Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Saw question

Posts

Saw question

#1

Saw question

Dean Lapinel

>For dovetails I can use most of my saws (including Japanese) but I prefer the LN. The LN is easy for me to intuitively hold at a proper angle. With the others I have to check and double check until I get a good start.

For tenons, crosscuts I cannot duplicate that pleasure.

My vintage gents is too small but does work well. My Disston backsaw (around 15ppi) with its 12� long blade should work well (Tom Law sharpened as were all my saws) but it tears a wide kerf from (I guess) the wider set.

Since I collect and use, I was thinking about the Wenzloff, Adam Cherubini (If he makes a �specialty� smaller crosscut), Gramercy, LN carcass or another vintage saw to fill the void. There are backorder issues with some of these fine makers and my only hesitation with LN is that my shop is starting to look like a LN warehouse. I think I should diversify a little more.

There was a nice discussion that I can�t find (about a year ago) about fleam angles and more. I lost that reference but actually, I never really grasped the concept.

Two questions:

Where can I learn more about the variables of concern (set, fleam) as relevant to function?

If expense wasn�t an issue but pleasure was, which would you recommend that is readily available?

Re: Saw question

#2

Re: Saw question *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dean,

Where can I learn more about the variables of concern (set, fleam) as relevant to function?

If expense wasn�t an issue but pleasure was, which would you recommend that is readily available?

Beings you asked, here's a guy who will ask you the right questions and give you the right answers and will then make you the best saw you can imagine that will do exactly what you need the saw to do. He has been known to even make the tote/handle fit the users hand. I could say more but you need to get it from him. He has a website. His name is Andrew Lunn and you can email him from his website.

Marv


Great Saws

Re: Saw question

#3

Re: Saw question

joel

>Attached is a chart we gave out at WIA.

There are basically 6 or 7 major criteria for saw teeth (ignoring the handle which is also a very very maybe more important criteria.

You cannot look at any one of these criteria in isolation but you can look at combinations and see how they interplay. for example: a fine pitched saw will start easier so you can make it more aggressive but unless you file the gullets correctly it will cut real slow.

Of course hand filing gives a randomness to the teeth which makes them cut even smoother without getting stuck.

note the chart is 2 pages.

I will do a blog entry soon with more information but I thought the chart is relevant to the discussion now.

Re: Saw question

#4

Re: Saw answers - here is the line *LINK*

joel

>This time I will attach the link


Saw Spectra Chart

Re: Saw question

#5

Re: Comments on cross-cut Adria

Dave Mount

>Hi Dean--

I have an L-N dovetail saw and an Adria small tenon saw in X-cut. I haven't had the pleasure of using some of the other high quality modern maker saws that you list, so I can't offer a very broad comparison for you. Actually, it's even a little hard to compare the Adria and L-N because of the need to parse which differences are due to maker and which are due to saw type (XC v rip). However, I can say that the Adria is in the same league in terms of manufacture/fit/finish, came exceptionally sharp, feels good in the hand (actually, I like the handle slightly better than the L-N as my palm is apparently wider than many), and tracks very, very well.

Starting the saw takes some getting used to, as it is so aggressive that is takes a light touch to start it smoothly. I had similar problems when I first got my L-N DT, but I had to take another step "lighter" to learn to work with the Adria XC. However, it is quickly learned, after which its aggressiveness becomes a virtue rather than a vice. Despite cutting quickly, it cuts very cleanly.

Bill Tindall wrote recently about having an epiphany in dovetailing when he first got an LN DT saw. I had exactly the same experience and would recommend a quality new DT saw to anyone. I bring this up because I got the Adria second, so I'd already had my "so this is what a quality saw is like" moment. That said, I think it is just as worthy of praise. It's another one of those saws that seems to just know what to do if you learn to just let it do the work.

One final note -- I recall that starting Adria saws has been discussed before, and seem to remember something to the effect that Adria may have changed the filing pattern over time to address this. My Adria saw was purchased as new old stock from someone that bought a bunch of saws early on, so my saw may reflect an earlier filing pattern.

Food for thought,

Dave

P.S. Whatever you get, get the handle made from something that contrasts visually with the LN handle. Sounds silly, but at a glance the saws don't look that different and it's nice to just instinctively reach for the right color handle.

