Re: On sawing tenons
Don McConnell
>Wiley et al,
I suspect that traditional trade practice concerning cutting tenons may have varied amongst the woodworking trades, but if you are asking about cabinet/furniture-making, then I think Richard's training was typical. I was taught the same basic sequence for essentially the same reasons, and Charles Hayward (who underwent a traditional apprenticeship in London) presents the same sequence in both _Cabinet Making for Beginners_ and _Woodwork Joints_.
Hayward repeats this sequence in several different applications, but I think his treatment of making cabinet doors with mouldings stuck in the solid and the rails/stiles rabbeted to take a panel (pages 39 -40, _Woodwork Joints_) helps clarify why this became the convention. It also helps flesh out part of what Richard was saying.
Regarding the tenons, Hayward first knifes the shoulders all around, using a chisel and a try square. He then forms a sloping V-groove on the waste side of the line in which to run the back saw later. This is followed with a mortise gauge, and though he doesn't detail it, the implication is that any other necessary gauge lines are also struck at this point. Hayward then saws the cheeks of the tenons.
This is followed by running the rabbet and sticking the moulding. In the case of the rabbet, it needs to run the entire length of the rail piece, because it also determines the set-in (inside width) of the tenon. Clearly, cutting this rabbet obliterates the mortise gage lines on the inside edges of the rails and stiles, which helps clarify the reason for cutting the tenon cheeks first. (And, also, why mortises are typically chopped in the stiles before any rabbeting or ploughing of grooves.)
Sticking the moulding doesn't necessarily obliterate any gauge lines, but I think that, since the decision had already been made to saw the tenon cheeks, cabinetmakers simply decided to go ahead and stick the moulding full-length, before cutting the shoulders. It does, of course, obliterate part of the shoulder knife line, but the bulk of it remains to guide the saw. Sawing the shoulders is next, then.
As already hinted at, the inside width of the tenon is typically determined by the rabbet or groove in some types of work. Absent these features, the width of the tenon is laid out after both the cheeks and shoulders are cut by offering the tenon up to the mortise and transferring the layout lines to the end of the tenon. These lines are then carried down the tenon to guide the saw.
Hayward does caution against fouling the shoulders when sawing a tenon to width. So those in the trade knew of this risk. However, in many cases, especially those with rabbets or grooves and haunches, it really doesn't arise as an issue.
In some kind of work, the consideration of obliterating gauge lines doesn't really enter the equation. In which case, the sequence may not really matter that much, but I believe cabinetmakers, historically, tended to follow the same basic sequence in most instances.
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR