Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Cast steel

Posts

Cast steel

#1

Cast steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Gentlemen and ladies:

If an iron is marked 'Cast Steel', what does that tell us about its date of manufacture? When was the heyday of cast steel, and when were the latest cast steel irons made? I am thinking particularly of Sheffield irons.

Thanks!

Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#2

Re: Cast steel

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Wiley,

According to Ken Roberts.."Some 19th Century Woodworking Tools".

The development of Crucible Steel, is credited to Benjamin Huntsman, who moved to Sheffield in 1742,

and took 10 years of experimentation to develop the process, so that would date items marked "CAST STEEL" to later than 1750 ish.

Can't really comment on when it drifted out of use but probably into the 20th century at least.

Brian Read has a good article, on different steels over here...on Wiktors amazing website:-

http://www.wkfinetools.com/hUK/z-UKReading/ironSteelAlloys/ironSteelAlloys1.asp

And Simon Barley, has a good article (I understand, this one has since been re-written with some clarifications) but an excellent article nonetheless.

http://www.wkfinetools.com/hUK/z-UKReading/steelAndSaws/steelAndSaws1.asp

The proliferation of "marketing descriptions of steel" like "Double Refined Extra Spring Steel" tend to become more

common towards the end of the 19th Century, so that might indicate a basis for dating perhaps.

Regards

Ray

Re: Cast steel

#3

Re: Cast steel

Joel

>Cast steel starts being common in tools in the very early 19th century, although it was used earlier. It stops being used as a mark by ww2 I think - although there are several processes, not just the curcible steel process that used the cast steel mark.

Re: Cast steel

#4

Re: Cast steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Joel,

That makes sense. Don McConnell has an excellent post on OLDTOOLS which suggests that steel produced by electric furnace may well have been marketed as "cast steel", though it differed in method from the older crucible process. [http://swingleydev.com/archive/get.php?message_id=77201&submit_thread=1#message]

Could you comment on this line of thought as well: I would suppose that a 'cast steel' tool could in principle either be solid forged or laminated, since the tool itself will have been forged and heat treated. Now if a tool is marked 'cast steel', and in addition is laminated, does that shed any further light as to when it may have been made. In other words, do we know about when (in Sheffield, say), commercial blade makers stopped laminating?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#5

Re: Cast steel

Joel

>you have 2 questions here.

1 - Don is correct.

2 - dating by method is imprecise as these process you used for decades. Most lamination stopped by WW1 but my guess is that it continued in some areas. Also what's better a laminated tool that was made to be inexpensive and a contemporary solid blade that at the time was more expensive to produce?

Re: Cast steel

#6

Re: Cast steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Joel,

That's helpful in regard to lamination.

I was not trying to re-initiate the laminated vs. solid war--only interested in the date aspects. However, I would suppose that, for two identical steels, the superior one is the one whose forging and heat treating creates the best combination of hardness, toughness, and sharpenability for the intended task. I would think that it could be either the solid tool or the laminated tool, depending on a whole bunch of case by case details.

Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#7

Re: Cast steel

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Keep in mind, Wiley, you asked about the use of Cast Steel and Joel is really answering about the use of the STAMP "Cast steel". The cast steel stamp was used only at the very end of the 18th c. I don't know if anybody knows how prevalent cast steel was in tools that weren't stamped (earlier).

And it's correct (and often misconstrued) that the stamp tells us nothing about whether a tool is "laid, lined, laminated" or not. I have tools stamped cast steel that are and aren't laminated.

Adam

Re: Cast steel

#8

Re: Cast steel stamp

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If the tool is solid cast steel then the stamp is on cast steel, if the tool is laminated, then the stamp 'cast steel' is actually stamped into the wrought iron backer. Not that that means anything.

The White catalogue of 1912 lists both laminated and solid cast steel tools, haven't seen later references.

Stephen

Re: Cast steel

#9

Re: Cast steel

Dean J in MN

>To add ... The write-up on the chisels from the Seaton Chest (end of the 18th C) shows the fact that cast steel and laminated were not tied. The small chisels were solid "cast steel" and the larger ones were laminated. It makes sense to me, there is no real economic advantage to laminate a small tool.

