Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: book

Posts

OT: book

#1

OT: book

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>My old university is storing books for one of its sister campuses with an industrial arts program - so I'm discovering a small trove of woodworking books, mostly mid-20th-century.

I got out, "Hand Woodworking," by DeWitt Hunt and John Bruce Tate. This is the 1956 fourth edition of a book first published in 1925, clearly written as an industrial arts textbook. Interesting differences from our current perspective on what's important:

1. It opens with a chapter on design which manages to talk about proportions without once mentioning the Golden Section. It proposes ratios of 1:2, 5:7, 7:10, and others, but none of them comes close to the Golden Section. It also suggests very simplistic rules about massing, which include that, for any even-numbered vertical division, each division should be equal in size - as I understand current design thinking, this would be seen as bland beyond words.

2. It devotes an entire chapter (granted, only 13 pages - it's not a very large book) to the mortise and tenon, but mentions dovetails only in passing with one rather vague sentence, and then only in the context of drawers; and, in discussing drawers, devotes far more attention to nailed rabbets and some of the interlocking dado-and-tongue joints that are now commonly cut only with power tools.

3. Pages saved by not talking about dovetails are devoted to chamfers (four pages) and "clamp nail and spline construction" (three pages). The chapter on chamfers introduced a layout tool that was new to me: chamfer sticks, which are basically strips of scrap of various thicknesses that you lay on the bench next to your stock. You then run a pencil along the edge of the stick where it touches the stock, which marks out a distance from the arris of the stock. You repeat on the other face of the stock, and there you have your layout. The several thicknesses of chamfer sticks allow laying out 45 degree or oblique chamfers. Cleverly simple.

I was, finally, interested to find that the authors considered the circular plane a "basic" plane, which probably explains why you find so many at garage sales; and that they considered the turning saw a standard saw as late as the mid-1950's (again, explaining why they litter the tables of garage sales, next to all those rusty Disston saws).

Re: OT: book

#2

Oh, by the way, regarding the use of the thumb

Bill Houghton, rainy in Sebastopol, CA

>in starting a handsaw cut: the authors have a little picture with he thumb of the hand not holding the saw serving to locate the saw as it starts the cut. I don't know if it dates from the first edition, so don't know if it was proposed as standard practice back in 1925, but offer it as possible additional support for the notion that this isn't a new practice from our decadent era.

Re: OT: book

#3

Re: Oh, by the way, regarding the use of the thumb

Victor Parisian

>Well....................What about the nib???

Got to get one more thing done at work today and then it's home to turn some scrap wood on the small jet lathe.

Victor