Re: Saw question

#6

Hey Marv

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>What is your ebay seller name? I went looking for your reconditioned vintage saws the other day, and a senior moment ate my memory of where to look.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Saw question

#7

Words to live by.......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>"It's another one of those saws that seems to just know what to do if you learn to just let it do the work." Dave Mount, Dec. 2008

Re: Saw question

#8

Re: Saw question

ThomD

>For a western saw, I would say get Tom Law to sharpen anything you pick up at a flee market. My independence is the best western saw I have used, and I think he was the guy who sharpened those, could be wrong. No obvious reason why it works so much better, and I have tried a few other 200 dollar saws.

Re: Saw question

#9

Re: first question, where to find info

Bob Demers

>A good source is the Disston Handbook on saws, edition 1917, avail on line as a PDF (Toolemera?)

In the chapter Construction of saws and how to keep them work, starting at page 149 you should find the info you seek.

Particularly, starting at page 158 is an explanation of Fleam angle.

Perhaps what makes this one very clear is the illustration with the file in the tooth. Check it out

Bob, in between medical procedures..the things you have to submit to in order to serve your country, sigh! :-)

Re: Saw question

#10

Re: Hey Wiley

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

Thought you'd never ask :-))

My user name is marvco64

I don't think it's case sensitive.

I have two saws up for auction this week. Both are outstanding of course and have many hours invested in them. One of my favorite sayings is "if ya can't gloat, why do it?" You will really like the tenon saw.

Thanks for your interest,

Marv

Re: Saw question

#11

Re: Tom Law

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I heard from a semi-reliable source that Tom Law retired from saw filing over 3 years ago.

Marv

Re: Saw question

#12

Re: Tom Law

ThomD

>I wouldn't be surprised, I have a NOS saw from Independence just in case. And my dad also has one, which pretty much means it's unused also. That is were stuff like the new LV saw comes in. It's nice to save the better saws for... what, I am not exactly sure...

Re: Saw question

#13

Thank you all!

Dean Lapinel

>This has given me a good head start...nice links and facts. I will be pounding metal on an anvil this week OOT so I can't reply again until I return.

Re: Saw question

#14

Re: One more post (sorry, a bit long)

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dean,

It is easy to over annul-ize something of this nature and end up with more confusion than help. It is also easy for a professional to slip out of a teaching mode and into expounding on details that might be irrelavent to a beginner who is just searching for some basics to help them get started.

You could buy any one of the saws now being offered by the various expert saw makers of today and in a surprisingly short time get accustomed to any one saw's idiosyncrasies. No saw maker will make a saw that will fit every hand or do all the various things that people use these saws for.

If I were about to lay out some hard cash for a really good saw or saws, I would be inclined to buy from someone who is willing to give me some personal attention, someone who would quickly respond to my emails and my questions. Keep in mind, saws that are already designed and in catalogs and websites are what they are. In most cases what you see is what you get, with few exceptions. Most of the saws mentioned in this thread will do what you want to do and those are the saws that most people are buying these days. While one person will brag about one particular saw, another person will brag about what someone else doesn't like. A lot of what you hear are biased opinions based on personal experience.

A very useful thing for you to consider would be to learn how to file those little saws. After all, the saw is mainly a piece of sheetmetal with teeth filed along one edge. It's mainly about the teeth no matter which saw you buy. The angle of the handle you can get used to in a short time, but if the teeth aren't right, nothing about the saw is right. This is the reason you want to communicate directly with someone who will question you about what you are using the saw for and what kind of different woods will you be sawing, etc. etc. Andrew Lunn is one of those people. He makes saws to order, one at a time. I posted his website in an earlier post. I admire his artistic craftsmanship and attention to detail.

Once you get a good saw that you are happy with, if you can sharpen it yourself, you can either maintain it as it was originally when it was first sharpened or you can experiment with different rake angles and points per inch and bevel angles and amount of set in the teeth. When your saw begins to get dull, it becomes a different saw.

But now i'm getting off in that area of too much detail, but it's something to think about for the future.

Have fun,

Marv

Re: Saw question

#15

Re: Saw question

Tony Zaffuto

>Tom retired from saw sharpening a few years back, although he still sells rehabbed saws. Those in the DC area can visit him at the Patina gathering this coming March and buy a few saws.

I may be mistaken, but I thought it was Pete Taran who did the Independence saw sharpening. For what it's worth, I have an old Disston that Pete sharpened and an old Jackson that Tom sharpened (both a few years back) and both are a joy to use. Compared to a number of other vintage and modern saws I have, they are the equal of all.

