Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

saw sharping

Posts

saw sharping

#1

saw sharping

Jerry Schram

>I picked-up a couple of split nut disston hand saw a few mounths ago, I went to sharpen them yesterday and they just ate my nicholson files. I've read that the heat treating of the saw blades was not very consistant back then, but these saw have been sharpend before. Thanks for any help! Jerry

Re: saw sharping

#2

Re: saw sharping

MikeW

>Some saws are plain hard. You will likely need better files. I would buy a couple from Pete Taran. He sells Grobet.

Also, I am assuming that the blade is well clamped and the gullets low to the top of the clamp. Vibration will hasten the failure of a saw file, especially on hard steel.

Take care, Mike

Re: saw sharping

#3

Re: saw sharping

Alexander Grigoriev

>Nicholson files don't even hold against card scrapers currently sold. Their mill file gets dull instantly if I try to join a scraper with it.

Re: saw sharping

#4

Re: saw sharping

Bob Demers

>Interesting. Never had similar problems with my Nicholson's files, but then again they are like me, antiques :-)

Sound like Nicholson quality (tempering for one) went down the proverbial tube. Are they now outsourced to China and made of lead? :-)

I have a few Grobet, and they are superb files, althought, like my Nicholsons they are not recent...

Bob, single 'file' by the right..Quick march!

Re: saw sharping

#5

Re: saw sharping

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Jerry,

Some of those really old saws will in fact have hard spots or sometimes the whole blade will be harder than other saws. If you find that it's only a hard spot, be carefull if you set the teeth. Sometimes I just skip setting if there are only a few teeth involved. Better to have no set than no teeth.

Make sure your saw is clamped as close to the bottom of the teeth as possible without filing into the clamp jaws. Vibration is a file killer. Also it's best if the blade is clamped evenly the full length of the blade. Some of the old saw vises do a lousy job of clamping. Nichelson files are not the best, but I've used a lot of them with success. The trick is to make them cut with each stroke. Any sharp edge will dull faster if you don't make it bite.

Marv

Re: saw sharping

#6

Re: saw sharping

Alexander Grigoriev

>Lee Valees gives a no-name file with their scraper set, and that file holds pretty well against those sper-hard scrapers. I don't know where it's made; could be in Taiwan.

Re: saw sharping

#7

Re: saw sharping

Jerry Schram

>Thanks all I have'nt had a problem sharping other saws with nicolson files they just seem to skate over the teeth on these two saws.