Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Japanese style dovetail saws

Posts

Japanese style dovetail saws

#1

Japanese style dovetail saws

Alexander Grigoriev

>I wonder if dozuki dovetail saw cuts any fast in a rip cut, such as when dovetailing. A saw that Lee Valley sells with their magnetic dovetail guide is not quite good with that, because its teeth are more suited for a cross cut. I saw dozuki dovetail saws, but never tried.

And am I correct that their straight handle assumes that a workpiece should be held at quite low level (below waist)?

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#2

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

Hank Knight

>Alexander,

A rip dozuki definitely rips faster than a crosscut dozuki. They're not worth a flip crosscutting, so if you only have one dozuki, get a crosscut. It will rip and crosscut, but the ripping is slow. As to the height of your workpiece, the Japanese generally work on much lower surfaces than westerners. Many sit or work on very low benches. I've found cutting dovetails with a dozuki easiest with the workpiece laying flat on my bench top (I have a regular Western bench 34" high). I start the cut with the saw handle angled slightly downward and end up with the handle almost vertical (below the workpiece). I sometimes find myself kneeling to finish the cut. The bench top offers lots of support for the cut. There is no chatter or vibration like you sometimes get with Western saws and the workpiece held vertical in a vise.

Hank

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#3

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

ThomD

>I would go with the rip dozuki (theoretically the wrong term since it refers to a shoulder, I frankly don't really care for a lot of Japanese terms I can never quite get to the root of).

When cutting dovetails you do a lot of the cutting in rip mode, and not much in crosscut, at least that is accessible with a back saw. Also, there are a lot of cheap disposable cross cut saws out there that will do the end cuts. There is a combo saw that cuts on the diagonal and is equaly good at doing rip and crosscut. I have one in Doz. and one in Ryobi format, and they are great. They don't seem all that comon at a decent price.

As far as the approach to the wood is concerned I would, if possible just use a workbench in the normal way. What Hank describes is geometrically the exact same thing, saw to wood, that you get if you put the piece in a vice and saw it standing up. The style he mentions has been promoted by Carl Swenson, in a few articles in FWW and their workbench book. Carl has adapted this to a western workbench since his earlier days propoting viseless techniques. As it happens he did an article on cutting dovetails for FWW last year, in which he showed the current evolusion of his style. So you could save yourself 20 years and just go straight to the vise.

I started out in the 70s working on the floor and copying Odate and Svenson, and others. I really never saw how a Japanese cabinetmaker did this work. Still haven't. Svenson learner from Timberframer Imai, and at the same time we had Odate writing books and doing demos. Both these guys essentially are jobsite carpenters. There are workshop guys who build cabinet, but they have never been covered in the popular press over here, that I have seen. Hank's part of the world has lots of practicing guys so he may know better. I did see a Japanese Daiku making cabinets, on HGTV. He sawed in the most fluid style imagineable with the piece on a beam between his legs. I've tried that and the ergo is wonderful, but for one thing, your lines are 3 feet away.

When I started to do demos of dovetails, Independence came out with the first decent western DT saw in a while, and I used that for demos, the idea being that it would be more appropriate to the audience's expectations. I liked it a lot, bought 3, and really haven't used the Dozukis much since. The reality is that sawing doesn't depend on whether you can pull or push, but whether you can cut to the line. Western saws leave a wider kerf, and as long as that is not at the expence of rough cuts, or cutting action, there are some tactical advantages to it, like getting in there with a fret saw at times, or using the Frid blade technique on half blind dovetails.

Interestingly, Frid advocated using rip saws for all cutting, whether cross cut or rip cuts, and whacking big teeth. Sooner or later it all comes around on the guitar.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#4

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've tried that and the ergo is wonderful

Huh?

As to dovetail sawing, I've used several saws, at least 5 types:

1. huge, cheap western, Sears and the like

2. 14" tenon, also cheap, Tyzack

3. LV Professional dozuki (and Rob says the rip dozuki he sells is

even better)

4. LN dovetail with straight handle

5. Kaneharu rip, the most expensive

Results? I get perfect dovetails with at most 3 cutting events (as in zip-zip-zip) in 3/4 to 4/4 stock using any of the last three. The Kaneharu tends to make smoother cuts, but not by much. I also easily made perfect cuts with the Tyzack, but it's been 20 years since I used it, don't remember precisely how fast it was. I much prefer a straight handled saw for this job and others

Conclusion? Just get a saw and learn how to use it. It doesn't have to be expensive, and it would have to be a pretty bad saw (such as the Sears, and even that one may be OK with a little tuning) to have any negative effect on your dovetail sawing, which is, when you get down to it, a very trivial sawing job.

Pam

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#5

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

ThomD

>The ergonomics of the bent over position are great. Hard on the back but the arms can get right out of it very smooth. Fine for ripping stock.

One thing I noticed on the Peters tape Rob has is that Peters saws the visible surfaces first, which is sorta counter to what I would do just to make the cuts, but it makes sense as far as focusing on the money edges. As you say Pam, it is relatively trivial - so easy when you know how. Stuff rarely goes wrong in the first 3/4" of a saw cut. Now a tough test would be ripping two boards and then glueing them together left of board "a" to right of board "b". Works with a table saw, and they only cost 40 bucks all nice cast iron on Craigslist.

My best tip on sawing dovetails is to focus on the gap between the saw and the wood. Since kerf is wider than blade stock, you can see if you are torquing the saw in the kerf by looking for consistancy of blade to kerf. Not something you need to do all the time, but a good test.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#6

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>"My best tip on sawing dovetails is to focus on the gap between the saw and the wood. Since kerf is wider than blade stock, you can see if you are torquing the saw in the kerf by looking for consistancy of blade to kerf. Not something you need to do all the time, but a good test."

