Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

first dovetails...last dovetails?

Posts

first dovetails...last dovetails?

#1

first dovetails...last dovetails?

Gary

>Hi,

I thought I'd be creative, and try some handcut dovetails...for my lovely bride. Well, the wood is great, but the results...hmm. Don't they look great? (from 5 feet away...haha). Anyway, they were close enough for the glue to hold...thank God. Besides, my wife didn't really want the tray for anything....I guess it'll make a christmas present.

Funny!

Well, it was fun, but I'm not sure if I'll continue down this path or not. I used about as much patience as I could during the practice, and implementation of the saw/chisel skills as I could muster...perhaps I'm lazy, but I may go back to the machine!

Thanks for looking..

Gary


img

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#2

Okay, a bit closer now 

Gary

>


img

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#3

warning: content may offend you. 

Gary

>


img

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#4

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

John Pappas

>Gary, Nice box. Less than perfect hand dovetails look better to me than machine dovetails....period. Not bad for first time. I am sure than the next time or two that you try hand cut dovetails there will be plenty of improvement. Keep trying.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#5

I like it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Gary,

The box is beautiful. Wood has that instant-old figured look, tone is great on the finish. Figuration is fully developed. It's terrific.

On the dovetails.....you're just a heartbeat away. The sawing is straight and consistent--you can tell by the fact that the cut lines showing on the backside of the pins are parallel and not skew to each other. Also, the baselines are not munged up from the chisel.

What you are concerned about is that the fit is not tight. However, note that the clearances are very even and consistent on every pin/tail junction. Are you going tails first? If so, I think that what may be happening is that on the second board--the pins board--when you go to saw it. you are splitting the marked line rather than ju-u-u-u-st barely shaving it. Just a guess from a photo, but the main thing is that you are right there, just a breath away.

The box is beautiful, and that comes through.

Wiley

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#6

Re: should have seen my first

Dave Mount

>They never made it into a project. If these are really your first, they're not only better than most but you get kudos for having the guts to do it on something that mattered (mine were on scrap). Don't go back to the machine. Even while your fit is improving, doing it by hand lets you use all kinds of layouts. Router-made pins look pudgy, the pins on your tray look nice.

Pretty wood -- birch?

Best,

Dave

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#7

Very Well Said Wiley

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Gary, I echo completely what Wiley said, and will add that those dovetails look fine--especially for first attempts. I've seen much worse---in my own shop. :~(

Keep at it, I think you're a Natural.

T.O.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#8

Re: I like it

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Great response Wiiey,

I agree with your thoughts,

Take care,

Jim

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#9

Look pretty darn good from here !

steve mackay

>

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#10

Just like my students

McKay

>Some of my students do not want to go through a learning curve. The dovetails are fine. As I tell my students, the second, third, etc should continue to get better. If not then go back to the machine and live with perfectly meshing but ugly dovetails.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#11

Also Gary, remember this.....

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>we are own worse critics. I think that's just Human Nature. We tend to beat the dog doo-doo out of ourselves over small imperfections. If somebody where to beat us up half as badly as we beat up ourselves we'd demand that they go to prison.

As I was working in my shop later this afternoon it dawned on my that perhaps without even realizing it you had taken the late David Pye's advice and entered into the zone of "Workmanship of Risk" by using such beautiful wood on your first crack at dovetailing. You had confidence in yourself that is quite astonishing if you ask me.

Toss them dang machines and stick to the handwork, I say that you've got a knack for it and I highly encourage you to develop it.

T.O.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#12

Re: I like it

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Jim,

I know you've got some dovetails that cheer Gary up right quick! C'mon, c'mon let's seem 'em again. If those dovetails didn't discourage you out of hand dovetailing then Gary's got no worries.

T.O.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#13

You're WAY ahead of me!

Bill Houghton, rain/sun/rain/sun in Sebastopol, CA

>Seems like the few times I've tried to do fancy joints like that, they've looked OK from 100 yards away on a dark night, if you didn't look directly at them.

I note that at least one of the respected teachers on this subject (Tage Frid? Frank Klausz? can't remember) offers suggestions for repairing gaps in dovetails, including cutting down the line of the assembled box and gluing in "feathers" of stock to fill the gap; clearly, imperfection is inevitable.

I am also aware after years of trying to learn that hand tool skills are just that: skills. Skill: "Proficiency, facility, or dexterity that is acquired or developed through training or experience." (online American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition, copyright 2006, thank you dictionary.com).

I think you've begun right well.

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#14

Not at all. Truly hand made!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>For your first you should be proud! Give it to your mistress, not your wife... ;^).

What wood did you use and finish?

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#15

wood/finish

Gary

>Ah, at least I do like the finish. This is a fabulous figured maple, with one of Jeff Jewitt's finishing recipies...turned out great!

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#16

Come on Gary shareing is a good thing....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Spill it man. Wadda ya do!?!

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#17

Re: Come on Gary shareing is a good thing.... *LINK*

Gary

>Really, I followed Mr. Jewitt's advice entirely. I used his Early American Maple Finish article, but used the optional "for a darker finish" found at the end.

I am extremely happy with the finish results...but I cannot take much credit for it. I have included a link to this "recipe". There are a lot of steps, but strangely I don't mind the finishing (well, can we exclude the sanding/scraping for a moment - I DO mind that).

Thanks for looking.


Homestead Finishing Link

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#18

They look pretty good from here too.

Victor Parisian

>I concur 100% with Wiley.

My first hand cut dove tails were on scrap wood, and they were fairly tight, but I've never got them that good again.

I do have a wonderful Leigh jig that came with a book about an inch thick. My son and I used it when we made one of Norm's work benches with about a dozen drawers in it. For the most part it has sat in one of those drawers unused now for the better part of five years. Recently my BIL, a former high school shop teacher, expressed interest in the Leigh jig. We proceeded to spend a good hour attempting to get it set up to make decent joints, eventually we both kind of gave up in digust and went back in the house for a beer (Shiner Bock of course).

Still have the Leigh jig and it still sits in that same drawer.

but my hand cut dovetails are getting better.

Regards from Houston

Victor

Re: first dovetails...last dovetails?

#19

Re: They look pretty good from here too.

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'd heard those stories about the Leigh too. I bought an Akeda instead.

And it sits in a box on the shelf. Now for four years.

The nice joints come from a saw, a square and sharp chisels.

Keep at it!