Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Left-Eyed Sawing

Posts

Left-Eyed Sawing

#1

Left-Eyed Sawing

Robert Rothman

>I am a complete beginner, and am having trouble with perhaps the most basic techique of all: sawing accurately to a line. My sense is that at least part of the problem derives from the fact that I am both right-handed and very strongly left-eyed. Since my neck is not crank-shaped, this results in a parallax problem: it is physicaly impossible to align the back-and-forth axis of my sawing (right) arm with the optical axis from my dominant (left) eye to the line. The result is that typically I can wind up as much as one-quarter inch off when crosscutting a 10-inch wide board. I would appreciate any suggestions for how to deal with this problem. Thanks.

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#2

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Check out this article from Chris on his blog. He wrote on that subject in 2007.

Interesting experiment, but you may find the advice you need in there.

Bob, the pirate arg arg


How to see when sawing

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#3

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Robert,

I am totally blind in my right eye. Industrial accident at the age of 19.

I have no choice than to sight a saw cut with my one eye whether it is dominant or not. I am right handed.

I have been compensating for the loss of my right eye for 50 years. There is approx. one out of every 500 people who see with only one eye.

I have no problem sawing a straight line while following a pencil line. It's a matter of focusing on the teeth of the saw as it cuts. If the saw is sharpened properly there will be enough set in the teeth to allow you to stear the saw just a bit. So, the trick, is to not allow the teeth to cut any where other than close to the line.

Another thing to consider is, which side of the pencil line to make the cut. By focusing on the teeth, I can saw on either side of the line.

Perhaps your saw just won't saw straight due to being dull?

Relearning to site a rifle was much more difficult. I have to do it completely left handed.

Marv

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#4

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

James Watriss

>Hi Robert.

I'm cross-dominant, too. And I've learned a few things about sawing, as well as being cross dominant.

Since you're a beginner, you have an advantage. You're not used to sawing anyway. Given that, you may find that you're a little more ambidextrous than you think. It'll be awkward, but my suggestion is that you learn to saw with either hand.

I figured out a long time ago that for whatever reason, I was able to mirror movements with my left hand that I normally did with my right. For instance, handwriting... I can write left-handed... but it's mirror image. AND, it's very sloppy. But the movements are the same. Give it a try sometime... it'll feel completely alien, but the muscle movements are identical.

Point is, you're a beginner. It'll feel a little bit alien either way. Use that to your advantage, and try to learn things you wouldn't normally go for. You may find that as your competence with both hands improves, you'll be able to spot technique problems in one hand by trying the same movement with your other hand. The two hemispheres of the brain work differently, so the thought process will be different with each hand. But the muscles are still the same. You may find that helps you figure out a lot of things.

Another, simpler exercise... try working on coordination. Practice making 90-degree cross cuts. Don't look at the line, don't look at the wood. If you're sawing at a perfect 90 degree angle, the wood will be reflected in the blade, and the edge of the wood will align perfectly with the edge that you see in the reflection. Doesn't matter which eye you use. It's a geometrical fact. Saw at 90 degrees, and use the reflection to allow you to see what's going on with the saw. It'll tell you if you're holding the saw steady, and where in your saw stroke you're having issues. If you're sawing precisely, and the blade isn't wobbling, the reflection should be pretty clean, and not wobble. Get that down... if you can saw a straight line at 90, you can saw a straight line at other angles, too.

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#5

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Robert,

Learning to saw with the left-hand, as James says, may be the best answer. There is a lot of discussion of cross-dominance among competition shooters, and for long guns that is what they have to do. In your case, for a 26" saw, this is probably what you would have to do also.

There might be other solutions for backsaws however. One thing I read on a shooting site is that two-handed pistol shooting poses no problem for a cross-dominant person. This makes me wonder whether two-handed sawing would work (for backsaws). One could saw two-handed by finding an appropriate grip on the saw you now have.

Another possibility is the actual two-handed saw by Glen-Drake (see link below). By getting both hands on the saw, you may be able to find a body position that gets your eyes where you want them--you could try it left-eye only, or both eyes open which gives you better depth perception.

My suggestion would be to play around with getting two hands on the saw you now own, and see if that makes a positive difference. If it does, then it's down to practice, and you might consider the Glen-Drake saw.

One other thing comes to mind: A kerf starter, again, a Glen Drake idea. The kerf starter would ensure that your first cutting stroke is in the right place. This might be enhanced by marking the line in a bright color, like use a red pen, so that the line you're sawing to really jumps out.