-Dean

Re: Cast steel

#10

Re: Cast steel

ThomD

>I agree with that it is pretty time consuming to weld parts together then forging them to shape compared to working with pieces of plate, if one had the option. The same economies of scale that might automate the forge welding could also automate working with plate. Unless the materials are truly a large percentage of the finished price it is hard to see the savings. When it gets to which style is better, the economics come into a different view. People working with the plate rarely seem inclined to create the same forms as those working with the welded and forged stock. That is an econmic concequence if somewhat through the back door.

Re: Cast steel

#11

Re: Cast steel

Bill White

>Glad to see this post as I have a bunch of "W. Butcher-Cast Steel" chisels and a tennon saw. All are used in my shop, and have proven to be quality implements. I have NEVER been able to find any info on Butcher or these cast steel tools.

Not to hijack the post, but if there are links to info sites thyey would be greatly appreciated.

Bill

Re: Cast steel

#12

Re: Cast steel

Peter Evans

>I have a large W. Marples & Sons mortise chisel that is laminated. The chisel is dated at 1944 with the military arrow; so laminated chisels were being made well into the 20th C. The chisel is not marked "Cast Steel".

Cheers

Peter Evans in Sydney

Re: Cast steel

#13

Butcher *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Bill,

What mark do your chisels have?

There were two or three very useful threads on OLDTOOLS several years ago, with people asking questions about W. Butcher--manufacturing places and dates and marks. This is an old Sheffield firm, whose various marks existed from the early 1800s up til ca. 1900. There are numerous variations of W. Butcher marks and logos, and some very smart people are still trying to put date ranges on the various marks. Interestingly, W. Butcher set up shop in America right after the Civil War, seeking to establish crucible steel operation in the States.

Anyway, you can read all about it on the relevant OLDTOOLS threads. Follow the link below.

I have a set of Butcher plough irons, most with the W-crown-R logo on them.

I believe Adam has some Butcher tools also--they are highly regarded.

Click on the link below, and type 'Butcher' into the search block. Click on that and sort through the threads--there is lots of information that will leave you tantalizingly close to almost knowing when your tools were made.

Wiley


OLDTOOLS Search

Re: Cast steel

#14

Laminated Blades

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I have a reproduction of an early 20th century White Edge Tools catalog. This company was based in Buffalo, NY. They laminated their millwright's chisel blades, though one could also purchase them in solid blades. These chisels were for heavy use and mortising. It seems to me their use was the justification for the laminated blade.

Re: Cast steel

#15

Re: Laminated Blades

Todd Hughes

>which were more expensive...the solid steel or the laminated ones that they were selling?....Todd

Re: Cast steel

#16

Re: Laminated Blades

P. Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Todd, for some reason I can't find the catalog, but in my memory, the laminated blades are cheaper. I don't remember them being by much.

Re: Cast steel

#17

Re: Laminated Blades

Don McConnell

>L. & I. J. White offered their millwrights' socket framing chisels only in the "laid steel" version as far as I've been able to determine. But, they did offer their regular socket framing chisels in both "laid steel" and "solid cast steel" versions, which gives us a chance to directly compare prices. Here are those listings:




As you can see, the solid cast steel chisels were substantially more expensive than the laid steel ones. The smallest difference was the 7/8" chisel, with the solid cast steel chisel being about 35% more than the laminated one. The largest difference was the 2" chisel, with the solid cast version being about 67% more.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Cast steel

#18

Hardenability?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Todd and everyone else,

In the larger sizes, would the laid-blade chisels be easier to through-harden (cutting steel portion) than the solid cast steel? If so, I'm wondering if this might account for L&IJ White offering the millwright chisels in laid steel (only). Of course, there are numerous other explanations, such as (a) there wasn't enough demand for the millwright chisels to justify the cost of dies needed for solid forging, or (b) steel cost more than labor at the larger chisel size, or ........

Don, I am wondering about the cost and size difference between the millwright size chisel (laid), versus the regular framing chisels. Do you have that table from the catalog also? I am curious whether the millwright size with laid blades was cheaper or more expensive than the regular size in solid cast.

Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#19

Re: Hardenability?

