Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

On sawing tenons

Posts

On sawing tenons

#1

On sawing tenons

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

On a standard shouldered tenon, there are 8 saw cuts to make--4 crosscuts for the shoulders, 2 rips for the cheeks, and 2 rips for the little end pieces.

Here's my question....In what order do you take these cuts? I'm not sure what is 'correct' in terms of trade practice. For myself, I like to saw the shoulders first, the reason being that those shoulder cuts are sort of a line of resistance against going too deep with the rip cuts. In other words, if I make the shoulder cuts first, then as I make the rips, I can slow down and feel when the saw has completed the cut and the side and end pieces fall of.

BUT. Doing the cuts in this sequence guarantees that I will cut one set of marks away. For example, if I saw the shoulders, then saw the cheeks--the cheek pieces will fall away taking the marks for the end pieces with them. And if I rip the end pieces first, they will fall away taking the cheek marks with them. So I'm guaranteed of cutting my own marks away.

But still, I hate to do the rips first, for fear of leaving little saw marks on the shoulders.

What do you guys (including ladies) do? And is there a 'correct' way?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: On sawing tenons

#2

Re: On sawing tenons

Alex Grigoriev

>Try:

Long crosscut

Short shoulders

Long shoulders

Short crosscut

Re: On sawing tenons

#3

Re: On sawing tenons

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

I do the rip cuts first. Then the shoulders. Often there is just a skosh of material left at the junction of the cheeks/shoulders that I quickly pare with a wide chisel in a slicing fashion.

Which means I stop shy of the knifed lines on the rip cuts.

Take care, Mike

Re: On sawing tenons

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: On sawing tenons

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Wiley,I cut mine in the same order you do except...I mark the shoulder all around,mark the tenon thickness on ends and sides,crosscut cheek,rip cut cheek---then I mark the tenon ends. Saw shoulder crosscut,then depending on thickness of material to be removed,and straightness of grain,I either pare the wood away,split it off or saw it.I hope this is clear. BTW,as far as I'm concerned,there are no rules,just common practices.---Jack

Re: On sawing tenons

#5

preston range *LINK*

paul womack

>On a standard shouldered tenon, there are 8 saw cuts to make--4 crosscuts for the shoulders, 2 rips for the cheeks, and 2 rips for the little end pieces.


You know you *need* two saws for the different cuts - rip vs cross, right?

BugBear


link to discussion

Re: On sawing tenons

#6

Re: On sawing tenons

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I mark first, then cross cut all around. I do this so that I have a nice kerf to guide my saw. Then I rip down to the line. Yes, one loses the marks for the tenon ends. I have put them below the scribed shoulder line. But more often then case, I just hold the tenon over the mortise, line everything up and directly mark the tenon. You don't really need gauged lines for these cuts. The wood will compress easily no matter.

I've been looking closely at old furniture. Overcuts are pretty common on old dts. Not just the 1/2 blind pins behind drawer fronts. Guys over cut their tails too. They aren't longer than a nick in most cases. But I never see overcut tenon cheeks. Never. That could be because they too preferred to cross cut first. Or there may have been something about dts- a giter-done attitude. But that's what I see.

Adam

Re: On sawing tenons

#7

Re: On sawing tenons

Sgian Dubh

>I am in the cut the long grain cuts first camp. This is the standard practice I was taught during my training. It is standard practice because you don't lose any of the marks during the sawing procedures until you can afford to lose them.

I understand your concerns about possibly cutting too deep on the long grain cuts, but this is easily fixed by purposely stopping a hair short of the line. Subsequent cross cutting to form the haunches, shoulders, etc, will sometimes leave a small hump of wood in the corner that is quickly sliced off with a chisel. With practice most workers soon develop a knack of knowing precisely where the shoulder line is and know when to stop pretty much right on it.

On the other hand, a lot of old and antique furniture I have worked on over the decades illustrates that many workers in past centuries overcut beyond shoulder lines, especially where the joint is tucked up out of easy sight. Slainte.

Re: On sawing tenons

#8

Re: On sawing tenons

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I layout the tenons will all marks, tenons with a mortise gauge and the other sides with a marking gauge.

I cut the shoulders first to give a stop for the cheek work. I almost never rip my tenons, rather I split them and pare them to the line. I then use the marking gauge to remark the new tenon and split those off then pare to the line.

Traditionally, I have seen both split and more common, sawn tenons and with evidence of slight oversawing on cheeks, especially door frames.

Stephen

Re: On sawing tenons

#9

Re: On sawing tenons

Chris Friesen

>If you split your tenons, what do you do when the grain isn't straight? Do you work away from the shoulder towards the end, or go crossgrain?

Re: On sawing tenons

#10

Re: On sawing tenons

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Chris,

I select wood that is straight grain especially on tenon ends and while there is always some arrant grain, I read the grain, sneak up on the split and go to school on which way to work off the waste.

I will work in both directions and even work off the cheeks cross grain with a coffin smoother or skew rabbit. I have also used cabinet rasps and a toothing plane to prepare the tenons for gluing. The toothing plane works great in any direction of grain.

I also dress off the sharp outside edges on the tenon, including the ends. This eases assembly and gives excess hide glue somewhere to go. I also chamfer the top edges of the mortise for the same reasons.

Stephen

Re: On sawing tenons

#11

Re: On sawing tenons *LINK*

MikeW

>The link below is to George Huron's Springharvest web site. It demonstrates splitting tenons off.

It goes faster than George's delibrately slow pace for the video.

The video will start upon clicking the link (I believe). So if you are on a slow connection, bear that in mind.

Take care, Mike


Splitting tenon cheeks off

Re: On sawing tenons

#12

Hi Mike, Thanks for the link.

