Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Ellis Walentine

>Well, last weekend's excitement threw me off my "ides" schedule (what else is new?), but, undaunted, here I am with this month's provocative woodworking-related survey topic: "Cocooning." Most of us are no strangers to recessions and I'm wondering how you think hard(er) times affect your woodworking -- your time spent in the shop, you tool, material and supply purchases, and your project decisions. A lot of people put off buying a new home during hard times and opt to stay close to home and improve their existing homes instead. Often, it means more shop time rather than less. If any of this resonates with you, I'd like to hear your thoughts.

As usual, all replies will be harvested, winnowed, threshed (thrashed?), and baked into a fine confection to be served up in our column "News & Views from WoodCentral.com" in the next issue of Woodworker West magazine.

Join the fun today. Register your thoughts on this fascinating question. And, thanks for participating!

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Hank Knight

>Unfortunately, hard times will probably not affect my woodworking at all. I had planeed to retire at the end of this year and devote lots of time to my hobby. But that isn't going to happen for a while, given the state of the economy and the stock market. So I will reamin a weekend woodworker and continue watch many of my weekends be eaten up by other commitments.

Hank

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

"RJ" Whelan

>I am a professional cabinet and furniture maker.

Over the last three years I have carved out a little niche for myself building highly customized entertainment cabinets and suites. I seem to be the only woodworker in my small market area doing these.

I am typically dealing with houses in the upper end of the price spectrum for my area; probably the top 5-10% of the housing market. While inflation and depressed investment income affect these clients, I get the feeling that these folks are still willing to spend money on their homes.

I made the decision about six months ago to lower my hourly rate by $5/hour. I did this based on a hunch; whether my normal rate would have caused me to lose jobs or not is pure speculation and I may have forfeited a few thousand dollars for no reason.

Being a professional, I make my equipment purchase decisions pretty pragmatically: if a new piece of equipment is replacing something broken or worn out I don�t have to think too long. If a new piece of equipment saves me time or allows me to perform a task more precisely I will usually go ahead, but I may defer the purchase until I have put the money aside. In the present economy I am not purchasing anything on credit or open account. The interest savings can be pretty significant � I just bought a slot mortiser (after saving for 2 years) and saved $600 in interest by paying cash. Most of my suppliers offer 2-3% cash discounts and one of them offers free material delivery (200 miles each way) on cash orders over $500.

Most suppliers offer quantity discounts and I used to take advantage of these almost every time. In the present economy I am less likely to spend several hundred extra dollars in materials that may end up being stored in my shop for quite some time.

Because my shop is booked out (typically) six months, I explain to my clients that they can make the material deposit (35-40%) at the time the estimate is accepted (14 day window) and I will purchase their materials well in advance and lock in the price. If they choose to wait until I�m ready to begin work I will recheck all of my material costs and adjust the bid accordingly. Most of my clients have gone the early deposit route. As an example: I am building two bathroom suites for a client and purchased the Honduras Mahogany in May � if I had to buy it today it would cost me just over $2/bf more.

Anyway, this is my take on the present situation. Any value my opinions have certainly must be filtered taking into account that I have almost no competition, most of my clients are in the upper end of the income spectrum and I live and work in tiny, remote market.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#4

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

ThomD

>With the housing crisis a lot of people are not putting more money into their homes, according to Home Depot. I am doing some re-insulation and plastering in the entry vestibule, but only because the moisture situation finally got me moving.

As far as real woodworking is concerned, I am far overbought for the last 20 years, and the foreseeable 200. I could work the rest of my life to clear the projects and materials I already have. I don't find I do it though. I feel anxious and more as though I should be on the lookout, somehow, than spending time on trivial things. In fact I have sold about 3000 dollars worth of stuff just to reduce the feeling of over-supply. I find the market there is tightening too. I'm reading more books than usual. Books seem about the only thing that is helpful in preparing one for an uncertain future. Or give that feeling. Current affairs are all retrospective.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Stuart Hough

>I'm finding myself looking much harder at any purchase. I have all the big things I need. There are only two machines I need at this time, a good dust collector and an air cleaner. Other than that all I need is the material to work with. In my area there seems to be a decided lack of woodworking-related suppliers. The lumberyards (those not colored blue or orange) have only construction lumber. The borgs are also going up on the prices of their "premium hardwoods", which consist only of red oak and poplar. I'm finding myself looking at more non-traditional sources of wood, such as recycled flooring, and pallets. I came across a pallet made from cedar the other day. What a surprise! All in all, I seem to be in the shop a bit more often, though, due to the decision to forgo dining out more than twice a month. The wife told me to be more productive, so I am trying to be a goo hubby!

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#6

there are opportunities among the grief

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I think the current economic problems will last longer than people expect. People tend to have short economic memories and don't remember, or know about, recessions of 1980's and 1970's. The economy for the past several years was driven by unsustainable credit expansion. For the short term credit will contract and the economy will settle at a significantly lower rate from where it was.

