Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Modifying a Sargent plane

Posts

Modifying a Sargent plane

#1

Modifying a Sargent plane

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>I've done a little looking for a fence rod for my new-to-me Sargent No. 79 duplex rabbet, so far with no success. I'm considering re-tapping the holes for the fence rod from the existing 1/4"-22 to the 1/4"-28 that Stanley uses, since Stanley fence rods are no issue.

Now, I know the answer to this - it's a tool, and modifying it to make it more useful is perfectly fine - but is there any collectible value to routine Sargent planes? This is not one of Sargent's best efforts, but rather a simplified version of the Stanley - simpler casting, adjustment by guess, several engineering/machining decisions that were clearly bottom-line-driven; so it seems unlikely, but thought I'd ask before I get out the taps.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>One caveat: The �-22 tapped hole in the plane is probably the same size as the �-28 you want to convert to. It'll be pretty hard to get a set of 28tpi threads over/thru the existing 22tpi ones. I doubt it'll work - at least not well enough to make the rod stay firmly in place, or easy to remove/replace.

Ideally, you could drill out to 5/16", plug the hole, and solder (epoxy?) the plug in place, then re-drill and tap for the �-28.

As you said, it's a user plane, not a work of art, so minor mods like this shouldn't be a problem. In this case, it'd actually be an enhancement.

Jim D.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#3

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

Walt

>you know, we didn't touch on that when we talked earlier today...might work but I think you'll end up with a weak thread that will eventually fail...

still on the look out

Walt Q

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#4

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

Victor Parisian

>Why not thread up a new rod instead. Just a thought, but I do similar things at work on a somewhat regular basis with throttle/actuator linkage on gas and hydraulic motors. If you screw it up you can throw the rod away and start over or cut it down and start over.

Victor in Houston - still waiting for some fall weather.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#5

Actually

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>I've threaded finer threads in holes with coarser threads regularly without problems. The generator bracket on my 1949 Studebaker trucks (now in my son's possession), which is carrying a lot more stress than a plane fence likely would, is 5/16 fine thread done when the coarse thread stripped out.

I think it works because the minor diameter of the hole increases as the thread pitch becomes finer.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#6

Love to

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>if I had a 1/4"-22 die, not a standard size for many a year, or a metal lathe.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#7

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

Neal in San Jose

>As Walt said, you will end up with a very weak thread. One not likely to survive the rigors of use. A second thought is to purchase and insert a heli-coil in 1/4-28 thread. These are not exactly cheap, but easily available from MSC on line, or maybe your local auto repair parts place.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#8

1/4-22 die

Tom MacGregor

>I did a Google search on "1/4-22 thread" and it brought up a place with a 1/4-22 die available for $10. Don't know anything about the company but I thought I'd toss the info. into the mix.

Re: Modifying a Sargent plane

#9

and the strength of the board shows itself again.

Victor Parisian

>