Response to Stephen's British influence thread *LINK*
Larry Williams
>On Stephen's blog he had a post about British influence on American tools and discussion turned to Dutch influence on British tools. I think there are some common misconceptions about Dutch influence on British planes. Because I'm so late getting back to this, I thought I'd just post in a new thread with a link to the first.
There is a notion out there that British planes evolved from Dutch planes. The idea comes from some pretty knowledgeable researchers and authors. W.L. Goodman was one of the early writers who suggested this and it's been followed by others including Don and Anne Wing. In their book, Early Planemakers of London, the Wings again suggest this evolution.
While their book is probably the best and possibly the most important book on wooden planes to date, I disagree with the Wings assertion that British planes began as copies of Dutch planes. Like Goodman they start by citing the planes salvaged from the 1545 wreck of the Mary Rose. Because some of the Mary Rose planes appear to have rudimentary horns that could suggest those found on Dutch planes a connection is assumed. Yet if one examines Albrecht D�rer's 1514 engraving, Melencolia, one will see a fully formed Germanic smooth plane. D�rer's plane is very refined compared to the primitive appearing planes from the Mary Rose. The difference is dramatic and the Mary Rose planes appear more craftsman made.
Even through the 19th Century shipwrights and ship's carpenters had their own plane making tradition. They made their own planes and often used different materials than would have been used in plane making shops of the time. They had different needs than traditional bench trades and evolved different styles of planes. The razee plane is a good example of this.
I don't know of any direct evidence of a Dutch influence on the Mary Rose planes. There may have been some but there's no evidence. In fact the crude appearance of the Mary Rose planes suggest the tradition of craftsman made planes extended back that far.
The Wings also cite the early "English style" Dutch planes found at the Swedish Skoklosters Castle and a few similar planes found in Holland. It is insinuated that these planes were made for export to England or British colonies by their makers. None of those planes have any provenance that suggest they were intended for export by their Dutch makers. There is a 1645 invoice showing the Skoklosters planes were purchased in Amsterdam then shipped to Sweden. Not a single one of these planes has been found in England or locations that were British colonies. There are a number of refined features of early British planes that don't seem to appear in those "English style" planes. I've never had one in my hands but I have examined the drawings and photos and don't see evidence those features were incorporated in the Dutch planes. In fact, these advanced and important functional features didn't show up on Continental planes until the late 1900's if at all.
The important features that are missing from Dutch and other Continental planes are spring, leaning wedges and boxing. Spring improves cutting geometry, controls mouth opening, enables deeper profiles and allows for an easier to sharpen plane. Leaning wedges improve shaving clearance, improve bedding of the iron, assures a full-width iron when it's important and improves the ease of making planes.
But wait, you say, boxing wasn't used in British planes until somewhere around the middle of the 18th Century. I know there aren't documented examples of boxed British planes until around then but there is other evidence. Perhaps the most sophisticated planes the British developed were the snipes bill planes. The delicate point of these planes require the use of a dense hard wood like boxing if they're going to enter into marking gauge layout lines and begin the conversion to the intended profile. While they could have been made of solid boxwood, such construction wouldn't have been ideal because of cost and stability problems. The practice of boxing would, I think, have been quickly developed for these and other planes with small fine features. As early as 1680 Joseph Moxon describes snipes bill planes used in conjunction with hollows and rounds for producing mouldings. Again in 1736 Richard Neve lists snipes bills as used with hollows and rounds. In 1790 Thomas Sheraton described the process of entering gauge lines with these planes.
According to Goodman, Mark and Jane Rees and the Wings; the late 17th and early 18th Centuries was the time frame that the British were copying Dutch planes. Yet we know the Dutch and other Continental plane makers never developed produced snipes bill planes. At the time the British were supposedly just beginning their plane production by imitating the Dutch they were actually making more sophisticated planes than were ever produced by the Dutch.
I am aware that the Dutch were the leaders in the development of optics, scientific instruments and other things. This may be one reason it was assumed the more embellished Dutch planes were the fore-runners of British planes. Perhaps an uninformed observer could mistake the ornamental embellishment of the Dutch planes as a mark of superiority over the more utilitarian looking British planes.
Another place one could look for evidence of the British importing of Dutch planes would be in the early import tariff rate books. From the early 1600's on there were duties on all kinds of tools and those tools were listed individually in the Rates of Merchandize. Tariffs were listed for plane irons, chisels, chisel handles, anvils, grind stones and other tools but planes simply aren't listed. If there had been a trade in planes, there would have been tariffs on imported planes. That says a lot.
Today when someone tells me the British began plane making by copying Dutch planes I ask for their evidence. I haven't heard of any evidence that shows this. In fact, the evidence I'm aware of is that the British had their own robust woodworking tradition and, very early, developed planes that were superior to those produced elsewhere.
Stephen's thread



