Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

Posts

Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#1

Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

wilbur

>A recent episode of the Wood Whisperer mentioned that when Marc Spagnuolo uses shellac, he gets the gallon can of Zinsser Bulls Eye shellac, mainly because it's cheaper than buying flakes and denatured alcohol to make his own.

I was wondering what would be the advantages of making your own? The only one I could come up with is that you could vary the tint/color (don't know the proper term here) of the shellac by making your own, by choosing orange, garnet, or super blonde, but then the Zinsser Bulls Eye shellac comes in clear and amber, and the Zinsser website mentions that their shellac can be tinted as well.

What am I missing?

By the way, I was really surprised to find that buying flakes and making your own was the more expensive option.

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#2

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

Joel

>Try it and find out.

The mixed to order flakes give you a harder, more water resistant surface that dries faster and harder. and of course the flakes don't go out of date

but as I started to say - don't listen to me at all - it's a simple enough experiment to try - just get good flakes and proper quality alcohol. I personally would never go back.

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Zinsser

Jim in Burlington On

>They have some patented process to keep the shellac good.It's mighty easy to apply IMO. The biggest difference is making your own shellac takes planning and cleanup of the mess. It needs to be dissolved and filtered and does cost way more. That said I like to make my own dark garnet shellac. If Zinsser made it in dark garnet I'd never make my own again. Older canned shellac used to have a horrible shelf life. Once opened you needed to use it up quick.

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#4

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Shellac effectiveness expires, and you never really know how long a can has been sitting on the shelf. And if Zinsser has added something to keep it fresh, that's at least one other ingredient and you don't know what it is. Personally, I think it's fun to mix my own.

Pam

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#5

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Here's what I like about dewaxed flake shellac....Dewaxed is more water resistant than waxed. Jeff Jewitt did testing several years ago and dewaxed shellac was competitive with lacquer for water resistance--not as good as lacquer, but close. Shellac containing wax, including bullseye, will be less water resistant than dewaxed.

Flake does not degrade. Does not esterify in solution, because it's not in solution. I mix up small batches in quart rubbermaid containers that I get from wally world, and the dry flakes which are still in the bag or can remain dry and maintain their potency. Fresh shellac dries quickly and is harder than shellac that's getting played out in the can--maybe Zinnser has solved this, but find out.

You want to be able to control the cut. If you can do that with Zinser, fine. But you need to be able to control the cut. For example, you may want to use your shellac as a resist coat over water soluble dye, like transtint for example. If you want to completely seal the pores at that stage, you might use a 2-lb cut. But if you want to only partially fill the pores, you might use a 1/2 lb to 1 lb cut. What I think is really a nice finish interior to case goods or drawers is a real thin cut of shellac--Krenov described this in one of his books. Use 1/4 lb to 1/2 lb. It imparts a sweet and pleasing smell (that lasts forever near as I can tell) and equalizes (to some extent) differential moisture uptake.

When it is dry and warm, shellac will dry very quickly. You get one wipe of it, at most two, and that's it. It's helpful to use a thin cut on days like that, because you get that second wipe before it dries. Plus you don't get a 'fat edge', which is just murder to try to straighten out, and which will happen if you use a 3-lb cut on a dry warm day (out here anyway).

Compatibility. If shellac is the final finish, then this doesn't apply....But, suppose you're coming in behind a seal coat of shellac with something else. If the shellac is dewaxed, it will be compatible with everything else. Everything will adhere to it. But if the shellac has wax, you have to make sure that the top finish coat will adhere. Polyurethane and polyacrylic won't. That's not a deal killer maybe, because maybe you don't use those--but my point is that you have to slow down what you're doing and find out. Whereas if the shellac is dewaxed, you can proceed without worry.

The end.

Wiley

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#6

P. S.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I've never had to filter the dewaxed flakes after mixing with denatured borg alcohol. Just use it straight away.

Wiley

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#7

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

R Payne

>I never got what I thought of as good results using shellac from a can. Probably technique on my part. Just for giggles, I got some flakes and mixed my own and got a good finish. Because of that I really don't care if it cost more or not. I also use everclear to mix the shellac. Denatured alcohol is ethyl alcohol with something added to make it poisonous. Usually that is methyl alcohol sometimes it is something that can be absorbed through the skin.

ron

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#8

Re: P. S.

ThomD

>Why are you guys in the states using denatured alcohol? When I visit I have picked up, relatively cheaply, a bottle of pure alcohol from a liquor store or department. I gather there are differences state to state on that, but it worked in Nashville. It's important that it have an uber low water content, but the 98% stuff available in some states worked great for me. I;m not tempted to nip at the bottle, and working shellac made with real Alcohol is like spreading icing.

I have also heard shellac looses it's punch quickly after mixing. I have, however, a batch I made 50-10 years ago, didn't work out, so I kept it around for routine things, and I am still using it today. Before I use it I put a tiny droplet on my fingers and rub it briskly, as long as it sets, it is good to go for what I use that stuff for.

Adding a few % of walnut oil to shellac, does not reduce it's utility, but so long as it is a drying version of walnut oil (no vitamin E), it will make the shellac quite a lot more water resistant.

The reason people mix their own is because of quality of materials, and because the average stuff in a can is designed for washing over knots or other print through problems. Shellac has uses from, gooey to ultra thinned, and you might as well know all the toxics that go into it. Shellac is a super finish and it can be made out of essentially food grade materials. For those who polish it hours at a time, it is worth knowing what went into it.

On the flip side, Krenov used the shellac out of bottles, diluted even further for a wash coat on some of his cabinets.

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#9

Hi Wilbur...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I've never mixed my own. I have used Zinsser's a bit. As stated it can be tinted. I like to cut in half and wipe it on. Cut a bit more than half and it's great for the inside of drawers.

There's a date on the bottom of the can that tells you when it was made. It's good for 3 years after that date. I'm experimenting with some finishes now and I top coated a piece of dyed mahogany with the can I had, it set up just fine... It was made in 2003.

I'll probably never make my own.

Re: Shellac: made from flakes vs. premixed?

#10

Flakes are just better *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I'm a snob, when it comes to shellac. I love the stuff. Flakes allow me to mix whatever I want. I keep 3 or 4 different ones around and have mixed them together for fun. Most times I don't filter because the gunk will go to the bottom anyway. However, Wiley I find it very hard to believe that dewaxed is more water repellent than waxed is. When shellac is dewaxed, an element, the wax, is taken out. Wax repels water. Buttonlac is especially resistant to moisture. That's my understanding. Buttonlac is less refined than shellac and seedlac is less refined than buttonlac. The less refined, the more moisture barrier though the more bug parts and other gunk is in the product. That was my understanding. Refining can clean up the product and result in more colors as well as make the product easier to dissolve and thus quicker to use.


http://www.shellac.net/information.html