Our good news is that hardwood lumber prices are free-falling. And when that happens quality goes up. This will be a good time to lay in a stash of your preferred hardwood lumber. More good news is that everyone is offering deals- no shipping charges, XX% off orders, rebates, etc. It will be a good time to buy stuff for those that lived prudently and don't have suffocating debt. I just bought 4 unfinished cherry ladder back chairs from a cabinet shop for a bargain price. They were delighted to be rid of inventory.

Businesses that depend on consumers have my sympathy (and some of my business at the expense of their distress).

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#7

Good points!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Other commodities (than wood) also going down. Gasoline we all know about. The front month contract for steel was $1,200/ton in June; now approx. $300/ton. With inventory still building.

But I fear for peoples' jobs.

Wiley

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Tom MacGregor

>We're refinancing our mortgage at 2-3/4% lower than we've been paying, and at a fixed rate. It pays to have good credit in a tight market. With the $15,000 we just had to put into a new septic mound system added in we'll still be paying $130 less per month. It's going straight into lumber to finally trim out the interior. More shop time & an improved house!

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Tony - Memphis

>Well, it really hasn't affected/effected? my woodworking at all...yet. I've been building my tool inventory for ten years, so I have prettymuch everything one might need to build whatever one might want too. I don't have room to keep a large inventory of wood, but I have enough to build a few projects. I'm primarily a weekend and evening woodworker, so I don't get THAT much time inthe shop, so I take a long time to complete a project. The garden bench I am building has been in the works for a few months. I must admit that I may not have bought the teak (very expensive) had the economy been in the state it is in now when I bought it. I would have just picked a different project. I work for a large corporation, so we are constantly concerned about job security. So far, so good. I'm not one to collect tools, so I don't buy many. I normally only buy something I have a genuine need for. So, I'm not having to cut back on any purchases related to the hobby really. Anyway, best of luck to everyone. Seems like someone posts regularly about a job loss or bad situation. Hope everyone makes it out of this ok.

Tony

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#10

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

ThomD

>I'm in a pretty good position, thought my post sounded a little whinny. I was all set to buy a 5K tool in the US then the bottom fell out of the C dollar, because apparently well run currencies aren't as desireable under the current conditions. That wince aside, I really can coun't my economic blessings. I am conservative and my strategy finally paid off. The only downside is that some of the people who bet the farm are getting a bailout at my expense. The big picture is OK for me. But it isn't really transfering to my woodwork. It should because I can easily spend the time and improve our standard of living without much cost.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#11

Evolution

David Miller from Iowa

>I posted before that I was laid off my "regular" job due to the economy. No biggie - I used to be a carpenter and became one again - didn't have much trouble finding jobs over the summer and did pretty well. Then I sawed my finger on the table saw and was off a couple months - now that is mostly better and I'm back in the saddle, but there is no work to be had.

So... I'm thinking of embracing the econonic downturn and starting a "Hard Times" resale store - used tools, used garden stuff, old bicycles - anything practical - no clothes or decor. Any suggestions?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#12

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Fun shop time goes way down

Jim in Burlington On

>I have renovated so many houses it really involves so little shop time. Ideally you set up a mini shop in the room or rooms your doing over. If you change structure there's you and a skill saw. Hand tool time goes way down. Home reno needs to be done with some true skill and speed. Making a little bit of trim doesn't really count in the home improvment. If your unsure just ask your signifigant other.LOL

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#13

Little different thought

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>David and all,

Don't want to divert the thread, but will throw this in, for whatever it may be worth....

I have an acquaintance who for years made a decent living as a window specialist in our little town. Every older house in our town has a whole bunch of windows, mostly double-hung, and many of them are painted shut, need reglazing, need rescreening, need repainting, need to be reweighted, need new sash, right up to total replacement. If you can get known, you can keep busy at this work.

Favorable points:

1. Not everyone can do this kind of work. Barriers to entry high if you don't have the tools and know-how.

2. There's lots of windows, many with problems.

3. Good 'word of mouth' factor, leading to more work.

4. The house you fix windows in may also need cabinets, etc.

Unfavorable points:

5. Negotiating price.

6. Getting paid.

7. It's a tough high-skill job, with a zillion details.

Really glad your hand is healing up OK!

Wiley

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#14

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Bob Demers

>Being a career military man, I have a fairly recession proof job. I say fairly because during the last recession in the 90s we went thru a rapid period of downsizing and shut the door to recruiting. It was the end of the cold war and all, but we are now paying a heavy price, manpower wise for that short sightness.

Also, because of the nature of my job, we move a lot around the country. For me its comming up to that time again. That only mean one thing: more time spend working on the house (reno for house flipping) than shop time. Mind you, many project includes real shop time, like im about to make new cabinet doors for the bathroom vanity etc..

