Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Posts

OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#1

OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Once again, I turn to the collective wisdom of this group for an off-topic question.

I'm tapping a few holes in 1/4" acrylic today as another attempt to repair our vacuum cleaner - the front caster broke some time back, breaking the plastic body in the process. I glued and pop-riveted a sheet of acrylic under the break, both to reinforce it and to provide a platform for casters.

The casters didn't work, falling apart pretty quickly, so now I'm going to try a wooden leg - a two-layer wood prop with a large-diameter (2-1/2") furniture glide on the bottom (this was LOML's idea).

I need to fasten the wood to the acrylic, and plan to drill and tap it for #10 machine screws. My question: in general in metal, fine threads are stronger (my understanding has been that the strength comes from the root of the thread in each metal component, so finer thread = more roots; but I'm always open to learning more precisely why this is true). Is the same true in acrylic? That is, should I go for 10-32, which would give me eight threads in the 1/4" of acrylic, or 10-24, which would give me six? Or is acrylic happier with chunkier threads?

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#2

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Neal in San Jose

>I poked around on Tap Plastics web site, and they were silent on that particular question. They did say that normal metal working taps would work just fine (no pun intended). I think I would go with the fine thread for the reason you mentioned. I have done a little threading in plastic, and it worked very well, but didn't worry much about strength. It sounds like your "fix" would be easily "fixable" again if it doesn't work out.

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#3

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Neal,

If this one doesn't work, it's time to spend somewhere north of $100 for replacement parts - so I sure hope it works!

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#4

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

ThomD

>Bolts normally fail first, but in your case it will be the plastic due to the difference in materials. Coarse threads have more shear strength, therefore it will be harder to pull out of the hole, a shear failure of the threads. Fine threads have a lower pitch so develop greater loading for the same torque on drive, which is not your performance issue. Also bolts normally fail first due to smaller cross section, and fine threaded bolts have the beefier root diameter, again, not your prime concern due to materials factors.

I would go with the coarse. They may have less friction holding them in, so either tap the hole leaving it a little under diameter (might spall the plastic), or use some kind of cement to retain the bolt. Silicone seal is surprisingly effective in these kinds of application.

OT to this subject, some of you have heard me talk about epoxy bonding into wood. Thats the same kind of deal. Substitutes a heigher strength socket of epoxy to create a better shear factor and distribute it over a wide area that the wood can handle.

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#5

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

david brown

>I treat acrylic like aluminum. The strength of the threads is more a function of how well you tap than the tap you chose. If you practice good technique, like backing out the tap to clear the shavings, keep the tap perfectly vertical, etc you'll have strong threads.

I'm not totally clear on what failed on your first fix attempt. Did you try to reattach the original caster to your vacuum or some other sort of caster?

On a repair like that, where plastic breaks, I try to repair with a mechanical fix like rivets and an adhesive like JB Weld or expoxy. The JB weld and epoxy never bond to a plastic 100% but when you reinforce that with a mechanical fastener the combination works very well.

My daughter recently broke part the handle on her backpack where it attaches to the main frame sheet. The frame sheet is some sort of glass filled polymer. When I reattached the handle I used rivets and JB Weld. That fix will last longer than the rest of the backpack.

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#6

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>I used some hardware store casters, which fell apart almost immediately - ball bearings all over the place and eventually the pivoting part of the assembly fell out of the baseplate. Very disappointing.

I'm not inexperienced with field repairs - I have, after all, owned two air-cooled VW buses* - but by the time I was informed of the problem, the case was so damaged that it was beyond rivets and glue alone. Bonding the acrylic to the bottom of the case gave me a working surface to attach something to. The casters just weren't the right thing to attach.

*When I was young, the saying was that VWs were great cars for the young mechanically inclined owner because they were nice and simple to learn on. What I found out was that part of why you learned so much about cars working on them was the frequency with which you had to work on them, with the corollary being that you learned how to fabricate fixes, like dealing with vibration-induced cracks in the sheet metal shrouding around the motor. That doesn't explain why I bought another one in my 40s; only romance or insanity can explain that decision. I am now cured of the insanity; I do still recognize the romance, but am happier to have cars that don't require valve adjustments and oil changes every three months.

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#7

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

Here's an idea that works in a lot of situations where threads in plastic can be dubious.

If you haven't gone too far, you could embed a #10 hex nut on the back side of the plastic, with a clearance hole through from the front side.

Make the plastic piece big enough so you have at least 1/4" of plastic between the edge of the nut and the outer edge of the plastic.

Marv

Re: OT - tapping acrylic: coarse or fine better?

#8

Plexiglas Tips

Al Goldstein

>Bill,

I've been a lurker on this site for a long time learning woodworking tips from experienced woodworkers. Now I can payback some of the great tips I have learned here.

For many years I mostly worked with Plexiglas in my home shop to make some water tanks for my day job. By trial and error I learned to work with Plexi.

First, I would go with the coarse threads because Plexi isn't strong enough to support fine threads. Metal is.

Second, a standard metal tap with four flutes will cut threads in Plexi, but with difficulty. The problem is the small size of the flutes and the large size of the Plexi cuttings. The flutes fill up and you have to keep removing the tap and cleaning out the flutes. Also, I used a cutting solution of water and dish washing liquid. No laughs, it worked.

While a standard four flute tap will do for a small number of holes, a three flute tap (with larger flutes) will work much better without having to keep removing the tap to clean out the flutes.

Finally, if one will be making lots of holes in Plexi it would be better to get a drill bit made for Plexi. I can't describe in technical terms the shape of a Plexiglas drill, but all you have to do is go to a plastics shops and buy one. It makes drilling acrylics a lot easier with much less internal stress that might eventually cause a crack.

Hope this helps. Good luck.

Al