Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Posts

Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#1

Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

John Hoffman

>Hi Adam, and all.

I was reveiwing the handout on Chisels and noticed that the cross section of the parer appeared to be beveled on both sides, looking life a knife. Was this correct?

Also concerning the thin-ness of the firmer, do you think they hold up to much mallet pounding? I saw the Blue Spruce dovetail chisel which was thin but not intended for any significant pounding. Am I getting your point? I liked your presentation by the way.

Thanks

JH

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#2

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Michael Holden

>John,

cant speak for Adam, but regarding the blue spruce chisels: I spoke with Mr. Jeske at the show and after Adam's presentation. Asked about striking the chisels with a mallet. His response was to grab one of the original style chisels and drive it with a wooden mallet cross grain deep into a block of maple! OK, I am no longer too concerned about striking my blue spruce chisels (grin).

I also asked about making a set of chisels similar to Adams', and it would be possible based on the original set. This is now on my Christmas list. Main difference is the sides, Adams' have little or no bevel on the sides.

Hey Adam! are you chisels sides parallel or do the have a slight bevel?

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#3

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Dean J in MN

>One of the first things I did was put a square on one of Adam's chisels to be sure he had a tiny bit of relief on the sides. There was. So, they aren't "beveled" but there is an angle there. If there wasn't I was considering slapping him with a turbot! :)

-Dean

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#4

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Adam Cherubini

>I suspect many edge tools were knife edged in the days of yore. Paring chisels were probably much like sets of carving tools. Underhill says the name "firmer" comes from the French "Femoir", which he says was doubled beveled, made like an axe- a steel edge with iron folded around it.

There's malleting and then there's malleting. 18th c american craftsmen generally worked with woods that were failry easy to cut. And sharp tools in skilled hands tend to hold up well. I think patterns like the Stanley 750 are certainly not reflective of 18th c patterns and their popularity may be a result of their indestructibility.

So to answer your question, I've never broken or bent a chisel nor have I ever broken or split a mallet or chisel handle. And note that my handles have no ferrules.

I think the biggest issue with respect to malleting (and the only one I concern myself with) is edge retention as it relates to bevel angle. I'm convinced that for my work, low bevel angles are best. The chisels in my box were all 25 degrees or lower. But they were also stropped so they may have been a bit higher functionally.

Frank Klaus came over to visit my bench. I had a full set of chisels I had made to show him and ask what he thought. He played with them for a bit and we chatted about how thin they were and how well they penetrate when chopping dt's. I asked him about his chisels: "Do you use marples?" "750's" he replied. "750's" said I, "They're not chisels, they're punches!". He left quickly after that. (hmm wonder why). To my surprise, he returned 10 minutes later and asked me what I thought of Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce chisels. I told him honestly that I thought that they were functionally very similar to the chisels I made. They are thin, their sides are relieved, I liked the length and balance. And Frank said, "Good, because I just bought a set".

So there you have it: Even Frank Klaus likes thin chisels! We'll have to keep our eyes open for a set of Stanley 750's at the NJ Crafts tool auction from an anonymous seller.

(I'm not holding my breath)

Adam

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#5

Re: Torture tests

ThomD

>One thing FK said about his tool choices a few years back was that he had switched to English type tools, to put it loosely, so that when he did seminars people would see tools they could identify with and buy. He said that about the time that good western tools started to flood back into the market. We have moved into a separate space now. We have a whole new generation of tools with micro feature sets that separate them. Good thing for tools, we should see some progress.

As far as pounding on them goes, one can pound a nail into a piece of wood, unless one off-centers it, no tool as hefty as a chisel should be at risk. I do feel I may have seen this movie though. Klausz actually makes furniture. A lot of people, I think, are mostly serious tool buyers, not users. The way this played out in the knife world was that people read the knife tests and media, and then went and tried the tests for themselves. They didn't buy a given survival knife because they expected to use it, they bought it because they were fascinated with the tests in mags and wanted to beat the heck out of knives, as they had seen in torture tests. So makers should be careful what tests they popularize, because those can end up being the main reason people actually buy stuff. Which is OK as long as everyone is on the same page.

