Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

handplaning quartersawn oak

Posts

handplaning quartersawn oak

#1

handplaning quartersawn oak

Ed DeLauter

>I'm having tearout issues on quartersawn oak drawer faces. Iron(s) are sharp (whatever that is) and mouth is tight. Tearout occurs in either grain direction. The wood has alot of "tiger stripping." Skewing plane helps somewhat. Would it help to wet the surface prior to planing, like with maple?

Dazed and Confused,

Ed

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#2

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Can you go to a higher angle plane? Or use a back bevel to increase angle of attack?

Wiley

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#3

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You may have rediscovered the reason that quartered oak doesn't appear often in 18th century American furniture. It plans nicely with my thickness planer.

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#4

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

R.J. Whelan

>Ed ... try a diluted coat of shellac - about 2# cut. Should be able to plane within a half hour or so, in less your shop is very cold and/or damp.

Good luck ... rj

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#5

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think the reason quartersawn oak is rare in the 18th century has more to do with style than technology. Oak is rather a coarse wood for 18th century refinement. There is no shortage of quartersawn oak in American furniture from the 17th century.

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#6

Try planing it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>At a 45 deg angle to perpetuation to the grain. Sometimes this helps. Also sharpness is key here. Oak dulls blades quite quickly.

Time to fire up the Weber, it's getting to be turkey time!

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

#7

Re: handplaning quartersawn oak

Ed DeLauter

>RJ,

Thanks for the shellac suggestion! I must try this method. It is interesting that of the 5 drawers I have made thus far it is only the one drawer face that has proven uncooperative. The rest have cleaned up nicely with my wooden smoother.

I don't have a vast armada of handplanes to try and overcome the tearout with. I have used a couple German wooden smoothers and a Bailey number 4. Changing the attack angle on the cutting iron with a back bevel is another option I suppose.

The grain clarity is so much more pronounced with the planed surfaced that I hate to resort to a sanded surface on this 1/4 sawn.

Thanks for the tips guys,

Ed