Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Unusual square: what is it?

Posts

Unusual square: what is it?

#1

Unusual square: what is it?

TomW

>Greetings all, found this site from the owwm.com site. I have a question on an unusual metal square I picked up at a flea mkt. My neighbor collects old hand tools and thought maybe this is a tailors square..but I couldn't find anything on the web to verify or refute.

It measures ~ 27" x 13 1/2" Some notable features are the end profiles, the stamped 'mark' (looks like a crown w/ a stamped ? & G), and the two little notches along the inside edge of the longer piece, where the two pieces join at the 90* angle. The two pieces are joined via some type of joint and are pinned. Also, the pieces are thinner at the profiled edge, and get gradually thicker toward the 90* joint.

Any help appreciated on what it is, scarcity and so on..Regards, Tom


img

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#2

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

Todd Hughes

>While with out looking at it in person it can be hard to tell for certain but looks like a very early, perhaps 18th century square, most likely hand forged which would account maybe for the change in dimensions you seem to be talking about. The shape of the ends is what gives it away as this is an indication of an early square. I would rate this as a pretty rare find. Don't know about vaule, usually not much interest in roofing squares but again this is not your common square, I would figure around $100 and could be more to the right person. I have seen fake ones [square tipped squares reworked like this] at tool shows and they were pricy.Maybe a small chance that yours is not original too I guess, little unusual that the profile on the ends seem to be reversed.,,,don't know

... Probably not much chance on finding out anything on the stamp or who made it.

....No way is a tailor square I think most all tailer squares I have seen were made out of wood and are not shapped like this.....Todd

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#3

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

Wolfgang Jordan

>Tom,

hate to burst your bubble, but this is an ordinary German carpenter's square like this one:

http://www.feinewerkzeuge.de/G302856.htm

You can see in this picture that the taper in thickness is deliberately made and that these squares are still made like this. I have two similar squares and they look very much like yours.

Todd was certainly right if this was an English square, but I'm sure it is of German make.

As to the maker I can only guess. I have a pair of pliers with a mark you describe and I attribute it to Wilhelm Friedrich Gerlach in Steinbach-Hallenberg/Germany:

http://www.holzwerken.de/museum/sonstige/zange1.phtml

Wolfgang

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#4

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

TomW

>..thanks for the info..here's a close up of the mark..I'm thinking German window square, 19th cent? Tom


img

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#5

A smaller square

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This iron square has if I remember correctly a picture of a Dolphin stamped in the corner.

Stephen


img

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#6

So, my question is,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>there's a lot of little nibby looking things on the end of each arm of that square. Are they used to start kerfs?

Teasing a lot here, of course, but I do think that the presence of utterly unnecessary, though quite attractive, decorative elements on these squares (unless I am missing some function that they fulfill, in which case, of course, I'll want one for myself) does provide some argument-by-analogy support for the idea that the nib on handsaws is decorative.

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#7

Re: So, my question is,

Bob Demers

>Ah Ah Precisely! The shaped at the ends is not merely decorative, its designed to fit inside house's wall inside corners allowing precise measurements.

Cause as we all know, they have yet to build house wall with perfect 90 degrees inside corner...

And thus another form Vs fonction raging debate a la nib is born :-)

Bob, snow delirium, California dreaming

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#8

I thought at first

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>that the shapes were little French curves, for layout purposes, but there are too many abrupt changes of shape for that to work.

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#9

Intended function vs. acquired function - long

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Thoughts while doing the morning chores: I have teased, and will no doubt continue to tease, Stephen Shepherd about the kerf-starting function of saw nibs.

I realized just now, while taking out trash and so on (allows time for thinking), that a lot of the fervor around this subject has been that people are talking about different "functions." The question is usually posed, by some innocent early learner about this stuff, "what is the function of the saw nib?" Discussion ensues, with many alternate ideas, including kerf-starting, saw-guard-fastening-string-holding, decorative, etc.

Often, a feature is designed into an object with one function (including "oooh, that's pretty," which is arguably a function - bringing good feelings to the viewer) in mind; I'll call that intended function. Over time, ingenious mechanics discover ways to use the feature in their work; I'll call those acquired functions.

My chest of drawers, kind of mid-boy height, built by my grandfather, uses knobs on the drawers. It stands next to my side of the bed, and the knob on the upper right drawer is perfectly placed and sized to take the hanging loop of my housecoat, so I can grab it quickly in the dark when I get up, something that occurs, alas, more than once per night. I doubt Grandpa had this in mind when he chose knobs over pulls; I think he was looking more at the style of the chest and choosing something that fit the design aesthetically. Or, since it was built during the Depression, he may have chosen what he could afford (or may have made them - not sure). But the housecoat-hanger acquired function sure works for me.

Until we find the definitive contemporary documentation of what the sawmakers had in mind in spending the extra time/money to make the nib, I think we can but speculate on original intent. To then say, "I find it useful for..." is fine - but should not be confused with a confident statement of what the original makers had in mind.

It has occurred to me that the curly ends on the squares pictured in this thread may well have had a design function other than aesthetics. In a busy shop, it might be easy to mistake a carefully crafted square for a chunk of wood or steel, useful to brace the corner of that complicated piece of furniture. The scallops would sing out, "This is a tool, dummy!" I want to emphasize, though, that I'm speculating here. It's equally possible that, like dancing leg calipers, the scalloped ends may have just been an aesthetic decision about what a good mechanic's tools should look like.

Now, I'd best get to the projects of the day, including a concrete-and-metal recycling run (no squares will be harmed in the dumping of all this trash), flu shot, and taking Zen Master Pod, our Siamese, in for examination of wounds from a recent tussle with something outside.

Re: Unusual square: what is it?

#10

I always thought the profile on the end was

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>used to scribe coped joints. I have been imagining that each square (most of them I have seen with this profile feature are home made wooden ones) had a profile that matched a plane's in the owner's tool box.

Of course I have no basis for thinking this.

greg