Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Plow with a router plane?

Posts

Plow with a router plane?

#1

Plow with a router plane?

cj in western NC

>I'm wondering whether I should break down and buy the veritas small plow plane or just continue to make do with my veritas router plane equipped with a fence. For all you proud owners of the plow plane, I need help convincing SWMBO why I should get the plow. Maybe I should wait until the LARGE plow plane comes out...

Thanks, Chris

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#2

Re: Plow with a router plane?

Bill Houghton, sorta sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>I've never tried plowing with a router plane, so can't answer the comparison question. The plow can be purchased with irons from 1/8" to 3/8", a far wider range that stock router plane bits, and handles beautifully, almost intuitively.

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#3

Depends

roninkokomo

>How often do you "plow" and what does that mean" i.e. what kind of work are you doing.

Router planes do a great job under the right circumstances, but if you are routinely plowing grooves of any length, get a plow plane.

What kind is up to you.. I have a 45, 55 and a wooden plow... which is my preference for most jobs

ron

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#4

Re: Depends

cj in western NC

>Thanks for the feedback.

Bill H.: Good point on the various size blades.

Ron: I'm preparing to do some grooves for a door using frame and panel construction. I've done grooves with a router plane before, but it is a hassele to constantly adjust the depth of the cutter. I imagine a plow plane would accomplish this task faster, but would it be better? Sometimes the router plane leaves somewhat jagged grooves...especially in difficult grain. Are plow planes much better? I've read opinions about plows in general that critisize their usufullness on anything but even grained wood.

Chris

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#5

Re: Depends

Bob Demers

>''I've read opinions about plows in general that critisize their usufullness on anything but even grained wood''

Well, yah, any and all molding planes or planes used for creating joinery are designed for tame straight grain woods.

That is not to be view as a limiting factor in their usefullness, but just in the nature of the beast.

Bottom lines, plow planes, providing their fence can be adjusted and remained straight, are a joy to use. Quick efficient and no hear defenders required, wow!

Bob, who of course has a few wooden plows and a shiny new LV small plow plane. Its a keeper!

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#6

PLow

roninkokomo

>Plow plane will be much better for what you are doing

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#7

Plough and Router planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Chris

There is a place for each.

Some may point to the obvious, such as the plough plane has blades of differing widths. However, when I plough with a router plane, I score the sides with a knife, and chisel out the waste at the side walls. Then it is not vital that the blade fits the groove exactly.

More important for me is that beginning and end of a groove. The router plane excels in stopped grooves ..



You cannot do this with a plough, as illustrated by this stopped rebate. What happens is that you end up creating a curved edge.



... and then you must clean it up with a router plane.



A plough thrives on through grooves.



For half blind dovetailed drawers, or mitred boxes ..





So you need both. Heh.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#8

Re: Plough and Router planes

Dean J in MN

>

... and then you must clean it up with a router plane.

huh -- and here I just use a chisel... :)

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#9

Re: Plough and Router planes

cj in western NC

>Excellent points (and pics) Derek! Hadn't really thought about stopped grooves and through ones. I now feel fully justified to add the plough plane to my toolbox. Should I wait for the large plough plane?

Does anyone know whether Lee Valley will be rolling out the large plough plane anytime soon???

Chris

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#10

Ohhhh, plow planes, bet...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Ya just can't own one.

;^)

Re: Plow with a router plane?

#11

Re: Plough and Router planes

David Cockey

>"Does anyone know whether Lee Valley will be rolling out the large plough plane anytime soon???"

Haven't heard any mention of it from Rob Lee.