Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Planing speed vs. tearout

Posts

Planing speed vs. tearout

#1

Planing speed vs. tearout

wilbur

>Has anyone noticed whether tearout increases or decreases with how fast/slow you are pushing your plane?

If anyone cares, I was wrestling with planing the face of a maple board last night. I also don't know how I got into this position, but I also realized this was the first time I had really worked with maple.

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#2

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

Paul Kierstead

>In my observation, planing faster seems to help. I have nothing to back that up, other then casual observation. However, it also seems to introduce a whole bunch of new problems, so I plane at the speed which is well controlled.

Maple should plane well with the grain. It tears out like a SOB against the grain, particularly with low angles. High angle is very effective at taming it; My 52.5 degree smoother will go in any direction without tearout.

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#3

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Interesting question, Wilbur. I have long thought that speed improves the appearance- especially the liveliness of the wood, but have no feel for the tearout question. I use the double iron for tearout.

I love hard maple for turning, but I don't like it for case work. I don't think the appearance of hard maple justifies the extra labor it costs with respect to soft maple, walnut, cherry, mahogany, etc. And I think the evidence is that 18th century workers thought the same. Perhaps if you take a very light cut with the plane it will help.

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#4

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout *LINK*

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>We had a discussion about this two years ago, I think faster speed can help reduce tearout, but I wouldn't bet my life on it...

DC


Earlier thread

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#5

And I still stand by my post in that thread.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#6

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

ThomD

>Faster planing, within one's ability inploves the cut for finishing cuts. If you are using a set-up where you think you are pretty certain to tear a big hunk out, then I don't think it will chnage the outcome. If one was planing birdseye and was looking at the list of perfections that would improve the planed surface, speed would be one of them. Under the right circumstances speed is like a sharper blade.

Faster is harder to do by a huge margin. The average par golfer is about a 260 yard hitter, the average long pro is maybe 280, and 300+ on the measuring hole is a long distance. So an improvement of 10-20% will get you that much more energy squared, but it is a huge deal.

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#7

Data

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When machining maple the higher the cutter tip speed the less the tear out. Making the jump from machine planing to hand, I can smoothly machine plane boards that I would be unsuccessful hand planing. So there is no question about whether very high speed is better than hand speeds. Now to think further about whether this situation holds true at lower (hand) speeds.

It makes intuitive sense that faster would deflect the fibers less and thereby produce less tear out. A hanging rope can be cut with a knife if the stroke is fast enough. However, I think I have better hand planning success planing slow.

What is the ultimate in slow... chiseling and carving. One can chisel/carve any orientation and not get tear out. Where is a mechanical engineer when we need one to explain these principals?

Re: Planing speed vs. tearout

#8

Re: Data

ThomD

>"However, I think I have better hand planning success planing slow."

That could be like all the golfers who hit it better if they don't try to kill it: There are two reasons for this, playing within one's own ability, and also the fact that often trying to be fast is actually slower. In golf for lessor mortals it is because they don't conbine the various sources of speed.

Speed is rarely discussed as a source of cutting power over here. Not so in Japanese woodworking where they do a number of things to plane fast, they comonly combine foot and upper body action, for instance.

The rope cutting action has some application. Obviously faster is more energy concentrated at the point of impact, there also isn't the time for the rope to be pushed aside. Imagine being pushed by a car that is moving very slowly. It has much greater energy than an arrow, but the application is gradual and would allow you to move to one side. With tearout the fiber has to have the time to lift up and be ripped out of the board. With enough speed there isn't the time, and the force is overwelming and will cut cleanly. Interesting to speculate whether the energy increase or timing factor is the critical factor.