Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Not simply a sharpening question.

Posts

Not simply a sharpening question.

#1

Not simply a sharpening question.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I watched David Charlesworth's DVD on sharpening chisels last night. David is a fine technician and his instruction is clear and precise. I have no issue with David - I have learned a great deal from him. However his goal of honing three secondary bevels is something that raised a question mark in my mind and is worth discussing here.

I said that this post is not simply about sharpening. It is really about how sharpening affects the way we look at working wood. That is, the consequence of a sharpening methodology on the woodworking techniques you can employ.

The only time I hone a secondary bevel on a blade is when I prepare a BU blade or a morticel chisel. Otherwise never on a chisel blade. (Ditto no Ruler Trick on plane blades for me).

All my chisels, are hollow ground (with the exception of mortice chisels), and this includes Japanese chisels as well. I prefer to hone these freehand on waterstones, which is done directly over the hollow, and this automatically creates a microbevel that is co-planar with the bevel face.

This co-planar relationship with the bevel face is extremely important, in my view. Two reasons:

The first is that a flat bevel is easier to strop freehand as part of ongoing blade maintenance (that is, where one does not have to go through the multiple steps of honing). A microbevel or secondary bevel that is not co-planar will be difficult to reproduce freehand, and is too much effort to do with a honing guide.

The second reason affects the way one can use a chisel. Chisels may be used either bevel down or bevel up. Most of the time they are used bevel up, such as when chopping or paring with the back against a reference/fence. Chisels are flipped over and used bevel down when working in closed areas or small detail or where the paring angle is better accessed this way. The bevel face now acts as the reference surface (rather than the back of the blade). A secondary bevel would affect this reference surface and make it difficult to maintain a paring angle. Thus, for me, a secondary bevel on a chisel is a no-no. I frequently use a chisel bevel down.

I am aware that many use secondary bevels on chisels. Some makers actively recommend this to strength the edge, say adding a 35 degree microbevel to a 30 degree primary bevel. It is, in fact, a common thing to "grind at 25 degrees and hone at 30 degrees". This would be more prevalent among blades made from A2 than O1 steel.

Opinions? Who uses a chisel bevel down? And does so with a secondary bevel?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#2

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

Sgian Dubh

>"Who uses a chisel bevel down? And does so with a secondary bevel?

I do Derek. Personally I can't ever recall having a problem finding the right spot to use a chisel this way.

What you are calling the primary bevel and micro-bevel I have always known as the grinding angle and honing angle. It is interesting how different or 'new' terminology gains currency.

I use a honing angle (secondary bevel to some) because my work is all about speed; I'm singularly disinterested in purism in woodworking tool use. An extra ten seconds sharpening the full length of the grinding angle (primary bevel) is a waste of my time. I just want the darned chisel to work.

A general purpose chisel fairly infrequently needs sharpening to near perfection. The same applies to turning tools, planes of all sorts, and carving tools; generally only the final light cuts need the best edge you can achieve. Hell, I even use chisels with nicks in the cutting edge, and faces (backs if you prefer) that aren't flat for bashing out things like dovetails, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#3

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

Charlie

>Who gives a damn? How's the weather in Perth?

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#4

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Sometimes I use a chisel bevel down when working in tight areas, for example hollowing out the recess for inlay..

Also, I don't ever bother with secondary bevels. I flat grind my chisels and plane irons and hone the primary bevel only.

Haven't ever had any issues with this.

I like this method because the primary bevel is consistent, I know what it is and when I free-hand hone on stones ( to touch up edges), it is straightforward to hold the chisel or plane iron at this angle

w/o guessing at the secondary bevel angle..

And ending up with multi-faceted edges.

Norman

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#5

I don't understand, Derek

Adam Cherubini

>Derek,

I don't believe using a reference face against the wood does what people think it does. Chisels wielded this way are planes without a wear and tearout is the inevitable outcome. Chisels really work better with a relief angle and a way of altering the cutting angle. The reference angle (either BU or BD) prohibits both.

If you are happy using your chisels the way you do and the way you sharpen God bless you. To use the sort of techniquye I use (and sounds like Richard uses) you need to sharpen differently. Micro/secondary bevels/a dubbed edge are really helpful. I think a dubbed over back is helpful too.

And the elliptical x-section is stronger on paper than a hollow or a flat ground edge. Folks mistakenly think x-sectional area is the only factor. Not so.

