Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

Posts

Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#1

Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

Larry Williams

>On Stephen's blog he had a post about British influence on American tools and discussion turned to Dutch influence on British tools. I think there are some common misconceptions about Dutch influence on British planes. Because I'm so late getting back to this, I thought I'd just post in a new thread with a link to the first.

There is a notion out there that British planes evolved from Dutch planes. The idea comes from some pretty knowledgeable researchers and authors. W.L. Goodman was one of the early writers who suggested this and it's been followed by others including Don and Anne Wing. In their book, Early Planemakers of London, the Wings again suggest this evolution.

While their book is probably the best and possibly the most important book on wooden planes to date, I disagree with the Wings assertion that British planes began as copies of Dutch planes. Like Goodman they start by citing the planes salvaged from the 1545 wreck of the Mary Rose. Because some of the Mary Rose planes appear to have rudimentary horns that could suggest those found on Dutch planes a connection is assumed. Yet if one examines Albrecht D�rer's 1514 engraving, Melencolia, one will see a fully formed Germanic smooth plane. D�rer's plane is very refined compared to the primitive appearing planes from the Mary Rose. The difference is dramatic and the Mary Rose planes appear more craftsman made.

Even through the 19th Century shipwrights and ship's carpenters had their own plane making tradition. They made their own planes and often used different materials than would have been used in plane making shops of the time. They had different needs than traditional bench trades and evolved different styles of planes. The razee plane is a good example of this.

I don't know of any direct evidence of a Dutch influence on the Mary Rose planes. There may have been some but there's no evidence. In fact the crude appearance of the Mary Rose planes suggest the tradition of craftsman made planes extended back that far.

The Wings also cite the early "English style" Dutch planes found at the Swedish Skoklosters Castle and a few similar planes found in Holland. It is insinuated that these planes were made for export to England or British colonies by their makers. None of those planes have any provenance that suggest they were intended for export by their Dutch makers. There is a 1645 invoice showing the Skoklosters planes were purchased in Amsterdam then shipped to Sweden. Not a single one of these planes has been found in England or locations that were British colonies. There are a number of refined features of early British planes that don't seem to appear in those "English style" planes. I've never had one in my hands but I have examined the drawings and photos and don't see evidence those features were incorporated in the Dutch planes. In fact, these advanced and important functional features didn't show up on Continental planes until the late 1900's if at all.

The important features that are missing from Dutch and other Continental planes are spring, leaning wedges and boxing. Spring improves cutting geometry, controls mouth opening, enables deeper profiles and allows for an easier to sharpen plane. Leaning wedges improve shaving clearance, improve bedding of the iron, assures a full-width iron when it's important and improves the ease of making planes.

But wait, you say, boxing wasn't used in British planes until somewhere around the middle of the 18th Century. I know there aren't documented examples of boxed British planes until around then but there is other evidence. Perhaps the most sophisticated planes the British developed were the snipes bill planes. The delicate point of these planes require the use of a dense hard wood like boxing if they're going to enter into marking gauge layout lines and begin the conversion to the intended profile. While they could have been made of solid boxwood, such construction wouldn't have been ideal because of cost and stability problems. The practice of boxing would, I think, have been quickly developed for these and other planes with small fine features. As early as 1680 Joseph Moxon describes snipes bill planes used in conjunction with hollows and rounds for producing mouldings. Again in 1736 Richard Neve lists snipes bills as used with hollows and rounds. In 1790 Thomas Sheraton described the process of entering gauge lines with these planes.

According to Goodman, Mark and Jane Rees and the Wings; the late 17th and early 18th Centuries was the time frame that the British were copying Dutch planes. Yet we know the Dutch and other Continental plane makers never developed produced snipes bill planes. At the time the British were supposedly just beginning their plane production by imitating the Dutch they were actually making more sophisticated planes than were ever produced by the Dutch.

