Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Coffin Smoother

Posts

Coffin Smoother

#1

Coffin Smoother

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Besides the nice shape and good fit in the hand, I am wondering what is the purpose of the double tapered shape of the coffin smoother.

Does the sole of this plane make the tool operate differently than if it were rectangular? Does removal of the corners allow the blade to get down in the furrows left by the joiner, jack and fore plane better than any other shape?

Does the taper just remove weight? How would it compare to a strike block plane with the same blade pitch?

Of course coffins were that shape to save wood, they are more convenient to carry and the hole is easier to dig.

Stephen

Re: Coffin Smoother

#2

Re: Coffin Smoother

ThomD

>I don't know the answer to that, it is not only double tapered, it is differentially double tapered. One can come up with a variety of reasons for this kind of treatment, but I don't know whether any of them would be sufficient compared to an aesthetic preference. I mean one could point out weight, cost (pretty marginal), Finer cut possible with less sole in play so that it doesn't so easily twist ou of the cut, ergonomics, etc... But unless these were deal breakers, like making a knife where the blade was held and the handle poked into things, who is to say what the real reason is. Identifying a technical reason does not make it the reason. I have wondered at times what the point was.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#3

Re: Coffin Smoother *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Stephen,

Plane makers Clark & Williams have an interesting idea about the function of the coffin shape. Their idea is that the coffin shape plays a significant role in maintaining moisture balance in the body of the plane through seasonal changes.

C&W have written an article on moisture balance and other design aspects of the wooden plane--see link below. C&W make two observations: (1) that the escapement section of the plane has thin cheeks which gain and lose moisture quickly with seasonal changes; (2) that the thick and solid toe block ahead of the escapement, and the heel block behind the escapement will exchange moisture more slowly than the escapement section. The coffin shape helps offset this difference in moisture exchange between the solid sections of the plane and the hollow escapment section.

Here's how. The coffin shape produces the greatest curvature in the toe block and in the heel block. The effect of the curvature is to expose end grain along the sides of the toe and heel blocks, which enhances moisture exchange in these solid sections. The net effect is to bring moisture exchange in the toe and heel sections more in phase with the throat section, than would occur in a straight-sided plane.

Larry Williams may want to comment further, as I may not have captured his full thinking. The full article is referenced in the link below.

Wiley


C&W--Design/Tuning Considerations for Bench Planes

Re: Coffin Smoother

#4

Re: Coffin Smoother

Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ

>Perhaps less wood on the sole equates to less friction as you push it.

Mike

Re: Coffin Smoother

#5

Re: Coffin Smoother

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Smoothing planes in the 18th century were more boxy, more rectangular. I think the makers accentuated the taper and rounded the back for more comfort in the 19th century. The C&W planes look a little more like 19th century smoothers to me.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#6

Re: Coffin Smoother *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Warren and all,

Whelan (The Wooden Plane, p. 49) puts the transition from square smoothers to coffin smoothers in the UK and US at "about 1800".

This topic brings to mind an interesting plane in Moxon's Plate 4 (Joyner's Work). I've linked to this plate below. Moxon's joinery plate is said to come from Felibien, which dates it to late 17th century. Moxon's smooth plane (B.4 in the plate) is indeed rectangular. However, there is another plane (B. 7) which is shown toward the lower right of the plate. It is a distinct coffin shape.

The key to Plate 4 refers to the B.7 coffin-shaped plane as a 'Block Plane', but I cannot find any reference or discussion in Moxon's text to this plane. It's use appears to be to illustrate the sole of a plane.

And here is a curious thing: Josef Greber in The History of the Woodworking Plane refers to Moxon's Plate 4 and states that the B.7 plane is the first illustration of a toothing plane, pointing out that you can see the toothed blade protruding through the sole. And indeed, at about 5X to 10X magnification, it does appear that the iron of this plane is toothed. Why is only the toothing plane shown in coffin shape?

