Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

Posts

Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#1

Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

ThomD

>This is one of those posts one hesitates to make since I feel sure I am the only one to miss the memo. Yet, even with catalogs galore I did miss this announcement. O1 and A2 blades for traditional planes, 3/16" steel. A few decades late for me, but a wonderful opportunity for anyone wanting to make their own traditional planes, or Krenov like planes. Not sure about the blade length at 6 inches, mine tend to be about 2 inches longer or shorter, but everything suits someone.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#2

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

Dean J in MN

>I wonder if Rob would consider offering those blades tapered? A straight blade in a wooden wedge set plane isn't the ideal situation. Tapered blades make the plane easier to set.

Rob???

-Dean

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#3

hack style

paul womack

>Historically, parallel blades for woodies were made, and sold at a substantial premium (certainly in the era 1880 - 1940)

BugBear

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#4

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

Rob Lee

>Hi Dean -

Request noted!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#5

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

MikeW

>Yes--and perhaps tapered blanks one needs to harden after shaping...ya know, for molding planes and the like.

Take care, Mike

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#6

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

ThomD

>That's an intereesting idea. I can turn out a parallel blade in about 10 or 20 minutes, not worth the 7 mile trip to Lee Valley, but a taper would be a pain, and chew up about 5-10 dollars of sandpaper, I am guessing. Paul's point that there wasn't anything inferior about a parallel blade is consistant with my experience, but then I haven't actually tried one in a fresh new plane of my own manufacture.

While you are at it Rob, how about some conveniently sized Beech stock and some floats?

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#7

Re: hack style

MikeW

>Marketing of parallel blades aside (took less time to make them, why charge more?), tapered blades require less force on the wedge to set the wedge.

They really are better.

Take care, Mike

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#8

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

Rob Lee

>Hi Thom (and Mike)...

Probably won't do unhardened blanks - as that's being done already... same goes for floats....

If we entered that market - it would uneconomic for two companies...us AND the cuurent suppliers!

Things like this are real service items, and while we're all for that, they're already available...so we'll stay away.

Ya gotta support the people who hang it out there by producing low volume, specialty items... or else no one will do it.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#9

Great answer!

Chuck Nickerson

>Because they don't just want you to sell them; they want you to sell them cheaper than the other guys. For small-volume items, that's a road to nowhere.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#10

"Road to nowhere"--absolutely agree!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Lee Valley's new initiative--a premium line with new branding and logo--is the opposite of commoditizing specialty products (like floats). What LV is doing is far more audacious: They're trying to start with a clean sheet of paper and make superior and unique primary tools. As Bill Tindall said upthread, this has got to be enormously energizing to everyone associated with LV/Veritas.

Wiley....taking Rob's advice and supporting specialty tool makers

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#11

Comment

Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA again

>"Ya gotta support the people who hang it out there by producing low volume, specialty items... or else no one will do it."

I was surprised, when the question of my fantasy vacation to a Lee Valley store came up the other day, to find out how many stores you've got around Canada; and your catalogs certainly imply that your mail order shipping operation sure isn't a one-car garage.

For you to then express the almost small-town cooperative capitalist attitude quoted above is a marvel and a delight!

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#12

Parallel irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I was under the impression that parallel blades were made for double iron planes and that the cap iron still contributed taper to the assembled doubled iron. I also thought that because the steel was welded on at the business end that the rough blank was already quite a bit thicker at this end. So that the tapered iron was actually easier to make than the parallel iron. The parallel iron does have the advantage that the mouth does not open up as the iron is used up. In my experience the iron is worn down a lot faster than the sole of the plane.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#13

Re: Comment

Miles

>It's almost mandatory to buy stuff from such nice folks. I will certainly be doing so as much as I can :-)

Hmm... Mike Wenzloff or Rob Lee or Tom LN or Ron Hock or Colen Clenton or Clifton or Adria or Ashley Iles or ...

are we not very fortunate to have such difficult and pleasurable choices? Thanks guys.

Happy Thanksgiving to US folks! The rest of us can look forward to Christmas shopping :-)

Miles

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#14

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

MikeW

>I understand and appreciate the answer.

To play the Devil's advocate, I don't believe in the simplistic--though understandable--response. Don't get me wrong, I do not mean to pry fuller reasons. Just an observation.

Taken to its fullest expression, LV/Veritas/Utilitas would not be making a lot of the tools LV/Veritas/Utilitas makes nor, more to the point, parallel plane blades as others are also doing them.

