Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Dovetail saw questions

Posts

Dovetail saw questions

#1

Dovetail saw questions

Craig

>I've been moving more and more to the hand tool side of woodworking lately and am trying to learn about dovetail saws and tenon saws. According to the "tools for working wood" website, the Gramercy saw works better because it's lighter and easier to control, but the Pax saw works better because it's heavier and easier to control. I'm confused. Are all of the higher end saws pretty much the same or is one type easier to learn to use than another?

I'm not really sure what to look for in hand tools so any pointers would be appreciated...brand names, length, teeth per inch.

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#2

hack style

paul womack

>At the risk of dropping you into a present controversy, I would recommend the new Veritas saw.

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=61974&cat=51&ap=1

By all accounts it cuts about as well as the other premium saws, but is much cheaper.

Although according to some traditionalists it is the Devil's work or worse :-)

BugBear

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#3

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Craig,

I don't think the weight of a dt saw is itself that big of a deal, within reason of course. My preference is for something of a medium weight. In my opinion the way the weight is balanced matters much more than the mere weight itself. I'd look for a saw that doesn't have a ton of blade under the back, as you don't really need it for dovetails, and I'd look for one that is in the 9" range and avoid anything shorter. I'd also look for a comfortable handle and avoid the clunky and ungainly ones made by places like Pax. In addition to the new saws out there, there are lots of nice vintage saws, and there are people you can pay to tune one up for you if you aren't up to the task yourself. Just more options to consider. Good luck.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#4

Re: The real answer

ThomD

>I'm one of those who wondered exactly why LV messed with a good looking saw look, and went with that plastic thing. I'm sold though, after the first time I used it. The weight is exactly what I want. A significant weight to help feed the cut, but I can't think of anyone thinking it's tiringly heavy.

Weight should be matched to the way a saw cuts, there are differences in teeth negative/positive angle, that determine how well it self-feeds without weight. The are differences in handle angle that will affect tooth pressure, so while there probably is a perfect weight out there, it would have to be considered as part of the package.

Imagine you had a geometry that made teeth very aggressive, like cutting into hardwood with the hook angle of a Japanese softwood saw. You probably don't want so much weight that it can't stutter a little and relieve what would be an unpleasant degree of aggressiveness in the cut. On the other hand, with a rather smooth-cutting resistant set of angles that feel a bit as if they skate on the surface, you might want the weight of the back to press in.

These factors could even vary if you and I bought the same saw, but I used it in 3/4" cherry all the time, while you used it mostly in 1/2" maple. You could have a harder hook up than me.

And then there is the issue of sawing style, this stuff will vary depending on start angles, or the amount of material you engage coming down. The variability in that exposure: some start on a corner and saw to the max diagonal, then level and remove the second triangle, constant changes in the amount of material in the cut, vs. parallel sawing.

From a beginner perspective, what I think is most successful about the LV saw is it seems they concentrated on making it smooth to start. As a result there is a slight loss of power. A production hand dovetailer, if they exist, would not choose this saw, but if LV actually planed it this way, then I think they were wise to choose easy start with medium cut speed over other alternatives.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#5

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is well established that I am not fond of spending money needlessly. That said, my ability to reliably cut dovetails improved markedly when I purchased the LN dovetail saw. I think the improvement came as a result of optimum teeth per inch, set and handle. It really was worth the money. I promptly sold all previous saws that were cheaper and didn't work out for me.

We have taught several dovetail classes and most students found learning with the LN saw was relatively easy. An occasional student preferred, and did better, with the "saw on a stick", aka Japanese saw.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#6

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Craig,

And then the saw gets a little dull and all the rules change.

Mainly what you want is a saw that cuts wood. If the saw is properly sharpened, any dovetail saw will cut dovetails. It's not exactly rocket science.

The main differences between one saw and another will be the rake angle of a rip profile, the thickness of the blade and the amount of set in the teeth. For sawing dry hardwoods you want minimum set in the teeth, just enough to prevent any drag in the kerf. When we talk about minimum set we are talking only a few thousands of an inch, maybe .004 to about .006. You really don't need much set because you aren't sawing very deep.