T.Z.

Re: Saw question

#16

Re: Saw question

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Tony,

From your post....

Compared to a number of other vintage and modern saws I have, they are the equal of all.

Can you be specific as to what makes the two saws that Tom and Pete sharpened equal to all others? Considering that rake angle, bevel angle, PPI and set are the main factors in making a saw cut well, Tom and Pete probably couldn't know to duplicate how your other saws were filed, perhaps the differences that are inevitable actually don't make all that much difference among the various saws you use?

I have watched Tom's video and have read Petes treatise on sharpening saws. Both have their own styles that differ significantly. For example, Pete uses a rake angle block at the far end of his file while Tom didn't use a block at all. He just filed by sight and feel. I think he had his wrist calibrated and indexed for different degrees of angle.*grin*

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Saw question

#17

saw parameters

paul womack

>I caught a glimpse of this (on an overhead) in one of the Berea shots.

Since everybody else is ignoring this, I'll chime in and say "wow"; this is the neatest and most concise information on this topic I've ever seen.

One (technical) gripe - for web use I'd prefer HTML over PDF.

BugBear

Re: Saw question

#18

Re: Saw question

Tony Z

>Marv,

I speak subjectively not scientifically. My criteria is the saw I grab first. Now this begs the question, "what makes me reach for a specific saw out of a group of 5 or 6"?

I am aware of Pete Taran's methods and the way Tom Law sharpens and I would agree with your comment that maybe differences in technique of the guy sharpening does not matter for how I use the saws. I will add that for the one saw that Pete sharpened and the several I have that Tom sharpened, I commented before the sharpening of the types of wood that I work: primarily cherry, and also poplar for the drawer sides, with occassional white oak and some walnut.

Again, I don't get hung up on the technical details, but rather what saw feels right (and I do have one saw in particular that feels like crap, but I will not mention the sharpener, other than this saw was done about 4 years ago).

T.Z.

Re: Saw question

#19

Re: Saw question

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Tony,

Thanks for your response,

If you were to look at the one saw that feels like "crap" with magnification and compare it to the saw that Pete or Tom filed, can you see a significant difference in the filing of the teeth? In asking that question I'm assuming that you are referring to the way the saws cut, and not the way the handle feels.

The reason for my question is, I started out filing saws only for myself, then I started reconditioning saws and selling them on eBay and then people started sending me their saws to be sharpened. I've never seen a saw that was filed by Pete or Tom that I could compare to my own sharpening. Just wondering if I would see a noticible difference in the way the teeth look and then relate that to how the saws cut. I have never gotten any complaints so I guess I'm doing something right. Just to gloat a little, I have done some sharpening for a furniture maker who does it for a living who used to have Tom sharpen his saws. When Tom retired he started looking for another saw sharpener. He sent me a saw for a test drive, so to speak. When he got the saw back, he immediately sent me several more saying that the saw performed at least as good as saws that Tom sharpened for him. "hey, if'n ya cain't gloat, why do it?"

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Saw question

#20

Re: Saw answers - here is the link

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Joel,

This is a great chart. Would make a nice poster. Or insert to your Tools for Working Wood catalogs.

But here at end of year, I'm thinking about calendars. Know what would be great--an olde-tyme saw calendar, with maybe even a couple new saws to contrast, plus this chart. With historic discussion accompanying each saw, and remarks about toothing styles or whatever is known about the old saws.

I would buy a saw calendar in a heartbeat. Along with some other stuff.....

Wiley

Wiley

Re: Saw question

#21

Re: Saw answers - here is the link

joel

>Thanks to the both of you for your kind remarks. I will be posting the table ( a color version) on our website in a few weeks - just too busy these days with the holiday season.

Re: Saw question

#22

Hear Hear!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'm lovin' all the saw talk lately!

Re: Saw question

#23

Our good friend...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Patrick Leach was in on the original design as well.

Re: Saw question

#24

Hear Hear?!? Harrr Harrr!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Here, Hear, Awww... Where's my dinner?

There I go typing on a empty stomach.

What Dave said I firmly believe in. I've been tryin my hand a Japanese saw and man o man, it's a different world when you go half way across it. I can drop my LN DT saw and just go. It took a bit of time to get use to it (not it to me:^) but now, I wouldn't want to live with out it.

Re: Saw question

#25

Thanks, Joel, the graphics are great.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>