Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Bill Tendall sharpening

Posts

Bill Tendall sharpening

#1

Bill Tendall sharpening

Stephen

>Bill can you use a kanaban to put diamond paste on for sharpening or is it made from different metal and cast iron would still be better?

Re: Bill Tendall sharpening

#2

Re: Bill Tindall sharpening

Wendell @ Murphy, TX

>I tried using Kanaban plates from Japan Woodworker as a substrate for 1/2 and 1/4 micron diamond paste. It did not work well for me. The plate kept getting gummed up and sticky no matter what I used to try and clean the plate. I had bought the paste from Joel at Tools for Working Wood so I emailed him about my issues. He had only tried 45 micron paste on the Kanaban plates and couldn't help with my problem. I suspect they work fine for the coarser grits but polycarbonate or acrylic works well too and is cheaper.

Wendell

Re: Bill Tendall sharpening

#3

I would guess....

John in NM

>that steel is not an adequate substitute for cast iron, as the crystal structures of the metals are different and diamond seems to work best with non-heterogeneous crystal structures. These alloys have soft areas that allow the diamond to embed and hard areas that resist deformation so that the blade won't dig in (or with stone cutting, so that the facets remain as flat as possible). Copper, tin, or lead/tin work great at holding diamond, but are probably too soft (and expensive) to be effective for sharpening uses.

Then again, people use MDF and wood blocks, so maybe the softness isn't much of a problem. A piece of copper sheet glued to a stone tile would make a good test - its already plenty flat enough for sharpening, being cold rolled, and stone tiles are readily available for a couple bucks at HD or wherever. You can probably get broken ones free even. When cutting stones, diamond is typically pressed into the soft lap with a bearing or with a stick of ceramic material.

Re: Bill Tendall sharpening

#4

don't know but copper is poor

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't know what a Kanaban is. I do know that copper is poor. I got some sheets of circuit board that are resin and glass on one side and copper on the other. The tool to be sharpened didn't slide well on copper.

I admire the creativity demonstrated in coming up with all sorts of ideas for the diamond substrate, but keep in mind cast iron has been in use for centuries and if there was something equivalent it would by now be common knowledge.

Acryllic works ok for coarser grits, but the tool is grabby with the fine grits.

The thing about cast iron is that it both embeds the diamond and provides nice sliding action of the tool across it.

Re: Bill Tendall sharpening

#5

you're right, its typically for coarser grits...

John in NM

>Once one moves from cutting to polishing, lead/tin alloys or tin alone is more typically used than copper. In general the harder alloys work better, and even then they're soft enough for the stone to start picking up metal when its time to recharge the lap. I hadn't really thought of that - you're more polishing than cutting.

The only cast iron laps I've seen in use were in a shop making petrographic thin sections. I think diamond cutters still use them too, but they're virtually unknown in domestic amatuer faceting. The trouble is all the lapidary substitutes I know of are more exotic than cast iron!

I'd think with all the junk planes floating around ebay, and old machine tools in scrap yards it wouldn't be so hard to find a pre-flattened bit of cast iron. How about an old wood stove top? Not really a machined surface I guess.

Re: Bill Tendall sharpening

#6

Re: don't know but copper is poor

ThomD

>I believe a Kanaban is supposed to be iron. In Odate he says they are similar to iron lythographer's plates in function, but made of steel. In the Masterpiece Tools catalog from the 70s they are refered to as "honing plates - or iron boards - made of special soft steel"... That clears it up for me. :)

My guess is that it is mostly just cold rolled.