My approach *LINK*
David Barnett - SW Florida
>My way: finish to bright, knock down, polish to desired sheen. On detailed carving/mouldings, highlight with restraint, leaving the recesses more matte for gentle contrast.
If your shellac was fresh and has cured hard, you might try lighly stroking to what I call 'high satin' with a slightly-worn 3M grey pad followed by Behlen's "Deluxing Compound". The friability of the grit allows control in acheiving the right amount of lustre and is forgiving inasmuch as it's undoable and redoable. This method (along with other variants) lets me produce the high lustre people often want without the greasy, sticky gloss of resins, whether shellac or amber, which I simply can't abide. Less rubbing will produce a softer glow (my preference). Just call me Mr. Matte.
Oh... rottenstone can make a real mess of any shellac that's softer, whether it was past its prime or simply too soon to have fully cured.
Behlen's Deluxing Compound