I am aware that the Dutch were the leaders in the development of optics, scientific instruments and other things. This may be one reason it was assumed the more embellished Dutch planes were the fore-runners of British planes. Perhaps an uninformed observer could mistake the ornamental embellishment of the Dutch planes as a mark of superiority over the more utilitarian looking British planes.

Another place one could look for evidence of the British importing of Dutch planes would be in the early import tariff rate books. From the early 1600's on there were duties on all kinds of tools and those tools were listed individually in the Rates of Merchandize. Tariffs were listed for plane irons, chisels, chisel handles, anvils, grind stones and other tools but planes simply aren't listed. If there had been a trade in planes, there would have been tariffs on imported planes. That says a lot.

Today when someone tells me the British began plane making by copying Dutch planes I ask for their evidence. I haven't heard of any evidence that shows this. In fact, the evidence I'm aware of is that the British had their own robust woodworking tradition and, very early, developed planes that were superior to those produced elsewhere.


Stephen's thread

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#2

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Gary Roberts

>Larry

For clarification, the question is not to the superior form or function of wooden planes from GB, but to the possibility of 'cross-pollination' between geo-political groups such as Great Britain, France, Holland, Germany and Belgian, to use the modern terminology for these countries. During the 16th - 18th Centuries, the borders of these countries varied from what they are today... I use their names for familiarity not for precision.

For example, Moxon and his father skipped town and worked in Holland for a while, publishing their religiously weighted books. It's assumed that Joseph Moxon learned globe and instrument making while in Holland and perfected his skills after returning to Britain. There is ample evidence of iterinant and journeymen craftsmen and toolmakers crossing political boundries, particularly when the political boundry was purely political and not social. The influence on diverse cultures of language and ethnicity on crafts is well documented.

Finding evidence of any 16th or 17th C trade is difficult at best. Sometimes you stumble upon the evidence and sometimes you go purposely looking for it.

The considerable personal travel as well as inter-marriage between Holland, France, Germany, Belgian and Great Britain during these time periods leads me to assume that there had to be some influence on certain aspects of tool making. While secrets were guarded by the existing guilds, we are still learning of peculiar guild associations that have been hidden. For example, in 17th and 18th C Britain, the Guild of Drapers listed cabinetmakers, joiners and planemakers as guild members. How and why we are still tracking down.

My point is that it is possible and quite likely that the development of design features across Europe could easily have been affected by personal travel and experiences. While there are clearly obvious differences between many styles of plane, there are some peculiar similarities that can lead me to posit the exchange and influence of designs between countries already heavily involved in trade.

The current lack of tarif records, while problematic, only indicates more research is in order. If you don't keep an open mind, you will never find the path to the answer.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#3

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Miles

>The very fine furniture made in Holland in the 'Golden Age' (17th Century) would suggest that tools as fundamental as planes must have been pretty well developed. How this happened is probably more interesting than trying to establish superiority of one region over another.

See for example "Furniture in Holland's Golden Age" by Reinier Baarsen, published by the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, for some truly stunning items. Ebony-veneered spiral columns as a technical challenge, any takers...?

If anyone is in Amsterdam, the furniture in the Rijksmuseum is a must-see. I don't know if the book is available elsewhere, but it's a very interesting read. ISBN 978 90 8689 014 9

cheers

Miles

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#4

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am sure that the English had a plane making tradition in the 17th century. But when William of Orange (and Mary} ascended to the throne near the end of the 17th century, he brought with him a cadre of Dutch cabinetmakers from his homeland. They had a huge influence on English furniture styles and construction. Even without evidence it is at least plausible that they influenced tools as well. I don't think that this possibility diminishes the accomplishments of English plane makers a generation or two later in the 18th century.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#5

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Gary Roberts

>And that is right on the money. It's not about which is superior. Japanese planes are primarily used on softwoods. They excel at this work because they developed within a craft environment that dictated their function. Why create a plane that will handle boxwood if boxwood is not a typical wood of the area?