The LV saw that has been mentioned, if it's the one I think they are referring to, has teeth that are graduated from smaller teeth at the toe end and increase in size along the tooth edge toward the handle end. I could be wrong, but this might not be the saw for a beginner. The teeth will grab more as you move the saw forward. This might be great for someone who is working against a stop watch and wants to make a cut in two seconds. As a beginner, I doubt if you are trying to break any speed records.

Most of the saws being made today are not inexpensive. As Andrew suggests, if you can find an old vintage saw in fair condition and then have someone tune it up for you, you could end up with a great saw that will cut dovetails just fine for a lot less money. Also,if you check on eBay, there are a few people who specialize in reconditioning old saws that are ready to go to work. Sometimes, they will sell for a fairly low price. You'd be surprised how many woodworkers prefer these old vintage saws, both for cutting ability and comfort.

So I'm not advertising here on this forum, email me and I'll give you some sources for having your saws made for you on a personal level and even made to fit your hand. And made to do the type of sawing that you want to do.

Good luck,

Marv

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#7

Re: Dovetail saw questions *LINK*

MikeW

>Marv, the progrssive PPI saw is by LN, not LV. One little letter difference...

The LV saw mentioned is Lee Valley's new DT saw. I placed the link to it below.

Take care, Mike


LV's DT saw linky

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#8

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

LV....LN.....MW....AL....so many acronyms!

Thanks for the link and Craig thanks you too...*grin*

Marv

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#9

Re: The real answer

Andrew Lunn

>Hi Thom,

Care to elaborate on what makes your answer "the real" one? My comments with respect to a dt saw's weight were meant to say simply that there is a range of weights that produce a very nice saw. Of course there are numerous other variables. But even so, the degree to which weight contributes to the "self feeding" nature of a dt saw is negligible, in my opinion. They are such small saws, I think what really matters is that they feel balanced and responsive, and not toe heavy, for instance, or so light in the blade that it's difficult to sense the blade's presence when holding the saw. And that the teeth are expertly sharpened. You can get into tooth configurations, and that's a whole other can of worms. The bottom line is there are lots of nice saws out there, any of which would cut great dovetails. And then there are some dogs. The Lee Valley saw is fine, it is what it is, an inexpensive and functional tool. Maybe I read too much into your "real answer", but I felt it was somewhat dismissive, and I didn't appreciate that. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#10

Acronyms

Bill Houghton, moderately nice in Sebastopol, CA

>and then, of course, there's CRS, from which I suffer increasingly as I grow....more mature....up....something like that.

Other readers (besides Marv, who, I bet, knows this acronym well) too young to know? The polite version is "can't remember stuff."

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#11

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Michael Holden

>Craig,

Unfortunately, there are a LOT of good dovetail saws out there.

So, pointing you to the "best" is difficult - this is compounded by the different philosophies of saw design - ALL of which can lead to the "best" saw for someone!

In my own experience, I started with a gents saw, quickly graduated to a japanese dozuki and was happy for awhile. Then I got the Lie-Nielsen dovetail saw and wow! what a difference, and I was happy for awhile, then the Gramercy dovetail saw came out, and I tried that - wow! what a difference. And I am happy again.

The big difference between the LN and the Gramercy comes in the handle. The LN is pushed by my palm and the Gramercy by the web of my hand. The Gramercy seems to me to be much more controllable and responsive - but your mileage may vary.

Are there any woodworking groups near you? Can you hook up with a couple others that have saws that you could try? Dovetail saws seem to be a very personal thing, so really you need to try several to see where your interests lie.

Best, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#12

Does a bear "stuff" in the woods?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#13

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Adam Cherubini

>I think it's easier to start a saw with finer teeth. I would go for the finest toothed saw you can get. A bit of rake helps as well. Before Wenzloff saws came along, LN had more rake than Adria. Not sure how these saws compare today. Then, I think less experienced sawyers preferred the LN. And I think their tooth pitches (tpi) are comparable.

I got to use a bunch of saws at WiA. This included the new LV. The only saw I really didn't care for was the LN progressive pitched DT saw. And that saw I loved for half blinds. (I use the heel teeth to dig out the blind corner, and that saw was great for that. The best for that. But if I could only have one DT saw, this saw wouldn't have been my choice.)

