Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Tennon Saw Length

Posts

Tennon Saw Length

#1

Tennon Saw Length

Al

>Hi folks. I'm looking for some input on length of a tennon saw. I have an opppurtunity to purchase a saw and I was looking at Adam's tennon saws, but can't decide bnetween the Jointer's or the Cabinetmaker's Tennon saw.

I do a variety of work, half carpentry half furniture making, and I sort of lean towards the idea that a longer saw ensures better accuracy. In terms of immediate needs, the next project on my list is buiding 27 storm windows for the house, which entails a whole lot of smaller tennons. after that I ahve a couple of tavern tables to make which involves several larger tennons for the table aprons.

So here's the question (aside from owning both saws)is it easier to cut small tennons with a large saw or large tennons with a small saw?

Both have adequate depth of cut for the work I do so it's mostly just the TPI and length that I'm concerned with.

Thanks for your input.

Al R.

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#2

Re: Tennon Saw Length

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Depends on how fast you want to cut and how wide the piece of wood in which the tenon will be formed. I forget the exact numbers, but the teeth have to be cleared of wood after cutting, and it takes n number of teeth free and clear to achieve this. A rough guide would be a saw length of 3 times the wood width.

Also, according to a Japanese saw expert whose advice I trust and have at least partially confirmed, one of the best ways to learn sawing is to use huge saws for little jobs.

Pam

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#3

Re: Tenon Saw Length

Adam Cherubini

>My opinion is that it's easier to cut large tenons with a smaller saw than vice versa.

I don't think blade length is related to accuracy. At least not directly. Provided the saw is deep enough for the cut, the saw design effects speed more than anything else.

I think Wenz tooths his tenons a bit finer than I do. I think he also includes a bit more rake and even a touch of fleam??? I suspect this combination will make his long saws a bit easier to use in smaller stock. So that may be a good choice.

This also depends on the stock. In hardwoods, the shorter, finer toothed saw will probably feel better to you than a coarser saw. In softer woods, the difference will be more subtle.

In the carcase I'm working on, tenons are less than 2" across. That's just too small IMHO for a 19" or 18" 10tpi saw. I make 2 tenon saws not because I want to sell more saws but because I think folks need 2. I certainly do. But then again, I'm fairly impatient. Sawing is a big deal in my shop. It's not a pastime.

Sorry I couldn't help more.

Adam

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#4

Re: Tennon Saw Length

MikeW

>Hi Al,

There is always a medium length. For me that is a 16" tenon saw. My personal one is filed at 10 PPI and find it great for both larger and smaller tenons.

My sash saw length is 14" and is 12 PPI. The sash is great for fairly small to tenons of a couple inches, but over that one saws for a longer period and I believe user fatigue begins to set in on more than a larger tenon or two.

You mention the majority of the upcoming tenons are for windows, with some on a table. I would elect to use my 16" tenon saw for either. If I was going to do more table apron tenons and the like than the smaller stuff, I would go for an even longer saw, though whether I used my 21" 8 PPI tenon saw is another matter...

Take care, Mike

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#5

Re: Tennon Saw Length

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>My experience has been that it's frustrating to try cutting a large tenon with a smaller saw. I'm thinking of when I had to use a fourteen inch saw on a six inch wide board. An extra two inches of saw makes a big difference in a situation like that. An eighteen inch saw would have probably been even better.

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#6

Re: Tennon Saw Length

Adam Cherubini

>No question. A 6" tenon is what those 18, 19" saws are designed for. And when you have that work, heck even a 3 or 4" tenon, you're glad if you have one of those long tenon saws. If you see a 3" tenon only once in a while and all the others are 2" wide, I think a 16" tenon saw is best.

I don't see a lot of wide tenons in philadelphia case work. At least not so far. That's why I made my 16" tenon. I see the wider tenons more in architectural work, beds, dining tables, etc. They are also helpful for workbenches and some tools and other workshop jobs. I personally, wouldn't want to choose between the two. It's a little like picking your favorite parent or child.

Just so everybody is on the same page, I'm not accepting any new tool orders at present. I'd like to make saws for my students in 2009. I'll try to make extras and sell them off as they become available to avoid any more long lead times for saws.

Adam

Re: Tennon Saw Length

#7

Re: Tennon Saw Length

Al

>Thanks everybody for the input. I appreciate it. I was also leaning toward something in the range of a 16 inch saw, although they're elusive these days so I went larger.

I've gone ahead and ordered Mike W's 19 inch kenyon saw. I figure that the length will help with my accuracy. It may take a few months to get here, but I have penty of other things to do until it arrives.

Thanks again for a the input. I appreciate it.

Al R.