Incidentally, Greber, in discussing the shapes of smooth planes, says that they "often have bulging sides", and points to Durer's plane from the 'Melancholia' plate (ca. 1514) and shows a detailed photo of another European example, ca. 1500.

Wiley


Moxon, Mechanick Exercises, Pl. 4 (click=enlarge)

Re: Coffin Smoother

#7

Re: Coffin Smoother

Larry Williams

>Wiley,

In one way, Warren is right. We put a 19th Century rounded heel on our smooth planes. It does affect the look and makes it look a little more curvilinear than does the 18th Century heel which we do for Williamsburg and others who request it. If one is to work frequently with a smooth plane it's real helpful to have the big callous in the palm if you're working with an 18th Century style smooth plane. The 19th Century heel is more gentile on the hands.

I saw Warren's post at lunch but didn't have time to reply. I had intended to post Moxon's smooth plane image which was the only British style plane he illustrated and that was because there wasn't an image of one in the French book by F�libien. Moxon's book copied F�libien's other images.

I'm curious as to Warren's source. Perhaps he's looking at 18th Century American smooth planes which are more common and have a more rectilinear and less refined appearance than the British smooth planes. British smooth planes are so scarce that there isn't even a photo of one in the third edition of Goodman's book on British wooden planes and plane makers. In their revised 3rd edition of Goodman Mark and Jane Rees used smooth plane style panel raising planes to illustrate what these rare planes might have looked like. There is one in the Seaton Chest and it's curvilinear.

There are other features that affect how a coffin smooth plane looks. Bed angle is one thing, a common pitch plane requires a longer billet. The longer plane body stretches the curve over a longer distance. Most of the old smooth planes I've seen, including several American 18th Century planes, have been heavily tuned and have had a significant amount of the sole removed. These squat planes also look more rectilinear. We do have an early 19th Century British smooth plane with the 18th Century style heel. You may remember it, it's the one with the F. Stones "shear steel" iron in it. It's kind of a bulky looking plane and I'm not sure how representative it is. It is certainly less refined than an 18th Century Robert Wooding smooth style panel raiser I had the opportunity to examine.

Maybe Warren has a nice crispy new condition 18th Century British plane. If so, I'm sure I'm not the only person who would sure like to see it.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#8

Re: Coffin Smoother

Joel

>What key? I've looked at B7 a lot over the years, and if you look closely the iron looks toothed. where in the text is this key you mention?

Re: Coffin Smoother

#9

Re: Coffin Smoother

Larry Williams

>You must have good eyes, Joel. I can't see any teeth on the iron but I can sure see the iron and wedge sticking out the top and it's not bedded like a toothing plane.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#10

Re: Coffin Smoother

Joel

>I know I know I know but on my copy (the 1703 repro) there are horizontal lines in the mouth. and IIRC the first edition had them too only cleaner. now the angle of the iron and wedge don't line up with the throat and the sole has lines going the other way. So at the very least it's in a different style than the French based drawings (poorly drawn at that) - and it might have been added because Moxon wanted to add something new. It might be a scraper iron, it might be a smoother but it is really really odd to me that the text doesn't refer to it at all. I mean he does refer to B4 as a smoothing plane - you would think if they want to all this trouble to add in a new style of smooth plane they would just say in the text Br4 and B7 are smooth planes. instead it's like a completely ignored afterthought.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#11

Re: Coffin Smoother

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I was thinking about American planes for boxy smoothers. I had forgotten about the Moxon example. I think it likely that this shape was used for other planes besides toothing planes.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#12

Re: Coffin Smoother

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Joel and Larry,

Joel, I have the Praeger Moxon. There is a key, or legend, to Plate 4. It is right opposite the Plate. This is the only place in Moxon where there is any mention of plane B7 (that I can find). Says it's a Block Plane. The Glossary does not mention 'block plane' or anything related to toothing. As to the toothing.....yes, indeed, the iron does appear to be toothed (under magnification for these eyes!), just as Greber says.

