Re: Japanese style dovetail saws
ThomD
>I would go with the rip dozuki (theoretically the wrong term since it refers to a shoulder, I frankly don't really care for a lot of Japanese terms I can never quite get to the root of).
When cutting dovetails you do a lot of the cutting in rip mode, and not much in crosscut, at least that is accessible with a back saw. Also, there are a lot of cheap disposable cross cut saws out there that will do the end cuts. There is a combo saw that cuts on the diagonal and is equaly good at doing rip and crosscut. I have one in Doz. and one in Ryobi format, and they are great. They don't seem all that comon at a decent price.
As far as the approach to the wood is concerned I would, if possible just use a workbench in the normal way. What Hank describes is geometrically the exact same thing, saw to wood, that you get if you put the piece in a vice and saw it standing up. The style he mentions has been promoted by Carl Swenson, in a few articles in FWW and their workbench book. Carl has adapted this to a western workbench since his earlier days propoting viseless techniques. As it happens he did an article on cutting dovetails for FWW last year, in which he showed the current evolusion of his style. So you could save yourself 20 years and just go straight to the vise.
I started out in the 70s working on the floor and copying Odate and Svenson, and others. I really never saw how a Japanese cabinetmaker did this work. Still haven't. Svenson learner from Timberframer Imai, and at the same time we had Odate writing books and doing demos. Both these guys essentially are jobsite carpenters. There are workshop guys who build cabinet, but they have never been covered in the popular press over here, that I have seen. Hank's part of the world has lots of practicing guys so he may know better. I did see a Japanese Daiku making cabinets, on HGTV. He sawed in the most fluid style imagineable with the piece on a beam between his legs. I've tried that and the ergo is wonderful, but for one thing, your lines are 3 feet away.
When I started to do demos of dovetails, Independence came out with the first decent western DT saw in a while, and I used that for demos, the idea being that it would be more appropriate to the audience's expectations. I liked it a lot, bought 3, and really haven't used the Dozukis much since. The reality is that sawing doesn't depend on whether you can pull or push, but whether you can cut to the line. Western saws leave a wider kerf, and as long as that is not at the expence of rough cuts, or cutting action, there are some tactical advantages to it, like getting in there with a fret saw at times, or using the Frid blade technique on half blind dovetails.
Interestingly, Frid advocated using rip saws for all cutting, whether cross cut or rip cuts, and whacking big teeth. Sooner or later it all comes around on the guitar.