Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Posts

OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#1

OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Dean Lapinel

>Spent the last four days with Tai Goo taking lessons on knife making. The knife has an 8 1/2 inch blade of 1065 with nickle silver guard and butt cap, copper spacer and copper tipped tang (peened). It cuts ironwood & barbed wire with little dulling.

It still needs finishing work but here it is so far.


img

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#2

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post 

Dean Lapinel

>


img

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#3

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dean,

That is extremely handsome work! You say it needs work....Funny thing, but it looks perfect to me as is. The antler and the steel make a perfect match, as is. Wonderful work, and thanks for sharing.

Wiley

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#4

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Dean Lapinel

>Thank you Wiley!

Dean

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#5

Beautiful work, Dean!

Stuart Hough

>

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#6

What's your source for antler, Dean?

Bill Houghton, overcast in Sebastopol, CA

>I need to get a chunk of antler some time - my wife's favorite kitchen knife had an antler or bone handle that has decomposed pretty badly (didn't know they could do that). Where do you get it?

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#7

Re: What's your source for antler, Dean?

Dean Lapinel

>It came off the mountains near Tucson. I have a pretty big shed collection for future knives.

I hike the wilderness (no trails)for the beauty and often find sheds as an additional benefit.

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#8

Re: What's your source for antler, Dean?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You can find all sorts of bone, antler, and hides on ebay.

Pam

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#9

Great work, Dean. How does it cut?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#10

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>That's a great looking knife, Dean. Is it entirely forged and/or how much sanding and polishing was necessary? I'm in the process of finishing a bowie made of OCLS that is taking a lot of sanding to get out the surface defects.

Good job.

Bruce

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#11

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

Dean Lapinel

>yes, entirely forged. The surface needed a run with a coarse file then a finer file...a small bit of sanding by hand on the blade. Files for the guard, spacer and butt cap after they were forged, then cut by jewelers saw to shape (inside and outside).

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#12

Re: Great work, Dean. How does it cut?

Dean Lapinel

>It is the best cutting knife I've ever had. Cut chunks out of ironwood, cut about ten or so slices off barbed wire then cut ears off a brass bar and it still shaved hair.

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#13

Just keeps sounding better and better...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>What design element(s) did you utilize to achieve that performance?

Pam

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#14

Re: Just keeps sounding better and better...

Dean Lapinel

>Choice of metal, taper to the tip but slightly wider again at the clip, low heat and lighter blows when getting close, careful quench of the blade edge including the clip then proper tempering.

I was lucky to get no warping and a good balance of hardness and durability.The post tempering testing of the knife was quite extensive...I mentioned a few things but there were others such as comparison filing with steel of known hardness, bending in the vise in both directions to make certain it had proper springback.

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#15

Beautiful work Dean!

Andrew Lunn

>So what sort of further cleanup do you envision? Be sure to post pics of the knife when you are all done with it. Looks great already!

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#16

getting OT, here, but...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I noticed that Tai Goo is an associate of the American Bladesmiths. Have you ever looked at the extensive tests they and their blades must pass to enter those august ranks? Uffda!

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#17

Subtle, very subtle.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#18

Re: getting OT, here, but...

ThomD

>Nice knife Dean!

Most guys who make Journeyman or Master Smith can do unbelieveably work. The actual requirements to make a blade pass the test is not that difficult to do. You can find the "formula" on a number of sites and in some books. The reason it isn't the toughest part is that it is a lot to do with heat treating which is more a knowledge thing than the smithing which is a bigtime art and skill.

A blade that passes those tests has to be a good all arounder, though even the meaning of that is not agreed outside the ABS. Wouldn't be my choice for woodworking, and there is no such claim. What hurts a little is that out of self-respect a lot of the guys going in for the tests make their destructo knife about as pretty as you please. They may still cut after the tests they don't tend to look as purtey.

Here is, for example, Bruce Bumps MS set, presumably he forged the damascus steel also:

http://brucebumpknives.com/images/msknives.jpg

His test knife was a practical looking type:

http://brucebumpknives.com/images/mstest3.jpg

Re: OT: Forging I mentioned in saw post

#19

How about that!

John in NM

>I took that same class at PCC the last year before Tai Goo started teaching it. Our teacher was a tallish guy with long hair and a beard who was somewhat famous in knife circles for his pattern welded steel. We were discussing magnetite too since I was a geology student and there's a lot available in the sand around Tucson. He and a friend had collected and smelted the magnetite and made a blade out of the resulting iron, attempting to replicate early damascus production.

Very nice knife Dean!