Don McConnell

>Wiley,

Here is the listing for L. & I. J. White's Millwrights' Socket Framing Chisels, Laid Steel":


And, to make the comparison you were interested easier, here is their entry for "Socket Framing Chisels, Solid Cast Steel":


Any commentary seems redundant at this point, so I'll simply say I hope this helps.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Cast steel

#20

Re: Hardenability?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks a lot, Don! Since the regular-size solid cast chisel is more expensive than even the considerably larger laid-blade chisel, then either the cost of solid was really high back then, or else the solid cast chisel was so much more in demand from the customers that L&IJ White could get a premium price for it versus the laid blade chisel.

I checked a couple of older catalogs offering plane blades--the Greenfield 1872 and the Sandusky 1877. These catalogs were 30 years prior to the L&IJ White, right?

Both the Greenfield and Sandusky catalogs were way into marketing what appears to be solid cast steel:

Greenfield, 1872: "Please notice our new and superior manufacture of Extra Cast Steel Plane Irons. By our improved process, we produce irons of perfectly uniform shape, size, and finish....." [they go on to make claims about their heat treat properties].

Sandusky, 1877: "Silver Steel Clipper Irons, Full Polished. We desire to call the attention of the trade and mechanics in particular, to this comparatively new feature in Plane Irons. These goods were first introduced by us at the International Exhibition of 1876, where they attracted general attention from the trade and mechanics. The orders received for these Irons since their first introduction, have been so encouraging that we are induced to present them generally before the trade, knowing that the merits they possess will readily be observed by the mechanic who uses the best tools.

The whole material from which these goods are made is manufactured expressly for us for this purpose. The goods are highly polished--presenting the appearance of being nickle-plated. These Irons are designed for the mechanics--those who understand good tools and their use."

What was in the marketing air in the 1870's was the finish and appearance of the tools. Old-fashioned appeared to be out of fashion: "Perfectly uniform shape, size, and finish" and "The goods are highly polished--presenting the appearance of being nickle-plated".

Shiny perfection was in fashion. No romanticism about leaving forging marks on the steel--looking like nickle plate was preferred. I see no claims about solid cast being an improvement over laminated--the argument is based primarily on appearance.

Putting all this together, I kinda get the feeling that solid cast was a marketing triumph over laminated, and had been for at least 30 years, and L&IJ White charged more for it because they could get more. I wonder if any other vendors were still offering laid-blade chisels or plane blades as an option, circa 1900.

Thanks again, Don.

Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#21

Marketing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

Excellent characterization of the marketing process, the solid cast steel tools are cheaper and easier to make than laid steel tools and sold for more money.

Stephen

Re: Cast steel

#22

Re: Hardenability?

Don McConnell

>Hi Wiley,

Pretty much without exception, the anglo-american wooden stock planes from the 19th and early 20th century I've seen have all had laminated irons. If these catalogues do not have wording (and I don't think they do) to the effect that their premium plane irons are of "Solid Cast Steel" construction, then I would be very leery about assuming that. In fact, my wager would be that they were of laminated, or "Steel Laid" construction.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Cast steel

#23

I stand corrected

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Don,

Thank you. The catalogs do not specify 'solid' in their cast steel description. I was particularly going by their emphasis on the blades being 'perfectly uniform in size and appearance'.

However, facts are powerful things, and your experience says that my supposing is in error.

That would also undo the rest of my argument.

So let me start over, back at the L&IJ White catalog. I"m still trying to account for why the regular size solid cast framing chisels sold for more than either the regular size or the millwright size laid blades. ECON 101 says that it's because the customer demand was that much stronger for the solid cast steel blades. For whatever reason.

I would love to see a cost analysis of the solid vs. laid blade chisels, but can't imagine that anyone has done one. Have you seen any such thing?

Thanks again for straightening out my supposings,

Wiley

Re: Cast steel

#24

Don, what is the year of the catalog?

Tom Colligan

>As I'd like to find an Inflation Calculator on line and see how their costs compare to today's chisels. Thanks for your posts, Don.

Re: Cast steel

#25

Re: Don, what is the year of the catalog?

Don McConnell

>Hi Tom,

The L. & I. J. White catalogue from which those listings were taken is not dated. But, among the front pages is one which purports to show two drawings of their manufacturing buildings, one dated 1837 and the other dated 1909. This has a "then and now" feel about it, and the art nouveau style of the artwork on that page is also consistent with the time-frame. So I think a date of 1909 would be pretty close.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR