANiAAe7AA+G

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#16

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Larry_Wyatt(Cole's Dad)

>I know I'm just returning to the group after a long hiatus, but I feel I must also comment on Chris Schwarz's book and Stephen's review as an owner of the book and from another perspective. To wit...

I've written two textbooks myself and am on the editorial boards of a number of scientific journals and a peer reviewer of scientific articles for other journals. It must be borne in mind that any text must be read under the guise of the author's intent. Given Chris' intent, to compare it to Moby Dick is disingenuous. The two works exist in diametric opposition to each other in terms of content and intent.

I find the Schwarz modern interpretation of Moxon's work to be illuminating, informative and a genuine and sincere attempt to make the original tome readable, interpretable and ready to 'put into action' to the 21st century reader.

Of course, I could be completely wrong. <8-)

Larry

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#17

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Raney

>Thanks for the meta-review Stephen - it's useful to have multiple points of view on this work, important or trivial as it may be.

Unfortunately, I was a bit disappointed with your commentary, which I found under-supported and at times inaccurate. A word of some mild caution from a fellow student of literature: if I didn't know better, I might almost have suspected professional envy - but fortunately I know of your commitment to making historical woodworking available. I am somewhat confident, therefore, that you would join me in supporting such a work as this (even with 'motes in its eye' so to speak) at least for its attempt to make such a text accessible to those possessing greater degrees of curiosity than erudition. While you and I may have hoped more for transliteration than palimpsest, I must wonder whether we aren't perhaps guilty of being overly choosy 'beggars' in our wishing for an original text that is, of course, elsewhere obtainable. Perhaps you will join me in amusingly recalling some of the initial criticism of Robert Fagles' translation of the Iliad - accused of sacrificing linguistic and idiomatic accuracy in furthering the accessibility of the works as part of an effort to restore the 'poetic' nature of the tale to generations of readers not trained in classic Greek... but I digress.

In the translator's defense, the prefatory explanations in the book make quite clear the intent of the work, which is in no way meant to be entirely accurate and is obviously guided by only a single woodworker's (rather than historian's) analysis. Perhaps you could find a buyer for your copy and put yourself that much closer to the original reproduction you pine for?

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schwarz *LINK*

#18

Re: The Art of Joinery, Jo. Moxon (Ed.: Chris Schw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

This is a good topic for Stephen to have brought up. Raney's response really puts the discussion in the correct perspective.

Now Stephen truly does have a researcher's and a scholar's interest, and he needs to get as close to the original as he can, if for no other reason than to assure himself he is looking at every clue which survives.

That said, I would like to get specific about the nature and extent of Chris Schwarz' editing. I have just gone through the olde English text of my Praeger edition. My focus was on "Section 10. Of Chiffels of feveral Sorts. And firft of Formers." I compared Praeger's Section 10 with the Lost Art Press's Section 10, word for word. These are the total changes made by Chris' editing:

1. f versus s, and capitalization. To take an example, Chris rendered the title "Of chisels of several sorts. And first of formers." The character 'f' was changed to 's'; chiffels became chisels; capitalized nouns were rendered lower case.

2. Spelling usage. 'Chiffel' was changed to 'chisel'; 'unluckly' was changed to 'unlucky'; and 'knockt' was changed to 'knocked'.

3. Run-on sentences. Two of Moxon's very long sentences were each made into two "normal length" sentences, by changing a colon to a period in one case, and a semi-colon to a period in the other case.

Everything else was left alone. There are some glosses in the text, where the original word is left in place, and glossed in parentheses: 'helve' is glossed 'handle'; former is glossed firmer.

To my eye and mind, Chris does no harm to Moxon's words. The translations he makes are the ones we each of us must mentally make anyway. The net effect is to reduce the friction in the reading. I am quite sure that Stephen truly does want to see the 'f's' and the 'knockt's' and the 'unluckly's', the original run-on sentences, and the capitalization of nouns. I am sure the editor's hand creates friction for Stephen rather than removing it, because of Stephen's sensibility about old texts. Stephen is going to need to spend the $100 to satisfy himself.

For me, comparing both texts, I think it is editing-lite. Much lighter than for example, the rendering of the King James Version into the Revised Standard Version--Chris' text never becomes fully modern or colloquial. He leaves enough of the archaic phrase to maintain a sense of place and time.

Wiley