Now my question:

"I prefer to hone these freehand on waterstones, which is done directly over the hollow, and this automatically creates a microbevel that is co-planar with the bevel face."

So are you just sitting on the hollow and rubbing it? Is the microbevel just a very small flat spot? See, when I hear microbevel, I think secondary.

"The first is that a flat bevel is easier to strop freehand"

Why is that? What does teh strop care? Are you concerned about stropping a higher angle then you honed? Isn't that kinda teh point of stropping? When you polish that edge, you are rounding it a tiny bit. The flexibility of the leather does this no matter how you hold your chisel. That's the difference between stropping and honing if you ask me.

Regarding your last paragraph and my first, I think folks seem to think of carving chisels as fundamentally different from all other chisels. We all know they do a fantastic job withlow bevels, thin edges, and rounded x-sections. I'm not sure the wood agrees there's a difference. It simply isn't a fact that flat backs and flat bevels are required to make a chisel (or plane blade) effective. And carving/sculpture tools are the proof, aren't they?

Sorry if I blathered on too much here, brother. I want to understand what you are describing.

adam

P.S. I have a spare 1/2" chisel in my shop with your name on it. I just have to find a handle for it and post it. I'll have it to you before Christmas.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#6

Re: I don't understand, Derek

Chris Friesen

>Adam, I've seen this comment of yours (about thinking of bench chisels like carving chisels) before, and I've always wondered about it.

With a flat back on a chisel I can rest the back on one piece and pare another piece to match it (shaving a peg flush with another surface, for instance). If the chisel has a back bevel, I need to tip it up. Doing this I lose the reference plane and have to actively steer the chisel to keep it from digging in. This seems more difficult.

I'd appreciate some elaboration on how you handle this...

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#7

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

ThomD

>The coplanar coment sounds off to me, you don't have a plane you have a hollow, with a micro bevel on either end of it. You are unconsciously using the very chisel you are asking a question about, until you are deep into the cut, at which point the bevel is rarely bearing.

I think use of the chisel with the bevel side is far more generally useful than outlined in the responses so far. I'm talking about cutting not prying. Pros seem to do this a lot. I think I agree with Adam's points on the planing syndrome. Chisels are generally pretty dynamic, particularly the more powerfully they are used.

The undiscussed thing these days seems to be the convex bevel, though it was comon enough on old tools. I guess particularly mortising chisels. Allows prying without prying.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#8

chisel use

Adam Cherubini

>I use the reference face. I just don't let it dictate what my cutting angle and depth of cut will be. I can raise the edge of the tool above the surface or dig into it as I see fit.

This is something I learned in Moxon and have been doing for many years now. I think it's a helpful technique.

In 2009, I'll be teaching classes that will include this technique specifically because I'm finding that a lot of woodworkers aren't familiar with it. I'm hoping they will take these sorts of techniques, develop a "physical understanding" with the tools/edges that support them, and apply them to work beyond 18th c pieces.

I THINK there are spots open in www.kellymehler.com (KY) for my class in March and www.schoolofwood.com (MN) in May. One of my friends (Mark Hickey) complained to me that the period woodworkers never leave the East Coast. So I'm hoping to help remedy that.

BTW, I don't believe there are no period woodworkers outside of the East Coast. One of the best, Dennis Bork, is in WI. But I understood Mark's point.

I'm doing a clinic with Underhill on this very subject in a couple days and I'll bounce this off of him and see what he says. Just seeing Roy is exciting. Helping him teach a clinic (my plan is to just stay out of his way) should be quite an experience! As you can guess, I'm a huge fan so this is a big thrill for me. (Thanks Chris)

Adam

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#9

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

Thomas S Stockton

>I was taught a couple of different ways to sharpen all of them slightly different, I think the most important thing in sharpening is to find a technique that works for you and get good at it. Once your good at it it is much easier to easier to figure out what works for you and what doesn't. Is Derek wrong and David right I don't think so both have figured out what works for them.

Sharpening is the one area of woodworking that I think gadgets have taken over and it is not a good thing. Sharpening is a pretty simple task and takes minimal tools a grinder, some stones and maybe a guide. Yes it takes some time to master but it really isn't that hard and once you master it you won't forget.