An informal poll revealed that many folks preferred MY saws, particularly my reproduction Kenyon saw (which looks a bit like the Grammercy). That was one of the few there with 18ppi. (Not sure how many teeth the Grammercy has.) That's a bit finer than the saws I offered for sale.

Fine pitched saws are crowd pleasers. They are easy to use for beginners. But they aren't fun to sharpen. And they can cut slowly. So like everything else, saws are a big ole bag of compromises. You may do just as well selecting one that looks pretty to you. The LV aside, I don't think the difference is price isn't enough to warrant selecting one other another. If money is short an time is long, you can do well to purchase a Crown Gent's saw and resharpen and set it. Unlike some of the others here, I don't see good small dt's frequently on the second hand market.

Adam

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#14

Re: Dovetail saw questions

Joel

>The Gramercy ( one M ) is 18ppi most tests (by us am more importantly others) show that it cuts pretty fast on up to 3/4" stock (I think you used 3/4" stock when you tried it) but this has to do with the way they are filed. If you use a needle file it will cut faster than with a 4" xx marginally slower than a 15ppi saw but in the same league.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#15

Thanks for all the input.

Craig

>Unfortunatly I'm not usually somewhere that I can get my hands on these types of tools until they land on the porch, so all the reading I do here is always a big help...decisions, decisions. I'll let you all know how the cutting goes when I get something in the shop.

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#16

I'm gonna give a wierd recommendation *LINK*

Roy Anderson

>Zona. See link. The Zona dovetail saw is dirt cheap, works fine, has 18 TPI, is light and easy to handle and when you are good enough at dovetails to need a better saw, just throw it away and get a Lie-Nielsen saw.

I have two Zona's, a Lie-Nielsen and a couple of E-Bay reclaimed specials. The Zona's are very easy to get started with. The main downside is they cut slowly. Now that my skills have improved a little, I know how to get a saw started, so I use the Lie-Nielsen 15 TPI. It cuts faster, is a little heavier and requires a little more control.


Zona Razor Saws

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#17

Re: I'm gonna give a wierd recommendation

Bob Demers

>Not as weird as it may sound..for that is the saw that Rocewood school in Almonte On, uses to teach dovetails

As you pointed out, work great and dirt cheap.

So why would a fine WW school like Rosewood used such a cheap saw?

(My guess) They have students from all over the world, if you dont want to lug a tool set with you, or do not own a good DT saw, or are unsure..you buy that inexpensive one, learn to cut dovetails and treat yourselves to a nice saw once you get back home and worn that one.

It is inexpensive, but it is not a 'cheap' saw

Bob, who has a LN, a 'few' antiques, and a couple Zona

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#18

No problem Thom.

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#19

Re: The real answer - and I mean it this time.

ThomD

>"Care to elaborate on what makes your answer "the real" one?"

Sure, I'm right and everyone else is wrong, though apparently not even my mother is on-board with that one.

My answer really wasn't targeting yours, though I can well understand how it would feel if it were me. Sorry. The one thing I don't like about this forum is that if one actually posts to the OP's post when several other posts have been made, the result is one's post drops way down the line, and monitoring responses indicates it gets a lot less reads than if tacked on higher up. An infamintory subject also seems to garner reads, though the effect is pretty marginal.

" My comments with respect to a dt saw's weight were meant to say simply that there is a range of weights that produce a very nice saw. Of course there are numerous other variables. But even so, the degree to which weight contributes to the "self feeding" nature of a dt saw is negligible, in my opinion."

Even if it were the major factor, which I didn't say (I hope), it would be minor because the feed on a dovetail saw is pretty slight. It still has to be ballanced, and for the saw to turn out nicely.

"They are such small saws, I think what really matters is that they feel balanced and responsive,"

Could well be, but one is not likely to know what that feeling is all about. Interesting research on putters years ago showed that people were enormously sensitive to issues of feel in sellecting putters. One type of feel highly rated is the impact feel on the head, and 10 years ago makers started to make inserts in metal putters, and feel became much researched (other tactics were used). Anyway, turns out the feel (which I still swear is touch). Is actually sound. People say they feel it in their hands, but the feel goes away with ear muffs. So my long winded point is that it is all good to talk about feel, but very difficult to place the factors.

