Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

Posts

Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#1

Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Short version: Bought a plough plane off Ebay. Arrived yesterday. Need to gloat. See link below for the item.

Extended version: There is some cursive handwriting on the top of the boxwood body that says "W. L. Curtis bought of David M. Spencer in Milan, Ohio. 1843. $9."

So I'm thinking maybe somebody decided to create a little instant provenance for this plane by writing this on the plane. But then, how did they come up with Milan, Ohio?

With curiosity aroused, I checked a couple catalogs as to what boxwood ploughs went for in the mid-1800's. $6 to $7 is the ballpark for a catalog price. So maybe the $9 checks out for a retail price.

But who in Milan, Ohio in 1843 would have bought this plane? Looked up Milan, and it turns out that northern Ohio was booming in the 1830s and 1840s. Milan is between Cleveland and Toledo, bordering Lake Erie. Some local folks had a brilliant idea in the 1830s to build themselves a Canal, which would turn Milan into an inland port for Lake Erie. There were dry roads into Milan, so all the northern Ohio wheat farmers could get their wagons there, and load their wheat onto lake schooners. This turned out to be a phenomenal success, because once you were at Lake Erie, you could get to many lake ports, and I suppose the Hudson River and New York via the Erie Canal. So in the late 1840s, Milan was the largest wheat exporting port in the world, second only to Odessa, Russia--that's what is claimed. Still trying to get my head wrapped around that fact(?).

Alas, in a couple of decades, the railroads were built through central Ohio, and all the canals and covered bridges became a beautiful dream, and Milan returned to being a quaint village. But in 1843--yeah, someone might have needed a plough plane to make stuff for all the new wealth.

So maybe the writing on the plane is for real. Who knows? But I sure had a great time finding out about Milan, Ohio, the Canals, and Great Lakes shipping. Not to speak of the plane-making Copeland family, but that can wait another day......

Wiley


Plough plane with a story

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#2

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>What a wonderful story, Wiley. That is so interesting.

The plane's iron is made by Butcher? Is that also not a gloat? I wonder if this is original or a replacement?

The pictures that came with the eBay advert are no longer active. Can you post some please?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#3

Here are photos *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Derek. They were showing on my preview screen, I guess because they were cached in my computer. Or something......Anyway, see if this works.

Wiley


A. Copeland plough plane

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#4

So, is it boxwood or beech? Sure looks pretty.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#5

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Philly

>Very nice, Wiley! Yes, you certainly do suck - a good price for such a decent plough :)

Cheers

Philly

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#6

Re: Here are photos

Bob Demers

>Sure look to be in great shape, wooden threads and all.

NIce one Wiley

Bob

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#7

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Marty Adams

>Yes, I've been to Milan Ohio. It's a little farm town. I used to drag race at Norwalk drag strip just south of there. We stopped in Milan every morning for breakfast. We ate at the Invention restaurant. It's called the invention because Thomas Edison was born there in Milan. The restaurant serves farmer style breakfasts that keep you going until supper time. Just thought you ought to know.

Marty

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#8

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Brad Chenoweth

>Hi Wiley,

Milan is about 25 miles west of me. Neat little town, the birthplace of Thomas Edison, as Marty mentioned. His boyhood home is now a small museum. They have some neat items there. Milan was also the site of a working shipyard in that time period, so woodworking tools would have been common. I recall seeing a "shipwrights ladder" there, which was basically a length or turned stock split lengthwise. The rungs had rounded ends, which were captured in holes in the the legs, and held by metal plates. The ladder could be "folded up" by bringing the 2 half-round legs together, and easily carried. It's also about 20 minutes south of Sandusky, Ohio, which was the home of the Sandusky Tool Co., although that was a bit later, beginning in 1861, I think. Just thought you might be interested.

Brad Chenoweth, in Elyria, Ohio

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#9

Re: So, is it boxwood or beech? Sure looks pretty.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Pam,

Its solid boxwood.

In this auction's photo presentation, there was a rogue photo of a plane's end grain, and that photo definitely showed a beech plane--plain as day, with rays and everything. However, a close look at that photo showed an imprint 'Stanley Rule and Level' No. 35. I'm guessing a transitional Stanley, but in any case, that photo got mistakenly jumbled into this auction. And prompted a question as to the wood.

Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#10

Part of my sweetie's interest in genealogy

Bill Houghton, moderately nice in Sebastopol, CA

>comes from finding out about places, people, historical events (another part is finding the black sheep in her family - though she says the main part is tracking down all the interconnections). Sounds like you got way more than a plane, Wiley - you also got a sense of the place the plane fit into.

And it's held its economic value, too - one online inflation calculator I checked says that, in today's dollars, $9 is $198.11, so, after 165 years, your plane has lost only half its retail value!

That is one VERY pretty plane. I haven't gotten involved in the woodies, having enough on my plate already, but they're sure good looking tools. I've always appreciated the almost architectural use of molding patterns on the fences of the wooden plough planes - yours is particularly nice.

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#11

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Phil,

Thanks a lot! Hope all went well for you on the Berea trip!

Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#12

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Marty,

I certainly do appreciate knowing about Thomas Edison! Plus the farmer breakfast--my grandmother, who lived with us, grew up on the farm, and that's how she cooked. No nouvelle cuisine--you couldn't see the plate.

Thanks again, Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#13

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Brad,

Thanks! That is fascinating about the shipyard. I was reading on line that the old Milan Canal featured a drydock for ship repairs and so forth. It was actually a remarkable bit of civil engineering--they had to relocate the Huron River from its natural bed; build 2 or 3 locks to accommodate the 8-foot drop to the river; and there were towpaths and a covered bridge. Is any of that stuff visible today? I can imagine that time and tide might have taken it all away after the railroads took their business away.

Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#14

Re: Part of my sweetie's interest in genealogy

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

What you described about your wife--that's where I'm coming from too. Apart from how great these woodies work, they are replete with history and family connections. I'm still trying to piece together the Copeland family of planemakers.

And, as you mention, specifically about the ploughs--they didn't have to make them so beautiful. I guess it was a competitive thing--the ornament was expected. One interesting thing about this plane: the moldings on the backside of the arms which hold the fence, are radiused, as though they were turned just like the finial. That's unusual IME and implies a different build logic than if the moldings are straight across, as they usually are.

Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#15

Re: So, is it boxwood or beech? Sure looks pretty.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Well you surely got a good deal. I've been tracking boxwood ploughs for years, and usually they go for much more. Congrats.

Pam

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#16

Nice story, nice plane, and nice price too!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Yep You suck!

Nice score, let us know how it works!

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#17

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat

Brad Chenoweth

>Wiley,

As I recall, there is none of the structure left (it's been a few years since I've been there), but you can still see the large basin where everything was located. The canal system in those days was extensive, I've been told that you could travel all over the state, as well as to New York, by canal. There are still remnants left in various areas of the state, and several rail lines and hiking trail follow the old canals. Another fascinating sight is the lock system down on the Muskingum River, above Marietta, Ohio. They were built in the 1830's, and several are still operated today. They still use the original operating systems, they are actually operated by hand, and the gates are built of large timbers. Cool stuff!

Brad Chenoweth

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#18

nice plane, but not....... *LINK*

cooper suter

>....the nicest to come out of Milan OH.

The title has to belong to a local (Toledo OH) collector who bought the Montgomery Plow out of Milan's history museum in the late 70's.

(The only image I could easily find is Jim Leamy's copy of it.)

He paid about a hundred more for his than you did for yours, but it only came w/one cutter ;).

It's a nice plane though, I've gotten to hold it.

Coincidentally, the Montgomery Plow also was made in Columbus, and ended up in Milan OH.

Coop


Montgomery Plow

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#19

Re: nice plane, but not.......

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Cooper,

Holy Cow, what a magnificent plane! Maybe the emergence of Ohio Tool in Columbus is the reason that we have Alfred Copeland moving back to Chester MA in 1843 and starting a bed making business.

Wiley

Re: Been to Milan, Ohio? Way OT + Gloat *LINK*

#20

Re: Nice story, nice plane, and nice price too!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Scott!

This plough works perfectly. The screw arm threads are almost perfect. It has a riveted-on fence, and it is tight and lays up against the bottom of the stock nicely. It's all square, tight, and sound, like so many other of these old ploughs. I might add, don't let the plough bug bite you--it's the worst slope of all (that I have found so far).

The thing about ploughs is that you're up against finding irons, since almost none of these are found with their original irons. Even the one that the seller stuffs in the plane to sell you may not fit. Now I'm in the process of going through sets of irons to see which will fit with the original wedge. Matched sets of irons are tougher to find than good ploughs.

Wiley... getting carried away about ploughs, sorry