Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Posts

Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#1

Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>First of all, thanks to all here who provided advice about Japanese bench chisels. The advice was very helpful. I mentioned that I would post a follow-up so here it is:

I have a birthday coming up in a week that will be one of those "decade" birthdays...that I care not to discuss. But to soothe my pain my wife green lighted me to treat myself to a special tool buy. So I ponied up the money and bought a 10 piece set of Akio Tasai "Polishing Finish" bench chisels with Rosewood handles.

This is my third set of bench chisels since I started woodworking. My first set were Marples Blue Chip. My second set were LN bench chisels and now these. Cost wise...there is a huge leap from the Marples to the Tasai chisels. So are they worth it?

I wish I had an absolute answer to that question, but I don't. I do not have the vast experience with either vintage chisels or current ones that I can offer authoritative comparisons. I can tell you that I make part of my living with my tools and my bench chisels get a tremendous amount of use. They are very vital to my work. So what do I think of the Tasai chisels? I think they are worth every penny.

Those who know Tasai's work know that his craftmanship is excellent. And I found that to be true when I inspected these chisels. The steel is well formed and the edge steel layer is ample. The chisels came razor sharp out of the box. For what it's worth, they come in a beautiful handmade wooden presentation box.

The rosewood handles are nicely finished and have a great feel. The chisels are well balanced and feel substantial to hold. They provide a sure and comfortable "feedback" when either pushed into the work or tapped by mallet. The geometry of the cutting edge has given me very nice results.

So if I am so pleased with these chisels why can I not give an absolute answer about whether they are worth the cost? Well, because I think much of the equation is subjective. These chisels perform beautifully for me but I know that woodworkers can get equally good results with other chisels. There is a matter of preferrence too. Many prefer western chisel forms over Japanese. Certainly personal ergonomics play a factor as well. So I won't profess that these chisels are the end all, be all. But in my hands and for my work they are fantastic. If you are looking for a high quality Japanese style bench chisel then I can certainly recommend the Tasai "Polishing Finish" bench chisels.

As a side note, I just learned that Akio Tasai will be in the hospital for a while to tend to some medical issues. I wish him well and I feel fortunate to have a set of tools made by a master such as he.

Tom

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#2

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

ThomD

>You are right that a lot of this is subjective. That doesn't mean that there aren't some objective measures, but there are also subjective aspects, and given the environment they tend to be determinative. In most cases people are looking for some kind of experience. I mention the tourist grade thing, when these threads come up, which seems to have been your entry point even being a pro. What does it say when a person decides to buy flashy chisels, to make the passing of an aniversarry more memorable?

I did something similar, different cause, same objective, when I bought my push chisels. Being a tool snob of a different sort I bought ones that weren't fancy because that pleased my sensibility about what I should buy moreso than buying the tourist ones, but it was flash of a different sort. Like the guy who buys a flat finished .45 vs. the guy who buys a nickle plated one. At the end of the day it says the person buying the product is after an experience. And only part of that experience is in the test drive, like driving a tricked out car is only partly about the peformance.

On that basis, Japanese chisels do really well; there is more depth to them in the quality of their manufacture, more to hold our interest. It's like a fine wine, that as the label says "has hints of licorice and rasberry". Who really needs that in a wine, but it adds interest for those so inclined.

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#3

Pictures!

wilbur

>We want pictures!

Well, I do, at least.

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#4

Thom....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Thom

I think you captured my thoughts very well. Your words ring true.

Thanks

Tom

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#5

Investment

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thomas,

Quality is always in style. You made an investment. What you have will last your lifetime, will give you no regrets or desire to 'upgrade'. Plus, you won't have to open a quarterly statement and find out how much they went down.

I think all of us want to get to a point in our lives where we say, 'these are my tools, I'm not thinking about upgrading, not thinking that these will do for a while. Nope, this is it, this is what I want and it's all I want.'

Does your wife have any sisters? Wow, she was your best decision ever.

Wiley

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#6

Well, if you insist...Pictures

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Much like asking a new parent to show pictures of the baby...no problem!


This is the presentation box.



Close up of the business end of one of the chisels


Back side of the chisel. I chose to go with multi-fluted chisels.