Wiley


Glen Drake: Two handed back saw

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#6

PS on Japanese saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>How could I forget?! If the two-handed deal helps, consider a Japanese saw also, which lend themselves easily to two-handed use, plus you can get a bit more distance from the saw which might help with parallax.

Wiley

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#7

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>In reading about your problem, I was reminded about something my driver's ed teacher said. He said that some kids are taught to line up some part of the hood with the center line or the edge of the road. But it is much better to move your eyes around and just gain a feel for where you are on the road. Perhaps there is some beginner's trick that will not work so well for you, but is unnecessary in the long run.

This afternoon I was sawing with a Disston saw I have used since 1955. Thinking about your problem, I tried sawing with one eye closed. I tried right hand right eye, right hand left eye, left right and left left. I could do all the combinations alright, but the one I was most comfortable with was, surprisingly, right hand and left eye.

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#8

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

Bill Houghton, overcast in Sebastopol, CA

>I found out this year (at age 60) that I have the opposite problem: left-handed and right-eye dominant. Up until then, I saw myself as strongly left-oriented physically. But my saw cuts are pretty straight and clean.

The basic rule is practice, practice, practice. Hand tool skills are just that: skills, acquired through practice.

But some tricks:

The saw has an existing kerf to follow, it will. If you get your kerf started wrong, your saw will happily follow it, eager as a golden retriever, even as you try to correct it, using up a lot of your curse word allowance for the week.

Whenever possible, saw to two lines. Lay out your cutlines on both the width and the thickness of the board. Once you start your initial cut on the corner of the board, swing the saw up to near vertical while cutting down until you've established a kerf through most of the thickness of the board. Then swing it down so it's nearly flat across the width of the board and, lining it up to your layout line, cut gently until you've established a long, shallow kerf across several inches of width. Now, gently bring the saw up to use these two kerfs to establish a kerf that's both vertical and aligned with your intended crosscut. You may have to repeat this several times as you go, and, if you see the cut going off course, return to holding the saw low.

For cuts that have to be carefully aligned, it's better to cut a bit on the waste side and clean it up (search the messages for "shooting board" for some discussion of how to clean it up) than to try to make the cut perfect.

Get your stance right. You want the motion of your arm to be kind of like a steam engine's driving rod - straight and aligned with the cut, with your shoulder and hand aligned with the cut. You also want the height - the relationship of your body to the wood and the saw - to be right. Saw horses or saw benches, for big crosscuts, are better than the top of your workbench.

Don't rush it. The weight of the saw should be enough to make the cut; your job as sawyer is to guide it. If you find you're gripping the saw handle tightly, or pushing too hard, you'll cut badly. Your motion should be about as vigorous as you would use in, say, throwing a ball to a three-year-old (well, maybe a little more; but not much); if you feel like you're in the finals of your bowling league, lighten up.

Sight the length of the saw. Is it straight? If not, this could be part of your problem (although some of the saws I use regularly have a slight curve over their length. this is not ideal, though).

If all this is working well, and the saw's still going off course, it may well be sharpened or set wrong. Don't do this next step until you're convinced that it's not you, it's the saw: take a sharpening stone and run it gently along the side of the saw teeth on the side toward which the saw is cutting. Try it again, and see if it helps.

But, again, the key is practice, which includes a patient understanding that you won't be as good at first as you are later.

All this took longer to write than it would have to have shown you; that is, of course, the unfortunate part of the Internet. So, if you're still having trouble, seek out an old dude/gal in your neighborhood who knows how to use a saw and ask him/her to show you.

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#9

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

Don in Vancouver,WA,USA

>In addition to the eye/aiming problem make sure your body is positioned so your arm/saw swing in a plane. I found moving my right foot/leg behind my left gives a more planar saw cut because my forarm, elbow , upper arm move in a plane with the shoulder as the point of rotation. All tips and techinques only work as well as the number of times you have praticed them! PRACTICE PRACTICE PRACTICE!

Re: Left-Eyed Sawing

#10

One more thing...

James Watriss

>It's an odd suggestion, maybe.

When you're sawing, I'd pay more attention to what your elbow is doing. Your hand isn't going to go anywhere in relation to the saw, and as long as the saw is in the wood, there's not a lot of room for error there, either. But paying attention to what your elbow is doing will give you a good clue as to where your stroke is going wrong.

Last thought... first stroke is the most important. Once the cut is started, it's going to go more or less that way. If you start it crooked, it's going to continue crooked. Any attempt to correct mid-cut is doomed to frustration, because either the saw is too stiff to allow such a thing, or it's flexible enough that the change in course will keep the blade bent, and the whole thing will go haywire. Get off to a good start, and the rest will follow naturally.