Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Iron & steel . . .

Posts

Iron & steel . . .

#1

Iron & steel . . .

steve mackay

>I'm removing some features from a mutt plane to in-fill it. While grinding I noticed there were no sparks. Just for kicks I wondered why. Asked Dad, Tool & Die Maker Extraordinaire, for the short answer. I'm sure everyone on this forum already knew this but it answered a couple years of wondering for me !

" Steel makes all the sparks, iron does not make sparks. You almost have to beg

iron to make sparke when putting it to a grinding wheel. Iron is what you

could all a dead metal.

The classic example of why and when you test metal for sparking is when a

metal part has broken and you need to weld it together to repair it and you

can't really tell if it's cast iron or cast steel.

It's a 50 50 gamble because if you use steel welding rod and start to weld

cast iron it will melt the cast iron and just make a spray of molten metal.

If you use cast iron welding rod to weld cast steel it just won't stick.

So you must do the spark test on a grinding wheel and then you do know for

certain."

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#2

Re: Iron & steel . . .

ThomD

>I think the possible answer is neither sparks, just the carbon or other alloying elements in the steel. Which is why the more it branches and the more it sparkles the greater the HT potential of the steel.

Say, Steve, if your dad is a T&D maker, does he know where the elephants of the tool world go to die? I need some cast parts for a project, old mill tables etc...

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#3

Wrong. . .

Todd Hughes

>Both Cast iron and wrought iron [two different materials] both sparks very well when you put them on a grinder. Cast iron sparks are red small and long with not many bursting like stars....but it is still sparking. Wrought iron has bigger red sparks with even less star bursts, steel will have more star bursts acording to how much carbon is in it. A high carbon file will spark with lots of bursting sparklers....wrought iron or cast iron will not spark like this but they both for sure spark and you don't have to "beg" them to spark..

I have sparked many hundreds of pieces to see if it was high carbon, low carbon or wrought iron.

Would be unusual to have to spark test a piece to see if it cast iron or cast steel since normaly you can just tell by what the thing is if it cast iron or steel. Also cast iron is fragile and breaks into pieces like a clay pot and when you look at the break it will have open pores...Cast iron objects will be cast in molds while cast steel is forged to shape. Guess thier are some modern alloys that could be cast but I am talking about tradtional cast iron and cast steel. Cast iron can not be hardened while of course cast steel can be and is why it is used for edge tools. Somthing like a plane body that was cast in a mold would always be cast iron and not cast steel.

Lots of people have misunderstandings about what is the difference between things like cast iron or cast steel or wrought iron or mild steel etc. so things like this is not uncommon to hear.....Todd

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#4

I guess this plane must be . . .

steve mackay

>some sort of heavy aluminum or something. Still can't get any sparks to speak of. But I learned something.

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#5

Because you are a maginet and I am steel

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#6

Dang hit the post button too quick...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Man o' man this post reminded of that song. I still hate it...

Now it will be stuck in my head all night long... :6(

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#7

Sorry ! How 'bout a Bee-Gees tune ?

steve mackay

>

Re: Iron & steel . . .

#8

Nooooooooooooooooooooo

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I don't want speak the brothers Gibb!