Tom

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#10

Re: I don't understand, Derek

Dean J in MN

>... With a flat back on a chisel I can rest the back on one piece and pare another piece to match it (shaving a peg flush with another surface, for instance). If the chisel has a back bevel, I need to tip it up. Doing this I lose the reference plane and have to actively steer the chisel to keep it from digging in. This seems more difficult.

You're steering the chisel even if you use the flat back as a reference. You may not realize it, but you have to be steering in your example. The moment the chisel starts cutting the peg it will be forced down and into the other surface. You have to stop that by steering, even if that steering force is just down pressure on the handle. A chisel is a wedge, and a flat back doesn't somehow make a chisel a plane. Left to follow its own path it will not follow the back, it will undercut. Lighter cuts, lower bevel angles, etc all reduce this tendency, but you can not escape it. Embrace the wedge!

-Dean

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#11

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I often use chisels bevel down (not talking about carving chisels here, which often are out cannel to start with (thus always bevel down)), no secondary bevel, ever. Bevel down reduces tear out.

Pam

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#12

Not yet a convert

Jim in VA

>I am always eager to try new (to me) techniques to see if they represent improvements. I just went out in the shop and, not willing to dub over the edge of my paring chisels, tried to pare the cheek and then shoulder of a tenon with a carving chisel. Works, of course, but I had MUCH less control than when use the reference face of a flat paring chisel. Sort of the difference between using a card scraper and a scraper plane. The card scraper can do different tasks, but it's harder to obtain a flat surface over a large surface with it. For rough, fast work the dubbed chisel might be okay, but not for refined work. Maybe my experiment would work better with just a dubbed paring chisel, but I'm skeptical. Glad it works for you.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#13

Complicated example *LINK*

Adam Cherubini

>I don't want to "convert" you. Unlike religion, this is something you can try, and learn, and use when and if it suits you. It's not an either or type of situation. The only reason I brought it up is that it can effect the way you sharpen your chisels. It's funny this came up, because we're going to have this exact conversation in Woodworking in America in a few days time in Kentucky. I think they are going to video some things so maybe Derek will get to see some of this discussed.

Tho I have no reason or grounds to quibble with your experience, this is a very complicated situation that I often find dismissed or over simplified.

If a tenon cheek is uniformly proud, you have no reference face to index against. You have to work down to one or more lines. If it's uniformly flat, theoretically your chisel won't cut (BU). Of course it will in real life and that's the reason why this technique doesn't do what people think it does. Chisels submarine as Dean explained and tho the section is worded unfortunately, Moxon discussed this very subject over 300 years ago.

In my shop, I hand saw all of my tenons. When i make a mistake with my hand saw, I don't just continue the bad cut, I try to correct it. As a result the face of the tenon cheek is often irregular or twisted. Once again, I have no reference face. I need to remove some triangular sliver. So being able to control depth and location of the cut precisely is what I'm after.

In the case of tenon shoulders, I too use my chisels BU there to straighten the edge. You really have to be very careful because that cut will also "submarine" under your scribe line, tho I find this less an issue when cutting end grain. Back side "spelching" (splitting off of back side fibers) is also a worry. So I often pare down toward the cheek. I also purposely undercut here on many things.

What I recommend for tenon cheeks is holding the chisel BD like a pencil (more or less- see moxon link below) with your hand resting on the rail. Using open hand or shoulder pressure, pare away material almost like an OWT router would.

I think one thing guys like about paring BU is the support. I think this is VERY important. I always have the hand holding the chisel on the work or bench. That sort of push pull is where we get the control.

I don't want to type out everything I planned to say in KY, but when I go to Wmsburg and watch those guys work (ww conference in January not yet sold out), they can just do amazingly complicated things with chisels. And quickly too. It's really a lot like watching a chef chop an onion. Such speed and precision, it's really inspiring.

Adam


New Moxon

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#14

Re: I don't understand, Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Adam

Many thanks for the detailed responses. I would love to be able to answer these quickly, but our time differences make this impossible - are you prepared to write them at about 4:00 a.m.? :) I was tempted to write one long post, but shall rather answer (where I can) a few separately. I am also typing away furiously between consultations, and the combination of insufficient time and distractions mean that I shall need to clarify my words at some point! :)

If you are happy using your chisels the way you do and the way you sharpen God bless you. To use the sort of techniquye I use (and sounds like Richard uses) you need to sharpen differently. Micro/secondary bevels/a dubbed edge are really helpful. I think a dubbed over back is helpful too.

