Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

lignum Vitae movement

Posts

lignum Vitae movement

#1

lignum Vitae movement

john lucas

>I just read a passage in the new David Ellsworth book and he is discussing green wood and wood movement. He makes the statement "Additionally , magnitude and direction o f movement often will be inconsistent rthroughout certain species. This why you would not generally use madrone burl, eucalyptus, or lignum vitae to make dovetail joints, at least not more than once.

Am I wrong in remembering that the bottom of a lot of hand planes use lignum vitae dovetailed onto the bottom.

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#2

Re: lignum Vitae movement

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>The German maker E. C. Emmerich (ECE planes) puts lignum soles on its more expensive smoothers, and maybe on other planes as well. I have had a smoother for several years and it has been very stable. ECE does not use a simple butt join for the sole--a crenulated pattern of dados is cut into the lignum sole piece, and a mating pattern is cut into the stock of the plane, which is cherry on my plane. So the lignum sole is mechanically constrained to the stock, in addition to whatever glue is used. No splits or signs of stress so far.

Wiley

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#3

Re: lignum Vitae movement

Alexander Grigoriev

>I think the point is that different boards and maybe different parts of the board move differently. Then, two boards dovetail-joined may break because they move differently.

For a narrow sole, with a single dovetail, it may not be a problem.

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#4

Re: lignum Vitae movement

ThomD

>LV used to be sold in a size that would accommodate bearings for the drive shafts of ocean going ships. Now it comes often in small vine pieces, often heavily waxed and unlikely to dry out any time soon. So part of the issue is whether you can get decent stock in the first place. Also, with equatorial woods there is not an early and late wood pattern to tell you what kind of grain is in there. The most innocent piece is quite capable of snaking off in any direction when cut.

The ECE plane's system seems to work well enough, but it is kinda weird. The extreme cross-hatching really undermines the structural integrity of a piece, it is what one does when one wants to make a surface easy to break off, though my planes are just fine.

Plane soles really don't make any sense anyway, and largely exists to make commercial planes look more techie. Most people would not bother with an ECE plane sole, lucky for them. I'm a long term fan of lamination for structural goals, but I really don't see the point on plane soles. OT though that may be.

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#5

machines *LINK*

paul womack

>Plane soles really don't make any sense anyway, and largely exists to make commercial planes look more techie.

The obvious idea (in the ECE tools) is to exploit the extraordinary wear and lubrication qualities of LV (which are also involved in the ships bearing application you allude to) without incurring the rather high material and fabrication cost of a sold LV plane.

This seem reasonable to me. The crennelated (or is it comb?) joint is because LV is famously difficult to glue.

BugBear


link to discussion

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#6

Re: machines

john lucas

>I certainly know what David was trying to say. As a segmented turner I've had to deal with wood movement issues. I could not find all the specs on LV movement last night. I thought it was not the best choice for his example.

I had read that LV was used on hand planes because of the wear qualities and had seen a few sitting on the shelves so I thought it was odd that David would pick this wood as an example of not wanting to use for dovetails. I know there are woods that move a whole lot more.

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#7

Re: machines

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The reason lignum vitae "plane soles don't make any sense anyway" is because beech soles don't wear out in a lifetime of use. And they don't need lubrication.

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#8

Re: lignum Vitae movement

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I wouldn't want to do too much dovetailing on lignum vitae because it is brittle and hard and can present problems when gluing (hide glue and garlic works). And how often would you dovetail lignum vitae anyway?

My problem is with the stability comment, lignum vitae was used for philosophical (scientific) instruments especially for navigation equipment. The wood was chosen for its stability when dried.

Stephen

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#9

beech *LINK*

paul womack

>And they don't need lubrication.

Mine benefit tremendously from the odd dab of paste wax.

BugBear


link to discussion

Re: lignum Vitae movement

#10

LV usage *LINK*

paul womack

>My problem is with the stability comment, lignum vitae was used for philosophical (scientific) instruments especially for navigation equipment. The wood was chosen for its stability when dried.

You've reminded me - also (famously) used for clock parts by John Harrison.

BugBear


link to discussion