For dozukis, rip or crosscut, this is a big key. True for tenons too. Particularly for saws with fine set, like less than a thou either side. In fact, you have to feel the kerf clearance; you can't see it, or at least I can't. There will be the finest of windows where the saw is running free. The only person I have seen who picked this up right off the bat on his own was Konrad Sauer, but then Konrad has a certain genius about tools.

The other big key, in my opinion, is sawing down both marked lines at once, once you've kerfed across the end grain with the first pull. This notion has been mentioned a number of times in the past on this forum, but I think is worth repeating (maybe it'll draw an argument this time).

Wiley

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#7

Dissertation on 'dovetails are easy to saw'

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Well, yeah. I suppose they are. What's hard is making a real good four-foot rip. Or sawing a perfect tenon. In dovetails, I think the chisel work is more critical, and takes more time and insight to get a system developed that works every time.

But I think there is a logical problem to say that sawing dovetails is easy. Talking about the second board now, not the first. This is one of those propositions whose opposite it also true--sawing dovetails is not easy. Why? Because none of us are any better at sawing joinery than our next joint will show. What is easy is a static skill like constructing geometry proofs or working algebra problems--once you know how, you can do a million of these in a row, and make 100% on every one of them. There is not a dynamic element to the skill. But hitting a baseball, or sawing joinery, or playing Bach's chaconne in D minor on the violin--all fall into the workmanship of risk. One can miss, and you're going uphill against entropy all the time.

With the workmanship of risk, there is always a chance of failure. That's why I say dovetails are easy, but then dovetails are also hard. A little lapse of focus, or just getting out of practice, or dark-colored wood + weak eyesight, .......

And then there are times you get in a zone, and can't miss. That's why I thought Thom's suggestion about minding how the saw body is running in the kerf is valuable--it's telling you how things should feel when everything is right.

Wiley

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#8

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

Hank Knight

>I agree with Thom. If you're looking for Japanese saw for dovetails, get a rip dozuki. That's what I use and it works lots better than a crosscut - it's much faster. As I said initially, a crosscut dozuki will rip and crosscut, but the ripping is slow - not optimal for dovetials, but it will work. Maybe somebody can crosscut with a rip dozuki, but I cartainly can't.

As for how I approach the work, I really don't know where I learned my "style." We don't have a lot Japanese woodworkers in South Carolina. I don't know any. The method I use has evolved for me over the years as the easiest, most effective way for me to cut dovetails. Cutting with the work flat on the bench takes advantage of the Japanese saw's cut on the pull stroke. I find it easier to start a cut in line with the long grain rather than cutting directly into the end grain as you would with the work clamped upright in a vise.

All of this is a matter of personal preference, including the choice of saws. Even so, maybe the one thing we can all agree on is that a rip dozuki is the best Japanese saw for dovetails.

Hank

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#9

P.S.

Hank Knight

>I agree with Pam. Get a decent saw and learn how to use it. Looking for a silver bullet for dovetails is a waste of time and money. The only thing that will give you good dovetails is practice.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#10

Re: Agree

ThomD

>Sawing down both sides is what I do, which is why I was interested that Peters decidedly didn't do it. Not saying one way or another is better, but it always gets me interested when I see someone who does the same thing with a different approach.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#11

Re: Dissertation on 'dovetails are easy to saw'

ThomD

>I agree with all of that. The reason the four foot rip is hard is that there is a lot of it to get right, and it is hard to control. Dovetails are like that to the extent that they involve cumulative erors, since each face introduces new opportunities to skew the joint. They are easy because they are short cuts. Another way to look at it is that while I fit from the saw, you can still goof to the inside and probably correct the problem. With the rip cut both sides mater. Of course if you are planing afterwards you don't have much problem, but at least one has to conceded there are cuts where both sides mater and cuts were only one side is used.

I could give many keys, you mention another one which is being open to feeling it. If the saw can't cut straight, or the person, there is a problem. But more often the person doesn't get out of the saw's way, or their own, and tries to steer too much. One has to be open to the feel.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#12

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

ThomD

>My bad, Hank. I thought you lived in South California.

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#13

Don't get him riled up, now (

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#14

Re: Dissertation on 'dovetails are easy to saw'

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I said "dovetail sawing" is a trivial job. Making dovetails is much more, although still not difficult in my experience. Marking is critical. Sawing on the right side of the line is critical. The trick is knowing where to saw, not the sawing process itself.

Pam

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#15

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

Hank Knight

>Thom,

I hope I didn't sound peevish. I didn't understand some of your post and wanted to explain that I learned the way I cut dovetails from trial and error, mostly error. I wish I had some Japanese tool users around here. Life would probably be simpler if I could learn from those who've been there.

No offense taken and, I hope, none given.

Hank

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#16

practice

roninkokomo

>Ask Frank Klaus, Krenov, Odate, whoever

The more dovetails you cut, the easier they get. Many us baby boomer woodworkers expect to cut dovetails like Klaus and Krenov after we have cut 4 joints.

Not happening

Re: Japanese style dovetail saws

#17

Agree with what Hank says...

wilbur

>Everything that Hank wrote above is absolutely true.

But for me the question is, how much benefit does the increased speed of using a rip dozuki really get you? For me, there are many things that I wish went better after making a dovetail joint, but I can't remember a single time that I thought, "Boy, that dovetail looks great. If only the sawing went faster."

I've found that most of the sawing time for a dovetail joint is towards the end of the cut, when you are trying to get as close to the baseline as possible without going over. In this situation, the speed advantage of rip teeth vs. crosscut teeth isn't really helpful.

Of course, your experience may be different, and in full disclosure I actually use a ryoba, not a dozuki, to cut dovetails. I do use the rip side of the ryoba, though. :@)