Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Legacy Planeworks - RIP

Posts

Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#1

Legacy Planeworks - RIP

Steven Kirincich

>http://blog.legacyplanes.com/

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#2

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

C.R. Miller

>It's a sad day. Legacy helped fill the void left by Shepherd Tools, and was an important toolmaker in its own right. $225 is an absolute bargain for those looking to get into planemaking.

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#3

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

Bob Demers

>First Shepperd, now Legacy, we now have two makers of infill's plane kit going under, on both sides of the border :-(

Interestingly they both featured CNC or laser cut components, in order to ensure a consistent quality product.

I guess that even automation does not fare well on a small scale.

It also give you an idea of why high quality hand built infill planes such as Sauers's are pricy ?). Low production high quality tools are an expensive proposition on a small scale, regardless of methods used.

Bob

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#4

Alternative interpertation

David Cockey

>"Interestingly they both featured CNC or laser cut components, in order to ensure a consistent quality product.

I guess that even automation does not fare well on a small scale."

Or CNC and laser cut components may not be the only key to success in the plane kit business. Shepherd Planes appears to have been undercapitalized and underestimated costs and the amount of work required to run the businesss based on various reports including quotes from one of the owners. They seem to have struggled for several years with a number of unhappy customers. Legacy seems to have concluded they were not going to be successful and decided to pull the plug.

It's pretty common for folks starting small businesses to underestimate the costs other than materials, and the amount of their time which will be required. It's also not uncommon to over-estimate the price/volume the market will support. Another very common problem is not enough capital. The current economy can make things worse. Not enough folks may be willing to spend enough money, and credit is tougher to get and keep.

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#5

Clarification

David Cockey

>In case there is any confusion I don't know anything other than what was on the website about Legacy. They may have had a very well thought out business plan with good estimates of costs, etc, and had the capital they needed. Given they have some remaining kits I assume there are no customers waiting for their orders.

I expect we may see several other, otherwise viable small tool businesses decide they can't continue in the current economic situation.

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#6

Bummer...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Yet another small business get slammed by large corporations mistakes.

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#7

That's it in a nut shell.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

It's pretty common for folks starting small businesses to underestimate the costs other than materials, and the amount of their time which will be required. It's also not uncommon to over-estimate the price/volume the market will support. Another very common problem is not enough capital. The current economy can make things worse. Not enough folks may be willing to spend enough money, and credit is tougher to get and keep.

What you say here is so true. So many people are blinded by their dreams and enthusiasm and aren't thorough and honest when they do the math. I can't think of a business that is easy. A small business encounters all the same problems and pitfalls as a larger business, only difference is the size of the numbers.

Marv

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#8

Re: That's it in a nut shell.

ThomD

>At the end of the day, running realistic numbers and realistic scenarios would still leave one in deep trouble in the current environment. And with a short period of operation, there is less in the way of goodwill to preserve by shoveling money than otherwise. The business can always be re-launched at a latter date if that should prove attractive.

Re: Legacy Planeworks - RIP

#9

Re: That's it in a nut shell.

walt q

>as a small shopkeeper/owner for 28 years I intimately understand the problems facing any small business owners...it has never been as hard to keep the doors open as it has this last year, and next year looks to be even worse. All the business models and plans will not help in this climate. Better they pulled the plug now before they really got in trouble and while they still have positive customer response. I wish them well...

Walt Q