Neither Great Britain nor France wanted to own up to the influence of the Dutch on their furniture styles. When trade wars begin, nationalistic self image becomes central to identity. What craftsman could stay in business by advertising the latest designs from Amsterdam? Instead, they became the latest designs from France and Greece. At least until Great Britain and France found themselves at war.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#6

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Larry Williams

>"...Even without evidence it is at least plausible that they influenced tools as well..."

I don't see any evidence the Dutch, William of Orange, or his imported cabinetmakers had any impact on British planes or British plane design. The fact is that Moxon had written about British planes and their uses eight years before William and Mary ascended to the throne. The planes Moxon described had features and uses more advanced than Dutch planes had then or even a hundred years later. One can speculate about all kinds of things but real evidence is what's important. Show me any change in British tool design that resulted from the Dutch cabinetmakers of William and Mary. Give me the evidence.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#7

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Japanese planes are primarily used on softwoods.

I really think it's time to rest this myth. Japan had and has many hardwoods from which they made such things as combs, furniture, and tools (e.g. chisel handles of gumi (Japanese boxwood) and dai of hon red oak).

Pam

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#8

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Gary Roberts

>Well Larry, when we get into the 1500's and 1600's, pure evidence is nearly always circumstantial or by visual comparison at best. Written records are few and those that do exist are often vague. Researching any topic of these time periods is always open to interpretation and discussion. Any hypothesis can be proven or disproven if the evidence is finally uncovered. But, often there is no evidence to be found. Early Dutch guild records are missing. One of the earliest is from 1614, according to van der Sterre. Who knows, maybe a document is sitting in some university library or local archive waiting to be uncovered.

I'll close by saying that my mullings only pertain to form and embellishment, not to function. Comparing the stop gouge cuts and embellishing gouge cuts of Dutch planes seems to indicate a possible relationship to the British and eventually to the American styles (let's not forgot that New York was primarily Dutch in it's early years. I spent many a pleasant afternoon in Van Cortland Park). Considering the 'possible' is, to me, part of the fun of research.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#9

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, but there's a big difference between considering the possibilities and making pronouncements, preaching the possibilities as gospel.

Pam

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#10

but Gary

Larry Williams

>We know the Dutch were making planes that were influenced by or in the style of the British planes. Examples exist and we know they were purchased in Holland. There are no examples of Dutch looking planes that have surfaced in England or its colonies. There's no early evidence the British imported planes from Holland or anywhere else. In fact Joseph Moxon described planes that were functionally superior to any of the Continental planes at the time the British were supposedly just starting to make planes and were copying the Dutch. It doesn't make sense, Gary. The evidence suggests that, if anyone was copying anyone else, the Dutch were copying and experimenting with British designs.

The features on British planes you suggest may have come from the Dutch are all functional. Chamfers and shoulder profiles serve a purpose and the gouge cuts are just elegant ways to terminate the chamfers and shoulder profiles. Evidence of a lot of British experimenting with different chamfers, shoulder profiles and terminating cuts abounds.

Some of the gouge cuts on Dutch planes are purely ornamental and serve no purpose I can figure out. The Dutch even go so far as ornamental carving on their bench planes. There's a totally different mindset by the makers. Is it more important to focus on makiing a plane that's "Oh, so precious" or one that works as good as it can? I think the Dutch and British came up with different answers to that important design question. I also think that's why the British had no interest in copying inferior Dutch planes.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#11

Anthropology, not archeology

Adam Cherubini

>I don't think the archeological record is robust enough to make any definitive statements except to say English planes look more like Dutch planes than any other style. That's essentially what Goodman said and without any additional evidence, I'm not sure what else can be said.

But I'm with Larry on this one and I'll tell you why. In my experience, the English are the most stubborn, slow to change folks I've ever encountered (or been related to). This is a group of people still building homes with separate hot and cold running water. Why would anyone still do that? They drive on the wrong side of the road and refuse to use Euros as their currency. I know I know, they love curry and have switched to the metric system. But come on; Parliament and a Monarch? Isn't that a little bit like suspenders and a belt? Choose one!