Speaking of double bevels, it's interesting that Japanese chisels are made so the the geometry is off-center a little as though a knife edge. It's a lot more subtle than that, not dead center, but then the western tools like slick aren't dead center either.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#6

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

John Hoffman

>Right but that was the bench chisels. I read on thier site that the dovetail chisels are not for pounding. I have not heard different on that and the dovetail chisels are the most similar to the chisels that Adam was talking about.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#7

Pounding chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have used some of Adam's chisels for five months. I use them both with a mallet and by hand. I have no fear that they will break, but I would not call what I do with them "pounding". I would not call what I do with a mallet and mortise chisels pounding either. The more skilled you are the more you can get away with delicate tools. There is a reason Stanley has made tools that are much more robust.

About a dozen years ago I had a chat with a Williamsburg blacksmith about why 18th century plane irons were so thin. He felt that it was a reflection of superior craftsmanship, that workers in the 18th century were more attuned to their tools.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#8

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Michael Holden

>John,

It WAS the dovetail chisel that Mr. Jeske drove cross grain into the maple block with a mallet!

The original blue spruce dovetail chisels!

He does NOT recommend chopping mortises with them, but chopping hardwood dovetails are what they ARE designed for.

Mike

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#9

Re: Pounding chisels

Dean J in MN

>Thin was "in" in years past. And I agree, the thinness should be of no concern if the tool is used properly. No prying, even when you're not chopping a mortise for example. If anything Adam's chisels were thicker than I expected them to be. The chisels from the Seaton chests were quite thin, 1/16" at the cannel for a 1" wide chisel! And as thin as 1/32" on the 7/16 chisel. I'd love to have a set of firmers that are right around 1/16" at the cannel.

-Dean

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#10

Well, make some

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>So long as one is not wedded to a socket (a tang is acceptable) chisels are simple to fabricate, especially so in carbon steel which is available at any machine supply house and anyone that can heat treat can reliably do carbon steel. You can likely make a set for only a few dollars a chisel.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#11

Re: Well, make some

Dean J in MN

>Bill -- Any tips on the bolster? That seems to be the barrier to entry for tanged tools. I spoke at length with the blacksmiths at Wmsbrg, and the bolster was the most difficult part.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#12

Bolster ideas

Jamey Amrine

>Dean,

I have been considering the same issues. One idea I had was to find some iron nuts that could slide up the tang, and then drop the chisel tang-first into a block of steel with a hold drilled in it as a swage block, and pein the nut down around the tang. If you create a shoulder on the tang, and maybe do a little silver soldering for good measure, I think this would work ok and could look all "vintagy."

That's the best I have come up with so far. I intend to try this soon, perhaps as a local club project.

Any thoughts on good steel thicknesses for paring and firmer chisels?

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#13

not necessary

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Anyone with a hacksaw can make the chisel Dave makes. They might not be as pretty depending on your patience, if that is important. I have to work tomorrow so it may be in the evening when I will post a picture of what a simple home made chisel looks like. They don't have conventional bolsters, as they are unnecessary to provide a chisel that will withstand more bashing than a chisel should ever get.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#14

Re: Well, make some

David Cockey

>I asked Adam in Berea how he made the bolster on his chisels. His response was along the lines of it was a secret he isn't ready to reveal, and I'd have to figure it out myself. He thought about it for a moment and repeated the same answer.

So I'm still wondering how he does it.

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#15

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Don McConnell

>Adam,

You wrote (in part):

"I suspect many edge tools were knife edged in the days of yore. Paring chisels were probably much like sets of carving tools. Underhill says the name "firmer" comes from the French "Femoir", which he says was doubled beveled, made like an axe- a steel edge with iron folded around it."

