Not simply a sharpening question.
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I watched David Charlesworth's DVD on sharpening chisels last night. David is a fine technician and his instruction is clear and precise. I have no issue with David - I have learned a great deal from him. However his goal of honing three secondary bevels is something that raised a question mark in my mind and is worth discussing here.
I said that this post is not simply about sharpening. It is really about how sharpening affects the way we look at working wood. That is, the consequence of a sharpening methodology on the woodworking techniques you can employ.
The only time I hone a secondary bevel on a blade is when I prepare a BU blade or a morticel chisel. Otherwise never on a chisel blade. (Ditto no Ruler Trick on plane blades for me).
All my chisels, are hollow ground (with the exception of mortice chisels), and this includes Japanese chisels as well. I prefer to hone these freehand on waterstones, which is done directly over the hollow, and this automatically creates a microbevel that is co-planar with the bevel face.
This co-planar relationship with the bevel face is extremely important, in my view. Two reasons:
The first is that a flat bevel is easier to strop freehand as part of ongoing blade maintenance (that is, where one does not have to go through the multiple steps of honing). A microbevel or secondary bevel that is not co-planar will be difficult to reproduce freehand, and is too much effort to do with a honing guide.
The second reason affects the way one can use a chisel. Chisels may be used either bevel down or bevel up. Most of the time they are used bevel up, such as when chopping or paring with the back against a reference/fence. Chisels are flipped over and used bevel down when working in closed areas or small detail or where the paring angle is better accessed this way. The bevel face now acts as the reference surface (rather than the back of the blade). A secondary bevel would affect this reference surface and make it difficult to maintain a paring angle. Thus, for me, a secondary bevel on a chisel is a no-no. I frequently use a chisel bevel down.
I am aware that many use secondary bevels on chisels. Some makers actively recommend this to strength the edge, say adding a 35 degree microbevel to a 30 degree primary bevel. It is, in fact, a common thing to "grind at 25 degrees and hone at 30 degrees". This would be more prevalent among blades made from A2 than O1 steel.
Opinions? Who uses a chisel bevel down? And does so with a secondary bevel?
Regards from Perth
Derek



