We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I just can't let it go. One last trip report on Berea. I had the pleasure of sitting in on a couple of Adam's lectures, one on chisels and one on hand tool shop layout. I thought the mortising technique that he described was worth writing up. See the blog.
>I added a comments to that entry. I work primarily bevel down. Don't know if I worked BU or if that was a typo. Anything is possible. Also talked about my use of gauges.
Thanks for your interest. I hope you enjoyed this talk.
I guess I'm a little dense this morning, but I'm having trouble understanding any perceived advantage in using a mortise gauge for marking out the tenons and a single point marking gauge (and single line) for marking out the mortises - even when the rail and stile/leg are not co-planar.
As I see it, one needs to set the double points of the mortise gauge to the mortise chisel for marking the thickness of the tenons in any event - regardless of the method. It then needs to be set for the placement of the tenons in the thickness of the rail - again, regardless of the method. It can then be used to mark all the tenons. I see no difference in the two approaches so far.
So, I guess the difference comes in setting a/the gauge for marking the mortises. As I see it, if one simply resets the head of the mortise gauge (leaving the distance between the double points alone) to account for the set-back of the rail, then the same mortise gauge can be used to mark all the mortises. Isn't this essentially the same operation as setting a separate single point gauge for gauging one line only? So, I see no appreciable difference in the number of steps or amount of layout work between the two approaches, unless I'm missing something.
As to any advantage in the single gauge line for mortises, again I'm having trouble seeing it. Granted, the most direct approach is to allow the width of the mortise chisel to determine the width of the mortise - but that doesn't change whether one is using a single or double gauge line(s). If one can't set the mortise gauge accurately to the mortise chisel in any event, doesn't that lead to accuracy issues when it comes to the tenon? In other words, as I see it, accuracy in setting the mortise gauge is helpful regardless of the approach, and I fail to see the down-side of double lines for the mortises if they are accurate.
Though I do tend to use a couple gauges--and identify one with a small piece of tape as to the double-pin one I use for mortises. I use two so I can avoid resetting the fences should I need to remake a part.
However, using a mortiser (I know, an evil powered tool) I did often use a single-pin gauge for the marking the side of the mortise toward me (away from the mortiser's fence). The tips of the hollow chisel on the mortise machine are easy to line up into the single gauge line.
I would set the gauge against the show face of the stile, adjust the pin to the far side of the mortise (which I cut first). This added the reveal amount, the tenon shoulder and tenon thickness.
I only have one mortise gage. The pins are fixed. If the tenons are nearer the reference face (set back from the leg stock say), and you don't want to move the head of your mortising gauge, you need 2 gauges. Right?
Now one can argue that it's not a big deal to move the gage heads. And it's not. But when the difference between the leg face and the rail face is 1/8" or less (1/8" step between stile and rail), it's not hard to make a mistake. And there are parts all over the bench. For my 17th c forme, I think I counted 28 mortises and tenons.
So what I have done is use my mortising gauge solely for tenons. Never changes throughout the project. For mortises, I don't really need two lines, so I just use my only other gauge, my single pin marking gauge for this.
With my mortising technique, it's fairly easy to work to a single gauge line accurately. Sometimes when you chop the wood can pull the chisel one way or the other. Practice helps. Not working too deeply helps. Working mahogany or green oak helps. But I've not seen a lot of folks who chop and don't pare the walls when they are done. I think a double line helps these folks an isn't necessary for me so much.
I'm learning more about how my posts are interpreted. What I'm hoping is that what I've written is clear. Fine with me if you (plural) think it's a stupid idea. I had to say this in Berea a couple times: I'm not seeking converts to my mortise religion. I've never sought that. I'm offering an alternative that I can produce good results with quickly with very little tool wear. This thing with the gauges seems to me to be one more little side benefit. Note that this technique only works for long shallow mortises. Short, deep sash mortises must be chopped as usual.
>When I work I use a lot of gauges. In order to keep everything straight I will put tape over the adjustment screw and if need be write what it's for (Mortise, tenon, table tenons, etc). The tape is an indication that the gauge is set and sometimes in the course of the project the gauges can stay set for months.
"I only have one mortise gage. The pins are fixed. If the tenons are nearer the reference face (set back from the leg stock say), and you don't want to move the head of your mortising gauge, you need 2 gauges. Right?"
You don't need two mortise gauges or repeatedly reset the head of one if you are working in an orderly and workmanlike manner. In other words, if you use the mortise gauge to mark all the tenons, you need only reset it once to mark all the mortises. No more work, nor more confusing, than setting two different gauges. They are called mortise gauges, right?
>I think that even with an orderly and workmanlike manner, anything is possible. I've had times where I'll be marking out piles of parts, on each end, for drilling or mortising, or whatever... and I'll find as I'm doing the drilling that there will inevitably be one end that I missed, forgot to flip the part around, and make the marks. Or, something could go wrong in the operation, or afterward, and I need to make and lay out a new piece. For some things, like Pam suggests, where the joint is flush, the setting never changes. But if there's a set-back on one of them, like the forme stretchers Adam's talking about, (I think?) then the setting has to be changed to make a new mark.
I took to using the single line marking technique a while ago, because it made more sense to me, and it seemed simpler, and more intuitive. If you're chopping accurately, to a straight line, then the other side of the mortise will be straight, too. The hole made by the chisel will of course be the width of the chisel... why would you then need to lay out a line to show you how wide your chisel ought to be? If the gauge is accurately set to be exactly the size of the chisel... then the second line is redundant, it will be removed when you chop.
In the end, I think the relevant point is that the tenon has to fit the mortise. And you can fit a tenon to a mortise regardless of how you marked out the mortise. For some people, the second line helps them out, and that's fine. For me, it was always something to pare to, and I know from experience that paring mortises generally leads me into trouble. If I have to pare the mortise, it's because I did a sloppy job of chopping. And by that point, the second line is meaningless, because the mortise is going to end up being wider than the chisel anyway. That gets made up by cutting a thicker tenon... which gets laid out to a measurement set to the width of the new mortise... assuming, of course, that it's still straight.
So I like Adam's argument that the mortise gauge is more useful for laying out tenons. If your mortise was chopped, and not pared, then it's exactly the width of the chisel, and so should your tenon be. But sawing tenons is a different animal entirely... at least until someone like Glen Drake comes out with a double handled, double bladed, pistol grip tenon sawing saw.
Maybe the name of the gauge is misleading. Maybe it's the mortise gauge, because, (predicating this point on Adam's argument) you're using it to gauge how wide your finished mortise is, so that you can then use the gauge to mark out your tenon.
All of the above is, as usual, just as much for the sake of argument as for academic discussion purposes, so please don't take it personally. In no way do I, nor do any of my campaign staff mean to imply, that a gauge should be used in any other way than that historically traditional way which has been passed down to us from previous generations. These normal ways of doing things have served us well for hundreds of years, and there's no pressing need to change them now. And while I think that those who choose to work and use their marking gauges in an alternative style should be granted equal status and privileges in our woodworking community, that does not mean that I condone or subscribe to such a practice myself.
Even if it makes sense.
Wow... I need more coffee.
Adam... please keep doing what you're doing, please keep speaking how you're speaking. Let the people take it how they will. It takes a lot of time to get to the little insights that pop up on their own, and I for one think they make for good reading, and I can't wait to see how it's reflected in your tools.