Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Posts

Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#1

Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Ed DeLauter

>I need recommendations for applying an ammonia based walnut stain to an oak piece I just completed.

I have heard the stain is not colorfast and will fade similiar to aniline dyes if exposed to sunlight. If it does fade does the color remain true or get a greyish cast? If true, would applying shellac over it help slow down this process.

Is a washcoat or sanding sealer (water-based?)needed BEFORE applying the stain to ensure better color uniformity? Does the ammonia based stain raise the grain like aniline dyes do? And would a sanding sealer be a good idea to seal the oak pores before applying a varnish topcoat?

When I made up the sample stain board for my client I really didn't think they would pick this particular stain over the others. But they like the idea of a "natural" stain made with local walnuts. Whatever.

If you have hands on experience with the ammonia stain I really would like to hear from you.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#2

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You haven't described what stain you are asking about- just ammonia, or something else. In any case, I did lightfastness testing of basic stains on mahogany and they were exceptionally fleeting, way more so than the synthetic dye stains. For that matter, the "natural" color of walnut is fleeting in sunlight.

I always stain walnut and I used a mineral pigment stain consisting mostly of burnt umber. Applied to a properly prepared surface I don't experience the "muddying" of the luster some fret about when using a pigment stain.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#3

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

R.J. Whelan

>Ed ... I tried this several years ago following a discussion on Badger Pond.

The stain looked great for a couple of months and then started to go gray (fortunately this was on a test piece and not a finished piece of furniture). I kept the sample around the shop for a couple of years (my shop has lots of windows on the north wall and gets a good bit of sunlight most days); the whole piece had a definite gray cast that would, probably, have been unacceptable in any environment I can imagine.

Based on my limited experience, I would not recommend this method.

RJ

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#4

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>This stain has been used for many, many years. I have used it for at least 25 years. The stain probably fades over the years, but usually the wood is darkening over this time from exposure to light and the finish will retard both processes. The ammonia itself darkens oak somewhat, so it adds to the color, but it also makes the stain penetrate better, especially in oak pores because it affects the viscosity. It tends to a more natural look than the aniline dyes. You don't want a wash coat as that will also affect penetration and ammonia has some peculiar interactions with shellac. The excess ammonia evaporates as the stain dries. If you use a smoothing plane there will be no "grain" to raise; if you sand you will have this problem as with water stains.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#5

What is it? Any link?

Alex Grigoriev

>

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#6

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Ed DeLauter

>Bill,

RE: "You haven't described what stain you are asking about- just ammonia, or something else."

I am referring to a homemade walnut stain that uses ammonia as the base.

It is to be used on red oak. Not sure how else to describe it.

Ed

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#7

oh...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You mean walnut colored, not stain involving walnuts. I am having some bottoms put in chairs and the lady (very old school) is staining the bottom material with some walnut husk concoction which she didn't divulge. I had that on my mind while reading you note. I was hoping to gain insight as to what she was using.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#8

Re: oh...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes, we make the stain from walnut hulls. Soaked and somewhat fermented in water and ammonia added. Also known as brou de noix.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#9

Re: Walnut stain from WALNUTS....

Ed DeLauter

>Bill,

Sorry. This is homemade WALNUT stain made from, believe it or not, walnuts off my property! Ammonia is the carrier and breaks the outer covering of the walnut down. The walnut "juice" is absorbed/mixed into the ammonia.

No mystery concoction: quart glass jar, broken up walnut husks, (not the nut or shell surrounding the nut) and non-detergent ammonia. At least a couple months of transfer time is required; 6 months to a year is even better. You need to top the jar up periodically as the liquid ammonia is absorbed.

Strain through a cotton cloth to remove particulates.

Ed

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#10

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Warren and I did this in Williamsburg to an oak bench we made. I felt the stain was a bit too weak. I was looking for a darker color. Don Weber boils his brew down to concentrate it a bit.

I painted my Nicholson bench with walnut hull dye. The bench is doug fir. The result was an ugly grayed color. I applied several "coats". Not to worry. You can warm up that color with some nice boiled linseed oil. I think my bench, which appears in almost every issue of PW, looks pretty good. The result is a nice tobacco color (about the only thing nice about tobacco in my opinion).

Adam

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#11

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The condition of the hulls when you start the process has a lot to do with the outcome. I have had some inky batches that I would not consider using full strength and some that I wished were a lot stronger.

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#12

learn something new every day..thanks

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#13

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Ed,

Most vegetable stains like walnut hulls are fugitive and do fade with age. Ammonia however is a chemical stain and does not suffer from the same rate of fading, the wood usually darkens with age.

The Arts & Crafts white oak was fumed with ammonia and the stain seems to be fine on those old pieces.

You probably shouldn't seal before you stain as that will effect the stain take up into the wood. To get even take up on end grain just use a thinner mixture, thin with water. The stain will raise the grain, even fuming will raise the grain.

Sand smooth, fill if desired and seal with thinned shellac before you put on the varnish.

I have used both staining techniques but never together, I either fume or stain with walnut hulls (decocted in water with a tad of alum as a mordant). I can see using them together can present problems as you might not be able to determine the outcome of the color.

Ammonia is a chemical stain that alters the wood and while walnut hulls are fugitive, the latter contain tannic acid so they are also chemically changing the wood as well as imparting some color.

Good Luck

Stephen

Re: Ammonia based walnut stain....pitfalls ???

#14

Hi Ed, A bit more info please...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Guess I've been in the back of the tool shed too long. I've never heard of this. Could you pleas explain this in more detail? A web site perhaps? What color does it make wood? I'm very curious.

Thanks, Scott