Tom

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#7

Re: Investment

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Right on Target Wiley. Properly cared for I expect these chisels to give me a career of good use. And when I use them they will always remind me of how special they are.

The "gift" from my wife of course was not money but merely the gift of permission. Why is that important? For exoneration of guilt! ;-) The chisels were in fact paid for by my WW business. It's been a good year so I guess I earned them. :-)

Tom

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#8

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Hank Knight

>Thomas,

Those are nice looking chisels. I reached Wiley's pinnacle point with my Imais and I have no thought that I will ever have (or want) to replace them. I hope you feel the same after you have used yours for a while. I have come (almost) to find these endless arguments about the pros and cons of Japanese chisels amusing. The subjective "hints of licorice," the hype about Japanese toolmaking, the objective data about edge hardness, durability and all that that are of no consequence to me. Whatever the reason, my Japanese chisels feel better and work better for me than any others; I need to look no further. I hope you arrive at the same place with yours.

Hank

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#9

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Kevin Adams

>Tom--

Beautiful chisels and I'm sure they will bring you a life time of good use. If you don't mind me asking, which vendor did you purchase them through and how long was the wait?

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#10

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report *LINK*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I bought them from Tomohita Iida at Iida Tools. He is excellent to work with and is very helpful. He knows the master tool makers personally so he can give insight. Once I ordered I had the chisels in about 1 week. However, since the tools that Iida carries are handmade they are not always in stock and you would have to wait for a set to be made in some cases. Tomohito-san would let you know if any tool you are interested is in his inventory or not.

Here is a link:


Iida Tools

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#11

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Great to hear that you've got your chisels, have loads of fun.

Pam

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#12

Hey you know the rules about posting porn

Thomas S Stockton

>

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#13

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Kevin Adams

>Thanks, Tom. Yes, my bank account is acquainted with Tomohita-san as well! He is a great guy--extremely responsive and friendly. I try to avoid looking at his site too often so I stay out of trouble.

Enjoy those chisels and hopefully we'll see how well they work in one of your beautiful furniture pieces in the near future.

Kevin

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#14

Re: Thom....

ThomD

>Gee, I am glad for that, because as I often do, I was really musing about my own reactions, probably someone elses, not necesarilly yours, and I get into heavy trouble doing that. So I am glad that at some level we are on the same wavelength, and I didn't cause hard feelings. May you have health to enjoy them as my family was prone to say, and happy 20th birthday!

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#15

Way to go!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Very nice chisels! And I support your choice of multiple hollows, even if some label these as "tourist stuff" (I did the same with my Imai).

I'm sure you'll enjoy these chisels all your life, there's something to buying tools you know you won't need to upgrade down the road...

DC

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#16

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

Dave Anderson NH

>Well an early Happy Birthday to you Tommy. While not a Eastern style tool user, I can certainly appreciate the beauty of that set. Milestone birthdays are always interesting and there is no need to feel strange or worried about them. Start to worry when you don't have them. Mine's in a couple of weeks and also one of those "decade" birthdays. Congrats again on the chisels you did indeed earn them.

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#17

Ooooo.... Aaaaahh....

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>They look nice Tommy. Really nice. Thom's comment hits home for me too; he said it better than I could.

Even though I have a chisel weakness myself, I am curious that the LNs did not cure you. Is there anything about them you dislike?

Oh, and congrats on your good year and rewarding yourself. My milestone Bday present did not make the forum only because it was not a tool. But I know the feeling.

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#18

The L-Ns

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>First of all, the LN chisels are very nice. I have no major complaints. Like I said earlier, some of it is just user preferrence and ergonomics. The LN's are a bit short. I have come to not like the handles and I will some day turn some that are longer and more to my liking. They are light in weight and I think I like chisels to have a bit more heft. The other thing is my own quirk. I generally hold chisels like most folks but in some situations I "choke up" and hold the shaft of the chisel. The geometry of the LNs create sharp edges from the bevel to the shaft. I have cut my hands on those edges before. Performance-wise they are good tools but I think these Tasai chisels will provide me both performance and suitability to my personal preferences.

Re: Japanese Bench Chisel Report

#19

Re: Well, if you insist...Pictures

wilbur

>Thanks for the photos, Tom! Always nice to see baby pictures. :@)