Re: Hardenability?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Thanks a lot, Don! Since the regular-size solid cast chisel is more expensive than even the considerably larger laid-blade chisel, then either the cost of solid was really high back then, or else the solid cast chisel was so much more in demand from the customers that L&IJ White could get a premium price for it versus the laid blade chisel.
I checked a couple of older catalogs offering plane blades--the Greenfield 1872 and the Sandusky 1877. These catalogs were 30 years prior to the L&IJ White, right?
Both the Greenfield and Sandusky catalogs were way into marketing what appears to be solid cast steel:
Greenfield, 1872: "Please notice our new and superior manufacture of Extra Cast Steel Plane Irons. By our improved process, we produce irons of perfectly uniform shape, size, and finish....." [they go on to make claims about their heat treat properties].
Sandusky, 1877: "Silver Steel Clipper Irons, Full Polished. We desire to call the attention of the trade and mechanics in particular, to this comparatively new feature in Plane Irons. These goods were first introduced by us at the International Exhibition of 1876, where they attracted general attention from the trade and mechanics. The orders received for these Irons since their first introduction, have been so encouraging that we are induced to present them generally before the trade, knowing that the merits they possess will readily be observed by the mechanic who uses the best tools.
The whole material from which these goods are made is manufactured expressly for us for this purpose. The goods are highly polished--presenting the appearance of being nickle-plated. These Irons are designed for the mechanics--those who understand good tools and their use."
What was in the marketing air in the 1870's was the finish and appearance of the tools. Old-fashioned appeared to be out of fashion: "Perfectly uniform shape, size, and finish" and "The goods are highly polished--presenting the appearance of being nickle-plated".
Shiny perfection was in fashion. No romanticism about leaving forging marks on the steel--looking like nickle plate was preferred. I see no claims about solid cast being an improvement over laminated--the argument is based primarily on appearance.
Putting all this together, I kinda get the feeling that solid cast was a marketing triumph over laminated, and had been for at least 30 years, and L&IJ White charged more for it because they could get more. I wonder if any other vendors were still offering laid-blade chisels or plane blades as an option, circa 1900.
Thanks again, Don.
Wiley