Clearly there are many ways to use a chisel. Would it be a valid simplification to say that one does so either as a bench/paring chisel with a guide (any reference surface) or freehand/unguided (ala a carving chisel)?

Now my question:

"I prefer to hone these freehand on waterstones, which is done directly over the hollow, and this automatically creates a microbevel that is co-planar with the bevel face."

So are you just sitting on the hollow and rubbing it? Is the microbevel just a very small flat spot? See, when I hear microbevel, I think secondary.

I place the hollow ground face flat on the waterstone and use the two sides to register and support the bevel face. The result is a bevel edge that is co-planar across the bevel face.

Terminology is a confusing thing. When I use "microbevel" I am simply saying that the bevel honed it tiny .. micro .. in width. A microbevel is not a secondary bevel, per se, although the opposite may be true. A "secondary bevel" is not co-planar to the bevel face, but honed at a steeper angle. A very small secondary bevel is also a microbevel.

I aim to hone a microbevel (not a secondary). That is sufficient for an edge. It is created from the hollow, and to make it "micro" I will grind the hollow as close to the edge of the bevel face as possible.

"The first is that a flat bevel is easier to strop freehand"

Why is that? What does teh strop care? Are you concerned about stropping a higher angle then you honed? Isn't that kinda teh point of stropping? When you polish that edge, you are rounding it a tiny bit. The flexibility of the leather does this no matter how you hold your chisel. That's the difference between stropping and honing if you ask me.

I do not see why one must change the angle of the bevel (micro or secondary) when stropping. Stropping in this instance is merely to renew an edge, not reshape it, and I do this as I work when I feel the chisel beginning to dull. If I do not have to change the bevel angle, then there is less work to do.

I try to use as bevels as low as the wood will allow. In part, this is simply because they penetrate hardwood more easily than high bevel angles, or because they cut soft wood fibres more cleanly.

Jarrah (for example) is not just a very hard wood, but is also very abrasive and dulls an edge rapidly.

Regarding your last paragraph and my first, I think folks seem to think of carving chisels as fundamentally different from all other chisels. We all know they do a fantastic job withlow bevels, thin edges, and rounded x-sections. I'm not sure the wood agrees there's a difference. It simply isn't a fact that flat backs and flat bevels are required to make a chisel (or plane blade) effective. And carving/sculpture tools are the proof, aren't they?

In reality I am convinced that I also use my chisels in a similar way to you, rather than just in the way I painted at the start. Sometimes a delicate cut made BD means that the hollow removes the regustration, and so one is then using the chisel like a carving chisel.

P.S. I have a spare 1/2" chisel in my shop with your name on it. I just have to find a handle for it and post it. I'll have it to you before Christmas.

Adam, you are very kind. That would make a wonderful Christmas present .. or even New Year present - I know how busy you are, so do not fret if you run out of time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#15

disagreement

James Watriss

>I have to disagree on that point... it's very hard to steer a flat back out of anything. If you're cutting bevel down, you push the handle down, and it steers the bit out of the work. If you're cutting bevel up, and you push the handle down, the only way to get the bit back out is to break off the fibers that are over the chisel. If, on the other hand, you have a small backbevel, then you'll have to cut with the handle slightly raised, and then you'll be able to push the handle down to steer it back out again.

I've seen this done with carving chisels, and with drawknives, and bevel up spokeshaves... but hadn't thought about it with a chisel...

hmmmm.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#16

Re: disagreement

Dean J in MN

>James -

Right -- and another good example that a flat back doesn't make a chisel a plane!

-Dean

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#17

Re: Complicated example

Charles

>When I do what you explain I set the chisel bevel down holding it with my left hand in such a way that my left thumb bridges the wood and the back (flat face) of the chisel. I can't describe what my right hand does other than power the chisel. I don't have a chisel nearby to take hold of it and describe my right hand grip. However, the key for me is the bridging across the flat face of the chisel and the wood being pared with my left thumb. And yes, you have to be careful to bend the thumb in such a way as to minimize nicks, though they do happen. A piece of white athletic tape around my left thumb offers protection at some loss of feel.

Re: Not simply a sharpening question.

#18

Re: Complicated example

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't use my thumb at all, nor do I try to bridge some chisel to wood gap (not there IME); but I do hold the chisel with several fingers holding down the chisel. Right hand is palm up to hold the handle.

Pam