Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA
Adam Cherubini
>I suspect many edge tools were knife edged in the days of yore. Paring chisels were probably much like sets of carving tools. Underhill says the name "firmer" comes from the French "Femoir", which he says was doubled beveled, made like an axe- a steel edge with iron folded around it.
There's malleting and then there's malleting. 18th c american craftsmen generally worked with woods that were failry easy to cut. And sharp tools in skilled hands tend to hold up well. I think patterns like the Stanley 750 are certainly not reflective of 18th c patterns and their popularity may be a result of their indestructibility.
So to answer your question, I've never broken or bent a chisel nor have I ever broken or split a mallet or chisel handle. And note that my handles have no ferrules.
I think the biggest issue with respect to malleting (and the only one I concern myself with) is edge retention as it relates to bevel angle. I'm convinced that for my work, low bevel angles are best. The chisels in my box were all 25 degrees or lower. But they were also stropped so they may have been a bit higher functionally.
Frank Klaus came over to visit my bench. I had a full set of chisels I had made to show him and ask what he thought. He played with them for a bit and we chatted about how thin they were and how well they penetrate when chopping dt's. I asked him about his chisels: "Do you use marples?" "750's" he replied. "750's" said I, "They're not chisels, they're punches!". He left quickly after that. (hmm wonder why). To my surprise, he returned 10 minutes later and asked me what I thought of Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce chisels. I told him honestly that I thought that they were functionally very similar to the chisels I made. They are thin, their sides are relieved, I liked the length and balance. And Frank said, "Good, because I just bought a set".
So there you have it: Even Frank Klaus likes thin chisels! We'll have to keep our eyes open for a set of Stanley 750's at the NJ Crafts tool auction from an anonymous seller.
(I'm not holding my breath)
Adam