Victor Parisian

>pretty slick.

Victor in Houston

Re: On sawing tenons

#13

Re: On sawing tenons

Don McConnell

>Wiley et al,

I suspect that traditional trade practice concerning cutting tenons may have varied amongst the woodworking trades, but if you are asking about cabinet/furniture-making, then I think Richard's training was typical. I was taught the same basic sequence for essentially the same reasons, and Charles Hayward (who underwent a traditional apprenticeship in London) presents the same sequence in both _Cabinet Making for Beginners_ and _Woodwork Joints_.

Hayward repeats this sequence in several different applications, but I think his treatment of making cabinet doors with mouldings stuck in the solid and the rails/stiles rabbeted to take a panel (pages 39 -40, _Woodwork Joints_) helps clarify why this became the convention. It also helps flesh out part of what Richard was saying.

Regarding the tenons, Hayward first knifes the shoulders all around, using a chisel and a try square. He then forms a sloping V-groove on the waste side of the line in which to run the back saw later. This is followed with a mortise gauge, and though he doesn't detail it, the implication is that any other necessary gauge lines are also struck at this point. Hayward then saws the cheeks of the tenons.

This is followed by running the rabbet and sticking the moulding. In the case of the rabbet, it needs to run the entire length of the rail piece, because it also determines the set-in (inside width) of the tenon. Clearly, cutting this rabbet obliterates the mortise gage lines on the inside edges of the rails and stiles, which helps clarify the reason for cutting the tenon cheeks first. (And, also, why mortises are typically chopped in the stiles before any rabbeting or ploughing of grooves.)

Sticking the moulding doesn't necessarily obliterate any gauge lines, but I think that, since the decision had already been made to saw the tenon cheeks, cabinetmakers simply decided to go ahead and stick the moulding full-length, before cutting the shoulders. It does, of course, obliterate part of the shoulder knife line, but the bulk of it remains to guide the saw. Sawing the shoulders is next, then.

As already hinted at, the inside width of the tenon is typically determined by the rabbet or groove in some types of work. Absent these features, the width of the tenon is laid out after both the cheeks and shoulders are cut by offering the tenon up to the mortise and transferring the layout lines to the end of the tenon. These lines are then carried down the tenon to guide the saw.

Hayward does caution against fouling the shoulders when sawing a tenon to width. So those in the trade knew of this risk. However, in many cases, especially those with rabbets or grooves and haunches, it really doesn't arise as an issue.

In some kind of work, the consideration of obliterating gauge lines doesn't really enter the equation. In which case, the sequence may not really matter that much, but I believe cabinetmakers, historically, tended to follow the same basic sequence in most instances.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: On sawing tenons

#14

Fabulous explanation!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Don,

That's convincing!--that the most complex of the typical joints would establish the convention. The reference to the mortise sequence also clears that up.

Serious suggestion....Do a frame-and-panel sequence for two of your upcoming videos. Just as you've laid it out here (plus the panel itself). Is there a date when your second video on moulding will be out?

Wiley

Re: On sawing tenons

#15

Thanks Mike!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Reminds me of my teacher.

Re: On sawing tenons

#16

yes but???

roninkokomo

>Visual evidence that this method works. But I am thinking that is way fussier and takes more time than sawing tenons to the line??

Re: On sawing tenons

#17

Re: yes but???

MikeW

>I offered the video up simply because it shows splitting tenons "work." It's faster than the video suggests. It also depends on just how fussy a fit one desires as regards the use of the router plane.

I seldom have worked wood that is conducive to splitting. Other than using the method on the few projects I could or playing with splitting tenon cheeks, I prefer other methods for myself.

I too prefer to work off the saw. I do need to often remove a touch here or there. I typically use a fine rasp or coarse file on the cheeks, however. And while I slice off the little bit following cross cutting shoulders, I typically undercut the tenon shoulds a tad.

I rarely have used the method of creating a V at the shoulder lines either. Most woods I have used one cannot easily create the V and so have thought that was too time consuming. It does make undercutting or simply paring the shoulders well easier.

There are times I have used a router plane to arrive at fairly precise thicknesses. For instance, I built a cabinet with half-lapped drawer dividers set into dadoes. 20 precise half-laps. The router plane was just the ticket.

Take care, Mike

Re: On sawing tenons

#18

I agree

roninkokomo

>The router plane is an underutilized tool in many shops. I find it very useful.

Re: On sawing tenons

#19

What if the split goes the wrong way?

wilbur

>I've seen the splitting technique used on making a tenon before, but I've never seen how one would recover if the split goes into the tenon, making at least part of it too narrow, instead of going straight down.

Re: On sawing tenons

#20

Second Wiley's suggestion

Wendell @ Murphy, TX

>I would love to see a video sequence of doing a frame and plane with stuck molding. I bought Hayward's book a while back just for a good explanation of how to make that joint. A video would be even better! Jim Kingshott does a haunched mortise frame joint with a rebate in his mortise and tenon video. Unfortunately, he cut the mortise and tenon independent of each other on opposite ends of the same piece of wood then cut the piece in half to do the final fitting. Something seems odd about his sequence due to this. I would've liked it better if he had used two separate piece to begin with. In the video, he cuts the cheeks before the shoulders on every tenon he makes. He also specifically warns about cutting too far or it will show on the finished work.

Wendell

Re: On sawing tenons

#21

Re: What if the split goes the wrong way?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>One of the ways to avoid splitting is to use the chisel bevel down. Of course, that would make this process even slower and more fiddly. :) There are some time advantages gained by sawing off most of the tenon first, you don't have to process stuff that will be waste.

Pam