Larry, do you have a loupe? Check it out under magnification. I'm allowing some artistic license on the bedding, because the bedding angle (as shown in the plate) does not line up with the plane's mouth. Greber's discussion indicates that there was considerable variation in the bedding angles of toothing planes on the continent. He says that Roubo shows one at 80 degrees, while the Zurich Museum has one dated 1677 which is 50 degrees.

Perhaps it is of some interest that Greber discusses the function of the toothing plane. His argument is that the true function of a toothing plane is to level a surface prior to veneering--to remove all unevenness, and says that a toothing plane is unequaled for doing this. He says that the oft-heard argument that it is for roughing the surface to get a better glue bond is not scientifically sound in light of today's knowledge.

Wiley

Re: Coffin Smoother

#13

Stability?

BradinOttawa

>I don't pretend to know a lot about wood movement or plane making but... I thought I saw an article somewhere about making wooden straight edges. In the article, it was recommended that the sides of the wooden straight edge be tapered similar to a coffin smoother. The reason being to expose end grain. I think the point was to minimise wood movement due to fluctuations in moisture content.

This is nothing more than wild speculation on my part!

Brad

Re: Coffin Smoother

#14

Re: Coffin Smoother

Joel

>pardon my ignorance but what is the Praeger Moxon? as far as I know the 1703 edition is a resetting of the original serial edition from 168? and the text and illusrations are exactly the same.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#15

Re: Coffin Smoother

Joel

>google is my friend.

is the key you are reffering to contemporary or modern commenary?

Re: Coffin Smoother

#16

Editors' Preface

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Joel,

This reprint is by Praeger Publishers, 1970 (LC 69-19363), published in the USA and printed in Federal Republic of Germany.

_______

The Editors' Preface states as follows:

"The original, serial edition included a separate half-title page for each number. These pages were eliminated in the 1703 edition, upon which the present reprint is based. Originally, there were no captions for the plates, and in no two copies that the editors have seen were the plates found in the same relative places."

"In the present edition, the plates have been grouped together and captions have been added on the facing pages. Where possible, the editors have employed Moxon's own words and have retained the original spellings. Numbers on the right-hand columns [NB: presumably the columns of the captions] refer the reader to the pages where the tools and their uses are discussed."

_______

Joel, it is this 'caption' for Plate 4 that contains the only reference I can find to plane B7, and identifies it as a 'block plane'. I am interpreting the Praeger Editors' words to mean that these captions were not contained in the "original"--meaning the serial edition. In context, that would seem to imply that the captions were somewhere to be found in the 1703 edition, but then the Editors do not explicitly say that the captions were contained in the 1703 edition. The Editors also seem to imply that the captions were in part their own work (for example, the right column numbering) simply because there was no standard edition and standard pagination for them to follow. As they say, "No two texts we have examined are exactly the same". The greatest mystery to me is (a) do the reprinted captions date back to the 1703 edition? and (b) to what extent were these captions original, and what features were added by the editors?

It is actually amazing how little is clarified by the Editors' Preface, and how much is left ambiguous.

Does your version have captions for each plate?

Wiley

Re: Coffin Smoother

#17

Re: Editors' Preface

Joel

>no - and IIRC the term "block plane" is mid 19th century - so at first glance it seems they are applying a modern terminology.

Re: Coffin Smoother

#18

Block plane = universal recommendation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Holy Cow. Did they just make it up? Maybe it's like whenever someone writes in to a handtool forum--anywhere in the world--and says "I don't know what to get. What kind of a plane should I get." Guaranteed that the first eight replies will be 'block plane'.

So I'm getting this vision about what happened with Praeger's Moxon.....

Editor's Ass't 1: What kinda plane is this B.7 plane, Marty?

Editor's Ass't 2: I dunno Alfie, what you do think?

Ass't 1: I dunno Marty.

Ass't 2: Maybe it's a block plane.

Ass't 1: Yeah, that sounds right. I heard that somewhere.

True story. That's how Praeger decided what to do.

Wiley