Someone once told me choice is good for the consumer.

As to niche plane blades, at least no one is making commercially availble tapered plane blades that I know. But then, I don't get out much...

Take care, Mike

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#15

Re: When is the Tenon saw coming out?

ThomD

>One thing from my Can. perspective is LV is a neighbourhood store, like nothing coming from the US can ever be. With current currency volatility I don't even know within 10 percent what my card would be billed on a US purchase, and I don't even really know they will still be in business to ship the product. So as far as I am concerned nobody makes floats in my market. However, I understand most of the real market (both ideas and dollars) is south of the border so someone is making floats in LV's market. That would only be a juicy prospect if people are actually using them for all the novel non-plane making things that have been discused here.

I agree with Mike, my first western dovetail saw came from Independence, and they were picked up by LN. Now LV has one, costs less than half, and every time I pick it up in my 40 degree shop, I figure it is worth a lot more. I still think I will like it when the temperature heats up, for that mater. So if they want to make a plastic backed float with a Buzinga handle, I will be at the front of the line as usual.

Note: So far the only problem I am having with the Aero Dovetail saw is finding an elegant way to hang it on my tool board, it doesn't have many corners.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#16

Re: When is the Tenon saw coming out?

MikeW

>"Note: So far the only problem I am having with the Aero Dovetail saw is finding an elegant way to hang it on my tool board, it doesn't have many corners"

I don't mean to sound flip, but how about drilling a hang hole? At the toe just below the back.

Before someone asks "how would I like it" if someone drilled through one of our saws...A) I wouldn't care. B) We've done it on request for customers.

About the only other means of not taking up much space in/on a tool box/board is a saw still like arrangement for a single saw or two. Which can be added to most any tool box or board.

Take care, Mike

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#17

LN

David Cockey

>Lie-Nielsen makes and sells tapered blanks for hollow and round wood planes and a variety of floats. These were developed in conjunction with Clark & Williams.

Rob Lee was probably trying to say the market for such specialty items isn't very big, there isn't much profit in it after development costs are taken into account, and if LV got into it with direct competition there probably wouldn't be enough for either to make it worthwile to do.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#18

Re: Parallel irons

Philly

>All my planes have parallel irons - I've never experienced the problems that tapered iron users suggest happen with parallel irons. If the wedge is well fitting then setting and adjusting the iron is quick and easy - if you've ever watched someone set a plane with a tapered iron you'll know what a drawn out process that can be.

Sometimes you have to try things yourself to find out the truth - too many woodworking "old wives tales" ;)

Cheers

Philly

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#19

Re: Parallel irons

Dean J in MN

>I have no issues with the tapered irons and have struggled with parallel irons. Perhaps I'm just used to setting the tapered irons, but I find the parallel irons do require a firmer wedge setting in use. That tight wedge makes, for me, the fine tweaking of the set difficult.

-Dean

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#20

Re: Comment

Rick in Oakville

>A couple of years back Leonard Lee was in a dispute with the Canadian Post office over the way the post office charged for the packages Lee Valley was shipping through them. He had a web page devoted to the issue separate from the Lee Valley site. Somewhere on that site he revealed that Lee Valley was paying more than $1,500,000 a year in postage to the post office. No small operation indeed!

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#21

Re: When is the Tenon saw coming out?

ThomD

>As a cabinetmaker, I think I need a better storage solution. My shop would show that the hand tool racks are the only even remotely organized part of the shop. What remains of my storage self-respect is on the line here.

Your suggestion isn't bad, for some reason I like the effect of a hole in a knife handle with a nice piece of tubing defining it, but not on woodworking tools. In this case there is a tang that runs through the handle, interfering with most places I might put such a hole, a bit the same way a handle is held on a plane, or a Bowie. There is a barrel nut that holds the handle on, and that could be replace with a barrel nut with an eyelet formed in it (patent pending).

What I will probably do is place two pegs in a position that will trap the handle, that works ok.

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#22

Re: Comment

ThomD

>What does that get you? A letter from Pickering to Oakville?

Re: Lee Valley Blades for Wooden Planes

#23

Re: Parallel irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>"If you've ever watched someone set a plane with a tapered iron you'll know what a drawn out process it can be" I have to admit that after decades I do this so unconsciously that I have no idea how tedious it is. But when I have watched others I did not think it tedious. I wonder what kind of workers you have been watching.