Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

Posts

Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#1

Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

Rich S

>I was browsing through Woodcarvers Supply catalog and see they carry a line of carving chisels identified as the Lamp brand...are these made by Pfeil for Woodcarver's Supply?..They look a lot like Pfeil's chisels by the handle and the stamps pressed into the steel...anyone have any Lamp chisels? Are you happy with them?

Thanks, Rich in Madison

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#2

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Rich,

Lamp is a German brand. See link below to Wood Carver's Supply.

Pfeil has an internal ferrule, and the handles are octagonal or hex, but with a slight bulge in the middle. Pfeil's logo is an arrow; their tools are also marketed as 'Swiss Made'.

The Lamp handles and ferrules look a lot like Dastra and Kirschen (Two Cherries) to me. I have some of the latter and they are good steel.

Wiley


Lamp brand gouge--Wood Carvers Supply

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#3

To use the link........

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Click the link provided above, then on left side of page select 'Lamp', then 'straight gouges', then click on any size gouge, and there will be a writeup about Lamp brand gouges.

Sorry I couldn't link you straight through to the info.

Wiley

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#4

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

Neal praying for rain in San Jose

>As Wiley said, there are some differences, so I don't think they are the same. I don't carve very much, but I have a few Lamp chisels and have no complaints. They seem to take an edge well and hold it long enough for me.

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#5

Me too. looks like we'er getting some!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>More, more, more...

How do you want it, How do you want it...

Hail and and a mere 1/2" today.

Bring it!

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#6

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

Andrew Lunn

>I think Lamp and Pfeil are notably different, but they're both nice tools. Lamp gouges are very similar to Two Cherries gouges, so much so that if you removed the handles I doubt you could tell which was which. The steel in the Lamp tools is different from the steel in the Pfeil tools. Either one takes a good edge and holds it; they just feel different, and the steels kind of have a different texture or feel to them, which you can discern when you're doing that nitty gritty sharpening that you do to carving tools. They'll both do serious work. I own and use gouges by a number of makers and would rank the Lamp right there with the others. The one I'd probably put at the top of the pack is the Auriou. However, certain makers sometimes seem especially good at a particular type of gouge, like a v-tool, for instance, or a veiner. But generally speaking I think Auriou is the best. Hope this helps.

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#7

Yikes, I just shoveled 6" of snow!

VTAndy4

>

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

#8

Re: Lamp vs. Pfeil Carving Tools

Pat Riley

>I know that Lamps are a good tool and that Lee Grindinger recommended them and used them. I'm not sure you can get a better recommendation than that.