I think it's pretty clear the English have a "not invented here" attitude. When offered superior technology, they turn it down. Like planes with horns or coffee for example. So Larry's right. I think the English are just too stubborn to be influenced by the Dutch.

Adam

P.S. Ran out of time to discuss the foreign (French) words the English have mangled thru shear unwillingness to pronounce them correctly. And what's up with them renaming soccer "football"? Unless you hear a whistle every 30 seconds and you get crushed on every play, you're not a football player. I met an English pro football player who said he was a center. Must have been pulling my leg. That little guy wouldn't last one play in center in the good ole US of A.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#12

Re: Anthropology, not archeology

MikeW

>Geez, I almost busted a gut--and nearly spewed coffee at the monitor.

Thanks for my morning laugh, Adam!

Take care, Mike

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#13

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

MikeW

>One issue I have--and in the development of the plane I admit I am fairly ignorant--is it almost sounds like these tools were being developed in isolation from each other, in a virtual vacuum of peoples, concept and technology.

It is difficult for me to believe there wasn't a more symbiotic development. Else it is as if the Roman concept developed along two divergent, and wholly separate, lines. Hard to imagine it was so.

I think there is room to believe that while influence was mutual, spanning time and distance, there were conscious choices made regionally that kept them apart in certain aspects.

Take care, Mike

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#14

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Moxon did have a strong Dutch influence. This had a lot to do with the Dutch reputation for map making, printing and scientific instruments. It would not surprise me to find out that much of Moxon's work was ghost written, though I've now awakened on a different side of the bed this morning and feel he may be fully responsible for his work. I might add, we forget his impetus was map and globe making and printing. Who did his illustrations? These seem to cause the most problems of interpretation with Moxon. Also we rely on a certain printing edition. I've not seen anyone comparing the various editions and especially the earliest ones. Trade between the Dutch and English goes back to before the Hundred Years War. In deed, England has always relied on trade being an island nation. An interesting thing to do would be to look at English lists of cabinetmakers, joiners, etc. and see if any Dutch names are listed.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#15

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Joel

>Moxon copied his joinery illustrations from the French Feilbien (sp?) who published about 8-10 year earlier. (it's a holiday and i am too lazy to look stuff up). the commonly reproduced edition is from 1703 (third edition) The first edition is identical in content (I could not find any differences and

I was looking for them but the page formatting is different as edition one was a serialization.

Moxon himself was a successful publisher of all sorts of things. Samuel Pepy collected books and mentioned him in his diary. There is no evidience that I know of that Moxon did any woodworking and the chances that the text was ghosted is pretty darn high. The target audience was richer gents who were interested in woodworking - like Pepys himself who considered Simon the joyner to be a sort of friend who remodeled his house and took longer than expected.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#16

Me too, Mike! God Save the Queen. Carry on.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#17

Arguing by analogy

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>What I know about the development of tools in Europe and England during that or much of any other period could be written on a grain of rice in 16-point font, but let me offer this: there's been a lot of research on the California native American tribes that indicates, among other things, that there was active trade between the Sierras and the coast, and up and down the state; and that there is/was a small tribe in the Sierras that spoke an Algonquian language that contained words describing Eastern animals and plants, implying that this tribe migrated west from there. Considering that the normal means of transportation until the Europeans reintroduced the horse was by water in hand-paddled craft where possible and by foot otherwise, that demonstrates pretty impressive movement.

My wife, as she does her genealogical work, keeps uncovering parts of her family making major moves around Europe.

It's hard for me to believe that there wasn't quite a bit of movement back and forth, with tradesworkers carrying their habits and tools with them.

At the same time, it's still true today that tradesworkers are, generally speaking, conservative about tools and practices; and, from what little I've read about historical practices, it was probably even more true in earlier centuries. So there would have been conflicting pressures in England and elsewhere: the introduction of new ideas through trade, travel, and immigration; and resistance to change. It's my sense that the usual outcome of conflicting pressures such as that is that the only new ideas that survive are those that help the mechanic get the job out the door faster.

All of this is worth what y'all are paying for it, of course.