This simply doesn't square with the following entry from Thomas Sheraton's _Cabinet Dictionary_, c. 1803:

"CHISSEL. An instrument much in use amongst cabinet makers, joiners, and stone masons. The general names of which are the following; forming chissel, paring chissel, mortise chissel, ripping chissel, skue chissel, blunt chissel, for breaking walls, and various iron chissels for stone and sculpture work. Observe, for all stone and sculpture chissels, the steel should be in the centre, as also in the skue sort used for carving, but all the others have their steel on the front side."

The laying of the steel at the face of the former/firmer and paring chisels would militate against sharpening them to a knife edge. This, in turn, is consistent with Moxon's description of grinding a single bevel on a plane iron and subsequent observation that the other edge tools used by joiners were treated in the same manner.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#16

Re: how to make a bolster or socket chisel laminat

chichi

>It is true that the bolster is the most difficult part in making a chisel. I have no idea how Adam does his ,but one way is to start with say a 5/8 or 3/4 round mild steel bar for parent stock ,neck down the end with a spring fuller, draw out a short round tenon. Use a monkey tool(4in piece of 1 in sq. mild steel with a hole through the center the long way, long enough to accept the tang and slightly larger than the tang so it can slide over the tang) to bang against the bolster to establish a flat surface where the handle rests. Cut the 5/8 to say 3 inches and draw out a thin blade of your choice.

Take a piece of high carbon steel(section of old file) , put a feather edge on the end that will face the handle. Taper the end of the mild steel chisel so the high carbon bit plus the mild steel will be slightly thicker than the desired result. Wire or balance the steel bit to the mild steel and place in fire mild steel down. Slowly raise temp to red heat,flux the two pieces with borax ,put back in fire . Raise temp to welding heat and bring the chisel quickly to the anvil. A firm tap or two should get the two pieces stuck. Re flux and bring back to welding heat. Take out and strike more forcefully until the high carbon is welded. Shape to suit the purpose, anneal overnight in wood ashes. Next day bring up to yellow heat until steel loses magnetism and quench in water or oil. Clean off and set on a hot bar and run the colors, stopping when the edge is yellow.

I have made dozens and this is not as bad as it sounds, but 20 yrs. smithing is a plus.

Another way is to make a socket separately and forge or arc weld to a stub tenon that will just fit inside the socket.

As others have said, probably overkill. I make heavy timber framer chisels and do the sockets by arc welding and later forging out the bead to make pretty.I could demostrate if people near Wi. are interested.

Bob

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#17

Good grief!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Can we see one of your socket chisels?!

Wiley

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#18

Chichi is that u?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The one that hung around Badger pond?

Just curious...

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#19

Re: Chichi is that u?

chichi

>Nope. Where is Badger pond?

Bob

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#20

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I meant that I think they honed back bevels and very likely unintentionally. I've seen very few chisels in the wild with truly flat backs. Even in my Father's generation, they weren't flattening backs of chisels on sand paper on glass or granite inspection plates. Were they 10 degree back bevels? No.

I think whenever a person is "just honing the last little bit of blade, they are essentially back beveling. When I flatten chisels, I flatten them to the bolster, or at least to the shoulder. I want as much of that back on the stone/paper as possible. And my chisels have mirror polishes the whole way.

If you only hone the last 1" say, and on one stroke you push the chisel to 1-1/4" or 1-1/2", into the area you don't routinely flatten, I think you just rounded that back. You can't have a shiny spot you've honed repeatedly, and a dark patch you haven't remain co-planar.

I think the old timers didn't keep their stones flat. I think they polished their edges, and some amount of back beveling was unavoidable. While not particularly intentional, it wasn't detrimental either. Pretty sure Mack Headley sharpens this way. Of course, he's a carver at heart.

Adam

Re: Adam's Chisel Presentation WIA

#21

It dried up a few years ago...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It was a forum like wood central. When it was shut down alot of the people there came here and to sawmill creek.