The flipside of this, is that I have to continuously set up a new shop

and depending on my next location, I can buy more or less house, and make a bigger or smaller profit on my sale. Im hopping to move closer to a LV store this time :-)

This time will be either my last or second to last move before I retire. Ive already been warned by SWMBO that I should buy all my tools before 'we' retire. Problem is everytime I think I have everything I need Rob comes along with new must have (bracing myself for the 24 of nov :-) Darn you Rob, ill never be able to retire :-)

But as I age (mellow?) I find myself reconsidering my WW habits and needs and am in the process of paring down my kit with higher quality albeit more expensive stuff.

Once I retire, Im seriously thinking of buying myself a Sauer plane, cause its probably the only way ill be able to afford it...

Bob, so far recession proof

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#15

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

James Watriss

>Things have been a little weird. I'm actually setting up shop again.

I got out of North Bennet in Feb of '07, and set up a small one man shop down the street from my apartment. Things were touch and go as I got set up, made a few small things, and very little money. After a while I realized that I really couldn't stand working alone, and it had affected my general mood.

Back in April I got some news. The university that owned the old mill building that housed my shop (as well as many others) announced plans to turn it into some smashing new lab spaces, to expand the sci/engineering space, and try to get people from numerous disciplines in the same building together. Since then, they've put it on a back burner, since the crash of the credit market and subsequent turbulence. But it kicked off the current chain of events.

In July I emailed a couple of friends. I had had it with the one man shop thing, and I had had it with not knowing when I was going to get edged out of my building. So we decided to go in on a new space, which is further down the road from me, but it's much, much bigger... and I'm working with friends. I've been chronicling the new shop build at jameswatriss.blogspot dot com, for those who are curious to see how it's all been going together.

I'm still living on savings. I'm not going to lie, it's a hard road, watching money dwindle. On the other hand, I've been slowly finding my way to a number of small jobs. I did a handful of spring joints for a guy the other day who's trying to re-work some of his house. I found a small store that might be able to buy a small number of trestle bases for butcher block tables. And so on. Until we're able to fire up dust collection, I won't be able to do full steam work, but we're almost there.

I'm in a weird area, surrounded by colleges, and academics, and younger professionals, and the money is generally tight, but still flowing. There are a lot of old buildings, and I think there's more work to be found, but I've been very focused on the shop, since it's hard to sell services I can't provide yet. We'll see if that was a wise move or not.

My read on the current environment is that there's a lot of people who have spent the last 10 or 15 years playing video games, or chasing down academic roads under the assumption that a college education guaranteed a good job. People may be spending less on their homes, but I think that many of them will start to spend more once it's clear that they're going to be stuck with their homes for a while if they don't want to lose money. That said, I don't think that many of the Home Depot weekender crowd know that much about how to do things for themselves anymore. So I think that there's money to be made in working for them, or helping them. There are a lot of hack job tradesmen out there, but there's still room, I think, for small, intelligent, skilled guys who understand that the world is rarely put together in a tab-A into slot-B kind of way.

I'm hoping to make a living building furniture on a small scale... large scale manufacturers have been dropping like flies, it seems. (It's made the used tool market a buyers' paradise for big, old iron. I have my eye on a 36" band saw that's tagged at $2500.) I have a feeling that I'll have to be as versatile as possible though. I'm not turning my nose up at anything right now... not even spring jointing Borg Oak to be made into stair treads. It was 4 hours of work, for $200. Not a lot of money, but a profitable use of time.

At the end of the day, I have the reassurance of knowing that I'm in possession of the knowledge and tools to build all kinds of things... or to figure out how if I need to. I may end up having to do work I don't feel like doing, but I think things are going to move in a better direction. The green movement seems to be affecting forecasts for future jobs, and there's been talk in the news about a green economy. I think there's going to be a market for things that are made in a more durable fashion, as people come to understand that the disposable Ikea lifestyle is another way of throwing away money. Sustainable growth timber is a funny concept if it's being made for disposable goods... it's just another way of saying the stream of wasted money, and trash en route to the dump will never end.

All of that, of course, is only good if there's money around to buy my services. I'm pretty sure I'm not going to be making top dollar for a little while yet. But hopefully I'll be well positioned when things pick back up.

I'm hopeful, still working, losing money, but trying to become a viable manufacturer/producer of wooden... anything.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#16

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi James,

May I suggest that you focus on high-end kind of specialty items. Someone out there has all the money. Usually, those kind of people don't know what woodworking tools and machines are all about and will fork over lots of their wealth to people like you who have the special skills to make what they feel is unique and unavailble from any other source. Don't under value your skills, go for the big bucks. Often times the same amount of time is spent building something cheap as it takes to build something expensive.