Bill, speculating

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#18

Re: Anthropology, not archeology

Philly

>First Roy Underhill and now you, Adam???

Remember - the British are listening...... ;)

Philly :)

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#19

Re: Arguing by analogy

Gary Roberts

>Hi Folks. For those who don't know me all that well, Socratic dialog is a habit of mine. I suspect it comes of years of work in research libraries, where questioning a given 'fact' is par for the course. Rarely does research yield a final answer. Typically, the more we dig, the more questions we have and the more avenues open up for further research.

The responses to Stephen's original blog post are fascinating, in particular the carry over to Woodcentral (I lurk a lot and rarely post, only due to time limits). There is considerable personal investment in opinions while at the same time there has been a set of discussions traveling around archaeology, anthropology, sociology, industrial design, form follows function, the craft tradition and so on.

Just today I received an email from someone totally unrelated to this thread. His question is: "Why are British wooden planes of the period so much fancier than American wooden planes?" (my wording, not his). I'll be directing him to this thread as a starting point.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#20

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Gary Roberts

>Mike

In a sense you are correct in your comment on the isolation of design development. During the periods we are talking about, nationalistic fever was even worse than it is today, at least for what we call Europe. Religious, social and Monarchist feelings ruled the roost. Trade was often squashed or so regulated that the cost of moving goods between countries could be prohibitive. Unfortunately, we have little in the way of records of the black market. Who knows what goods moved under cover of darkness?

Even more so, people who lived along political boundaries often ignored the prevailing politics in favor of local familial and other social relationships. Many never really knew to which country they belonged as the border lines changed. At least until some lord showed up and informed them of who they now belonged to.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#21

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread

Gary Roberts

>Joel

Absolutely, there is no evidence that Moxon was skilled in these trades. His other work on printing is taken as one of the earliest and finest covers of the subject. But then he was a printer and publisher by trade. His skills lay in mathematics and the design/manufacture of scientific equipment. Moxon sought membership in the Royal Society but was initially refused because he was a printer... a tradesman.

The trade of engraving was part of the guild system. If Moxon had done his own engraving, he would have run afoul of the local guild and censored, if not heavily fined. He needed engravers for his business. It's an easy jump in reason to assume that the engravings were not his. It was a feature of engravers that their skill in precisely duplicating a prior work was their mark of accomplishment. So who knows who did the work and how many journeymen engravers might have been involved?

At the time Mechanick Exercises (both Printing and the one in question) where published, Moxon was more of a publisher than an isolated printer. The more successful printing houses had to operate as publishers in order to survive. Printing was low pay, publishing reaped a great profit, along with garnering more stature. It's a close call, but in reading over various editions (I have two variations of the 1703 to refer to and some digital pages of the first set), there is enough constancy of language for me to say that Moxon was the final editor. As for the question of did he personally author the entire book? We just don't know that much about him as of yet.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#22

Re: Anthropology, not archeology

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I think it's the mindset of an island country conquered by invaders multiple times.

Pam

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#23

Re: Le weekend

ThomD

>"Ran out of time to discuss the foreign (French) words the English have mangled thru shear unwillingness to pronounce them correctly."

They do pronounce them correctly, they use the English pronunciation. Pahr-ee is a place in English consciousness, even if it is in France.

Reminds me of fly fishing, where some people use Latin names for insects, and some people use (often) evocative plain English. Of course some of these fancy scientific names caught on and became much loved. Then the scientists made new discoveries, and subdivided the insects into new groups with new names: More names than anyone remembers, can discern, or than will ever catch on. This kind of thing is why it is better to own your own words.

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#24

Haut bois

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Who invented 'high boy'?

Thom, I like your 'words' dissertation a lot.

We Amuricans are on thin ice, though, when we get onto the subject of word mangling.

Wiley

Re: Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*

#25

Re: Anthropology, not archeology

Peter Evans

>Adam, doesn't everyone have separate hot and cold water pipes? Do you have a heater at every hot water tap?

Cheers

Peter Evans in Sydney