Re: The real answer - and I mean it this time.
ThomD
>"Care to elaborate on what makes your answer "the real" one?"
Sure, I'm right and everyone else is wrong, though apparently not even my mother is on-board with that one.
My answer really wasn't targeting yours, though I can well understand how it would feel if it were me. Sorry. The one thing I don't like about this forum is that if one actually posts to the OP's post when several other posts have been made, the result is one's post drops way down the line, and monitoring responses indicates it gets a lot less reads than if tacked on higher up. An infamintory subject also seems to garner reads, though the effect is pretty marginal.
" My comments with respect to a dt saw's weight were meant to say simply that there is a range of weights that produce a very nice saw. Of course there are numerous other variables. But even so, the degree to which weight contributes to the "self feeding" nature of a dt saw is negligible, in my opinion."
Even if it were the major factor, which I didn't say (I hope), it would be minor because the feed on a dovetail saw is pretty slight. It still has to be ballanced, and for the saw to turn out nicely.
"They are such small saws, I think what really matters is that they feel balanced and responsive,"
Could well be, but one is not likely to know what that feeling is all about. Interesting research on putters years ago showed that people were enormously sensitive to issues of feel in sellecting putters. One type of feel highly rated is the impact feel on the head, and 10 years ago makers started to make inserts in metal putters, and feel became much researched (other tactics were used). Anyway, turns out the feel (which I still swear is touch). Is actually sound. People say they feel it in their hands, but the feel goes away with ear muffs. So my long winded point is that it is all good to talk about feel, but very difficult to place the factors.
Actually, another interesting point from putters is that they break broadly into two classes. Stable ones with poor feel relatively (look like satelite dishes), but higher consistency, and putters that emphasise feel but loose out on consistancy. It takes mamoth amouts of testing to tell which will work better for which player. Of course since nobody really gets paid for maginal points in woodworking there is not much at stake making the "wrong" choice.
" and not toe heavy, for instance, or so light in the blade that it's difficult to sense the blade's presence when holding the saw."
Right but the saw doesn't cut in the air, it cuts in the piece, and there are a lot things going on in the piece, the weight distribution is affected by resting it on the blank of wood, and varies as the cut goes back and for. So is that highly variable effect mostly to the good of feed or feel. No idea. Good news is I, and presumably anyone else, can cut good dovetails with anything from a hack saw to a specialty saw. My vote is for cut every time. For instance, even agreeing with your points, I have used good Japanese, Western, and Bowsaws designed specifically for dovetails, the feel of each is very different.
"And that the teeth are expertly sharpened. You can get into tooth configurations, and that's a whole other can of worms."
Are you suggesting that these things should be independantly optimized or should an attempt be made to make them work harmoniously?
"The bottom line is there are lots of nice saws out there, any of which would cut great dovetails. "
Agree, but it would be nice for the OP if we could break it down a little, and I certainly hope that this discusion will help with that.