Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

David Denning on cabinetmaking

Posts

David Denning on cabinetmaking

#1

David Denning on cabinetmaking

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I read a bit of David Denning's 1891 book on cabinetmaking thanks to a link posted by Peter Evans on this forum on Saturday. Denning felt that he was working in a golden age of cabinetmaking and that the furniture of his era was superior to that of all previous eras. He probably did not see eye to eye with contemporaries Gimson, Barnsley and Morris.

As was mentioned last Friday, Denning said that the fillister plane was unsuitable for cabinet work, so I was curious how he actually formed a rabbet. He writes (page 169) "Mark its limits with a cutting gauge, cutting as deep as convenient; then with a chisel cut away a little of the wood to the line. This forms a kind of guide for the plane, with which the rest of the work is done. The fingers [left hand] then act as a further guide to the plane, and many use no other, even when beginning to cut a rabbet." Does anyone use a chisel to start a rabbet? There is no mention of a snipesbill, either here or in the section on moldings.

Also on pages 82-83 Denning writes "As jack, trying, and smoothing planes are made with both double and single irons, it should be said that the latter, though cheaper, are not suitable for cabinet work.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#2

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

Dean J in MN

>Does anyone use a chisel to start a rabbet?

I do if the rabbet isn't too long. For example, a case back I just use a rabbet plane and my fingers. But smaller scale work I find it faster to rough out most of the rabbet with a chisel and finish up with a rabbet plane.

-Dean

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#3

rising to the bait

Larry Williams

>While using your fingers for a fence when using a skewed rabbet is easiest when starting with light cuts, you'll find control is almost automatic when using a square rabbet.

As to Denning's double iron comment, he lived in a common pitch world. Other than a few craftsman made infills, I have yet to see an old double iron plane bedded at anything but 45� or the British 47 1/2�. I'm convinced double irons were a compromise to facilitate high volume production and their advantage was a better and more profitable fit into the modern wholesale/retail marketing system. The current bevel up fad pretty much debunks the idea that double irons are as effective as single irons with proper cutting geometry in controlling tear out.

A good example of what's effective can be found in the evolution of Karl Holtey's planes. He started out making double iron infills, copying the old British designs. Then he moved to a bevel up plane which, unlike some others, had adequate clearance angles. Holtey is now producing his ultimate hardwood plane, a single iron bevel down plane at middle pitch. Maybe someone should tell him that 55� is middle pitch, not York pitch.

Had he been inclined to listen to a back-woods Arkansas carpenter, I could have told him what works well in hardwoods a dozen years ago. ;-)

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#4

Re: rising to the bait

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>So you have been out looking for old double iron planes with high bedding angles? It doesn't seem strange to me that you haven't found any to speak of. What does seem strange is that anybody would be looking for such a thing. Because only a person with no idea how to use a double iron plane would want such an item.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#5

Am I missing something here?

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Warren,

I thought cap irons were supposed to make the plane function like a higher angle tool, forcing the curl of wood up higher. As I understand it, Larry thinks they don't do anything. I thought I recalled seeing planes offered in both configurations. I thought the double iron configuration was more expensive.

My wooden planes are so worn, that sole patches were needed. And maybe I made my patches incorrectly because I feel as though my cap irons interfere with the patch when I adjust them close to the end of the iron. Or it could be that the wedges interfere with the patches when the cap iron is so adjusted. I guess I'd better go look. But I'm pretty sure I'll find that all of my cap irons are pulled back from the edge.

Frankly, I'm happy with their performance.

Adam

P.S. I fence with my fingers when the wood is soft or the area won't be seen (like a rabbet for backer boards. But when the wood is harder, a greater number of passes is required to maintain control. So I have either wasted away with a chisel or plowed a 1/4" or 1/8" shoulder then wasted the remainder with a chisel, depending on the length of the stock.

I think Larry is failing to mention that when a rabbet plane is new like his are, the corners along the sole are nice and square, so finger fencing is easier. When the corners get worn down, the rabbet won't find a shallow rabbet as easily.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#6

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

Charles

>He didn't use a chisel to start the rebate. He used his cutting gauge to score a deep line. Big difference. Once you have a deep line to work to, the chisel work shouldn't present a huge problem. It definitely wouldn't have in that era.

Beyond that, he just wielded a plane to remove wood to an incised lines.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#7

Re: Am I missing something here?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>"I thought the cap irons were supposed to make the plane function like a higher angle tool"

Adam, there are a few important ways in which a double iron plane does not act like a higher angle tool. One is that the actual cutting goes on at a lower angle, resulting in a finer finish. You would not try using your chisel at a scraping angle if you wanted a fine surface. Another difference is that the lower angle is not so abusive to the iron, because there is more of a shearing cut and less of a sideways force on the edge. You would not abuse your chisel with a high angle. Think about turning where a low angle cut "cutting the wood the way it wants to be cut" results in a fine surface and long edge life.

The force required to push a double iron plane varies a bit with the cap iron placement, but I think that if you hit the sweet spot the force is less than a high angle plane.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#8

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I'm with Charles. Because I'm left-handed, I don't like using my Record fillister with the fence. Deeply scoring the line, I use a chisel and then whatever seems to be the best strategy; my Record fillister, a chisel, a router plane, my Stanley plow. Generally I finish with the router plane to even out the depth.

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#9

Somewhere I have an issue of "Wooden Boat"

Bill Houghton, overcast in Sebastopol, CA

>with an article on making a short-shanked gouge from one of those automotive lug nut wrenches that show up in the free pile at garage sales.

Apparently, in planking certain types of boats on which the adjacent planks are rabbeted, it's common to whack out most of the rabbet with a gouge, probably because the planks have compound curves, before finishing up with other tools.

In making some of our porch handrailing, I used a method similar to what Denning describes to start a location for the rabbet-like plane work.

Seems that there is more than one way to skin a rabbet (sorry, I couldn't resist).

Re: David Denning on cabinetmaking

#10

Will skewered rabbit do instead?

Alex Grigoriev

>