The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I was tempted to wait until April ��.
�� for those for whom nothing is more important than the perfect bevel .. heh .. heh ..
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#2Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI
>A new must have ;) I have oftne wondered why people believe that because something is digital it is more accurate. I think it is due to brainwashing through marketing hype. Because a person has a number reading to the thousandths of an inch their brain assumes that the measurement is spot on.
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#3Yeah but...........................
Brent Smith, Montreal
>How do you fit the chip breaker with that thing on the iron?????? :)
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#4this post brightened an othewise gloomy day
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#5
Digital level
Jack Guzman from Maine
>That reminds of a guy I did some carpentry with years ago.We were building a deck using pressure treated southern yellow pine.When it came time to level the posts this guy got a fancy instrument out of his truck.It was a digital level in a fancy case.It looked like something that came out of Bridge City.Don't get me wrong,this tool worked.However,due to the properties of the material we were using if you put the level higher up on the post you get a different reading.I grabbed my beat-up six foot aluminum level that I paid about 15 dollars for and he put away his toy.I use a plum bob for longer posts and it's not digital either.Still stubbornly resisting technology---Jack
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#6This is only part joke...
Alexander Grigoriev
>Actually, this is the simplest way to check your gauge setup, if you don't have fixed angle gauges on hand.
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#7Re: Lee Valley, and the flat earth society
ThomD
>I like the original LV bevel angle gage, it is a lot more positive than the polygon one they now sell, though it presumably works better for most people.
The digital angle guide is only accurate to .1 degrees, the old spirit level in quality form is a lot more accurate. For either to work you have to have a set-up surface, that is accurate dead nuts zero, or you will have your bevel accurately set to the tangent plane of the earth, but not your guide. That's the beauty of the LV one; it is a world of it's bevel setting own.
Funny thing about those digital guides. For my metal work I wanted one of those badly about 2 years ago, they used to be sold at home depot, but gradually disappeared. I finally found an online source and ordered one for about 110. Of course, predictably, the market has been flooded with cheap ones since, which is a good thing in general.
That is the Lee Valley gage on a Starrett set-up level, which is accurate to some ridiculous increment you can work off for milling or lathe operations.
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#8That wasn't, like, a driveby gloat, was it?
Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA
>I worked for an auto dealership that had one of those old cast iron levels - not sure 35 years later if it was a Starrett, I was even more ignorant then than now - that they used solely as a straight edge on car panels, kind of like using a micrometer to size olives.
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#9Re: This is only part joke...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Alexander
Agreed.
Set it once and then record the blade projection on a piece of ply or hardwood and add a stop. Then you have a permanent and accurate set up for your honing guides. However, I have tended to use a line off a protractor for the angle I want - the Wixey is a little OTT :)
Outside of BU plane blades, I generally only use a guide - the Kell in the picture - for mortice chisels. The ability to hone on the same spot each time means that you have less sharpening to do (and this is D1 steel!).
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#10Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Dan Donaldson
>I had an interesting experience one time long, long ago in a job assignment far, far away. We had some digital RMS voltmeters that were being used to measure some noise signals in the plant. At one time we had old mirrored scale analog meters, but they were replaced by the digital type because they could be interfaced to a computer. We were getting some readings close to, or slightly out of spec and I went looking for the cause. A reading of the mfg specs for the digital meters showed that, by design, they were not capable of making the readings that we needed. This had been totally overlooked because they were "digital" and must be better ;-) (The old analog meters WERE capable)
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#11Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Peter Evans
>Of course there are analogue methods. The advantage of this device is that, once you have the angle correct you can hone in the direction of Magnetic North (or True North if you have the appropriate chart) so aligning the iron molecules and thereby strengthening the edge.
The iron is a Stanley Australia (fairly) modern laminated (with HSS) blade; the best blade Stanley ever made (in Tasmania of all places) anywhere.
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#12Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Peter
The last time I was in Hobart (in January this year) I was hoping I might run into those blades (figuratively speaking). No such luck. I did find a bunch of new (made in Tassie ... "Tasmania" for those over the Pond) Stanley blades at the Salamanca Markets that I grabbed. These were pre-heat treatment and pre-bevelling. I plan to use the steel for knives.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#13Re: That wasn't, like, a driveby gloat, was it?
ThomD
>Not on the wood forum, no. But you give me hope, Bill. I didn't know it was gloatworthy, till now!
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#14Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Peter Evans
>Derek, I think Tony Blanks has bought all the blades still in existence on the island; I do not know where I picked up the 2 I have. I am looking forward to getting back to Tassie, we spend 3-4 months traveling each year, but there is so much to do in this country. Weddings, offspring living overseas, and grandkids also gobble up our traveling time. 2010 is our circumnavigation.
Cheers
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#15Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
Alexander Grigoriev
>I must be not understanding something... but why the level is not upside down? :P
Re: The ultimate in setting up a honing guide?
#16The wonders of the Internet
Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA
>One of the subtle features of the Internet is not well known: the automatic adjustment of images to correct for longitude, latitude, and coriolis effect. If you viewed Derek's and Peter's pictures as they were sent from their computers in Oz on your computer in the Northern Hemisphere, you would indeed see them upside down. Sophisticated computer software corrects this problem based upon the location of the viewer.
Notice, too, the reference in Peter's post to Magnetic North. That originally read, "magnetic south," since, down there in Oz, Magnetic North is an awfully long ways away, while Magnetic South is just below New Zealand.