Marv

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#17

Architectural woodworking

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've long thought that architectural woodworking could be a very profitable business, especially in the Boston area. Lot of fun, too. It's at least as much fun to make a tea house as a high boy.

The only potential problem is that if you're a success, you get tagged, which may make it hard to move to fine furniture.

Pam

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#18

Re: Architectural woodworking

James Watriss

>There are a lot of people working on built ins and things like that, I think it'd be interesting to do architectural work that was at least not plywood-based. A tea-house could be fun.

I do have friends who went to school for fine furniture, but ended up doing built in work, and yes, they've been tagged, and that's the kind of work they do right now.

But I guess it's better to be doing work than not doing work right now.

My current problem is a marketing one. I know how to to work with wood, but that's not the same thing as having business acumen or marketing skills. I'm getting there, though.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#19

Marketing, et al

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>One of the things I realized early on in running my business (software development, for 20+ years), is that while I could learn how to do everything associated with marketing, selling, payroll processing, administration, etc., I really didn't want to nor did I have the time. We were undercapitalized from day one; so for a long time we did the work that came to us via word of mouth, which kept us alive but not prospering. You have no idea the begging I did to find a president, but no one would bite because we simply didn't have enough money (true entrepreneurs are few and far between).

So, the lesson? Hire friends to do those things you can't or don't have time to do. Form a consortium of others with like problems so you can, as a group, fund those activities. Join larger groups of woodworkers (in my case, the Mass Software Council was extremely helpful). There are also gov't groups and/or agencies who can help (SCORE, for example).

I honestly don't understand why so many woodworkers think they can successfully start a one person operation straight out of school. I understand the appeal, but it's impractical. There's an amazing amount you (impersonal) can learn from more experienced people, and the easiest place to do this is working for their companies for a while (I spent 12 years developing software for corporate America before starting Pinehill). It also allows you to build up some capital.

Pam

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#20

Re: Marketing, et al

James Watriss

>I can't answer as to why so many think they can up and go straight out of school. Me, personally, I think it was probably the best road. I've been told too many times in to many places that I have some kind of attitude problem. I have no poker face whatsoever, and while I'm always willing to put in 100%, an eyebrow always goes up whenever I hear something stupid, or that seems wasteful of time, effort, or materials. Once in a while, there was a really good reason that got laid out to me, but a lot of the time I saw things differently and I was able to find a way that made more sense to me, and got things done better and quicker. I got told more than once that "Nobody likes a smart-ass."

I've paid dues in many places before, and I don't expect that starting up my own business will be any different. School of hard knocks is just that way. But at this stage of the game, I'll learn how to do things, and I'll learn them my way, because that's the way I've always been. I'm only 34, so I'm still wet behind the ears. But I also pick things up pretty quickly, and I've learned more in a year about project management, shop layout and organization, time management, and how to streamline things, than I've ever learned by working for someone else.

I'm Larry Wall's kinda guy... lazy, impatient, and filled with hubris. But I work with wood.

I'm pretty confident that I'll do well eventually. I've seen dumber people than I am do very well for themselves. But I'm also very much aware that it's going to take a lot of fast learning and doing things on the fly. Maybe it's a head full of rotten apples. Or, maybe I'm headed in the right direction. Time will tell... wish me luck.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#21

Good luck :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#22

Keep your options open

Dave Anderson NH

>Hi James, A very good friend of mine jokes that he has failed at being a full time professional furnituremaker 3 times. He is a graduate of the Leeds Design School in western MA which doesn't exist anymore, taught there, and did post grad work at RISD with Tag Frid many years ago. He still makes the occasional piece of furniture for customers and of the highest quality and design, but his major income is from architectural and he almost never uses plywood. He will do the occasional bathroom and he does a lot of walnut and mahogany solid wood libraries. He has done work in about half of the historic houses in Strawberry Banke from general rehab to actual structural work. His work is top notch and he is normally booked from 9 months to 2 years in advance. His mid 6 figure income has put 2 kids through college without loans and allows him to provide his wife with a barn for her horses that features a shower, flush toilet, and all the other amenities. He doesn't feel any less a woodworker or designer and his advestising is entirely word of mouth... not even a white or yellow pages free listing.

Consider all options and don't shy away from something you think you might not like until you've tried it and fouond out for sure. Obviously my free advice is worth what you've paid for it.

I wish you the best of luck no matter what your choices.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#23

Re: Keep your options open

James Watriss

>I sound militant, but in all honesty, I'm trying not to rule much out these days. Money is money.

I'd like to know more about your friend...

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#24

:^)....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Very nice story Dave. I like a somewhat happy ending.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

#25

More info

Dave Anderson NH

>Hi James,

You can visit his website at www.robertlacivita.com It pretty much speaks for itself, but only touches the surface of what he does.