Actually, another interesting point from putters is that they break broadly into two classes. Stable ones with poor feel relatively (look like satelite dishes), but higher consistency, and putters that emphasise feel but loose out on consistancy. It takes mamoth amouts of testing to tell which will work better for which player. Of course since nobody really gets paid for maginal points in woodworking there is not much at stake making the "wrong" choice.

" and not toe heavy, for instance, or so light in the blade that it's difficult to sense the blade's presence when holding the saw."

Right but the saw doesn't cut in the air, it cuts in the piece, and there are a lot things going on in the piece, the weight distribution is affected by resting it on the blank of wood, and varies as the cut goes back and for. So is that highly variable effect mostly to the good of feed or feel. No idea. Good news is I, and presumably anyone else, can cut good dovetails with anything from a hack saw to a specialty saw. My vote is for cut every time. For instance, even agreeing with your points, I have used good Japanese, Western, and Bowsaws designed specifically for dovetails, the feel of each is very different.

"And that the teeth are expertly sharpened. You can get into tooth configurations, and that's a whole other can of worms."

Are you suggesting that these things should be independantly optimized or should an attempt be made to make them work harmoniously?

"The bottom line is there are lots of nice saws out there, any of which would cut great dovetails. "

Agree, but it would be nice for the OP if we could break it down a little, and I certainly hope that this discusion will help with that.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#20

Agreed...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>A lot of thought and experimentation went into the Lie-Nielsen (Independence) dove tail saw.

It has a nice weight to it, and is very easy to control.

Some say it's hard to start, I've ever had that problem. I can't comment on any other DT saws. I only own the LN.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#21

Hiya Bob...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Didn't see you at the wood show today :-)

I took that class at Rosewood, and I did buy the Zona ($14 or so at the time), and it works great for small drawers (where the pieces are 3/8" thick or less). Any thicker than that and the cuts take forever, though.

Now you remind me that I wanted to try the LN progressive DT saw and forgot, duh :-(

But I did try the Veritas DT saw, and it's very nice thank you, especially at the price.

Oh, and the new block plane is drop dead gorgeous, I'm gonna get one after I'm off smoking for six straight months (commitment I made in front of my wife and kids)...

DC

Watch the snowballs! :-)

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#22

hack style

paul womack

>I think it's easier to start a saw with finer teeth. I would go for the finest toothed saw you can get. A bit of rake helps as well.

I assume by "a bit of rake" you mean away from 90 degrees - gentler rake.

Yes; smoothness of cutting stroke (AKA not "grabbing") is pretty much determined by these two factors.

Since sharpening small teeth is difficult, increasing rake is the obvious path to easing the stroke - and this is what LV have done, making their teeth at 14 degree rake.

The larger teeth (for comparable smoothness) allowed by this design solution may make their saw cheaper to make, and certainly easier to maintain than simply using fine teeth.

I note that MikeW found the LV saw a little too smooth - i.e. not fast enough cutting for his preference. I suspect MikeW is skilled enough to manage a slightly more aggressive saw.

BugBear

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#23

Starting the LN dovetail saw

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Once I became accustomed to lifting the saw (taking some weight off the blade) while starting a cut all was well. It is second nature now and I never have a hesitation upon starting a cut. I have been cutting a bunch of dovetails of late in poplar and oak and a slower cutting saw would be tedious.

The bottom line is that the learning curve to starting the LN saw is more than made up for in speed once you get used to it.

BTW, the novelty and satisfaction of hand cutting dovetails can soon wear away when a bunch of joints need to be completed to get something done and in use. I have taken to wasting out the material to be removed with a band saw. A BIG time saver. With practice one can cut to the scribe line with only slight chisel work necessary.

Re: Dovetail saw questions

#24

Incomming snow balls

Bob Demers

>Yes Denis, i couldnt quite make it to the woodshow that snowy WE :-)

I got caught being unprepared, need gaz for the blowerr and had to shove the snow with my barefoot in front of the shed to get to the snow shovels. And then, I had to trudge thru 6 ft snowbamks to...

OK slight exag�ration, but yes enough snow to make snow balls, Watchout! :-)

Bob, dreaming of a white Xmas..allright enough already!