Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

What's a good, used jack plane

Posts

What's a good, used jack plane

#1

What's a good, used jack plane

Dan Mitchell

>This is my 1st post in this forum. I posted the following on the "Messages" forum & was told this discussion would be more appropriate.

So here goes:

So far I've mostly been learning machine-based wood working. I thought it might be fun to pick up, refurbish & learn to use a vintage jack plane. I have a Dunlop my father bought 40-odd years ago, but I have been told it's not the best. Below is a link to a Stanley on ebay, being sold by someone who's within driving distance.

I have to say, based only on the pictures, it sure looks like my dad's old Dunlop ;-/

What are some really sweet vintage planes of a type that would be a good addition to a machine-based shop?

BTW, I'm not married to the idea of getting something off Ebay, I;m just using this plane as an example. I know there are other sources, flea markets, antique stores, etc. If anyone happens to know of an especially good source in the Seattle area, please pass it on.

TIA

Dan

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: What's a good, used jack plane *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Dan,

Welcome to the quiet side. Before condemning that dunlap as inferior,tune it up and see how it performs.For good used planes,older Stanleys were the leaders in this field. Check out this website for information on Stanleys.---Jack


Patricks Blood and Gore

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#3

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Tom MacGregor

>A well tuned and sharpened Dunlop will easily out perform a poorly set up plane of any brand. Get started with Dad's plane and don't worry about upgrading until your intrest, knowledge and skill require it. I have some very nice planes but still occasionally grab Dad's 1960's Handyman jack or Craftsman block plane that I proudly keep because they were his.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#4

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Adam Cherubini

>Welcome!

A jack plane is a technically roughing plane. As such, they need very few premium features to function. A sharp stiff blade is about all. I think it's a rite of passage to take an old #5, clean it up and put it back into service. I say stick with what you've got and enjoy it. Save your money for a new smoother.

If you asked me what I think the best jack plane is, I'd say I prefer a wooden jack plane over a metal model. I find wooden planes are easier to handle and hold, and their light weight bodies make extended use less tiring. I especially prefer the thick laminated irons found on old planes.

Adam

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Moses Yoder

>I would start with that Dunlop and order a Hock iron for it. The regular iron made for Stanley planes should fit the Dunlop. THe plane is really only a tool to hold the iron. If you tune the plane, going through Charlesworth's method for plane tuning, if the iron is good the plane will function just as well as a new Lie-Nielson or Veritas plane, although the adjustments and cast iron are better on those new planes.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#6

Welcome top the quiet side.

Victor Parisian

>I just Googled tuning a bench plane, and found a lot of information.

When I started out(also with a jack plane that I bought at a flea market), I read everything that I could find, and soon came to an understanding of the basics of tuning a plane. Start with a decent plane that isn't badly pitted, or cracked that has all it's pieces etc.

Then follow the steps outlined by so many before you.

By the way, mine is a Stanley #5-C type 11 that works as well as any that you could purchase anywhere today. Could it be tuned better? Likely,now that I have gone through the procedures several times.

Enjoy the experience.

Victor - in Houston

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#7

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>What do you intend to use it for? Jacks are usually for rougher work, though not always. Tune it up, use it for everything and soon you'll start wanting to achieve specific results that will lead you to other planes. But the collective advice so far is my position as well. Your old plane is the best place to start.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#8

Craftsman/Dunlap?

Jerry Nicholson

>All Craftsman/Dunlap planes are not alike! Both my dad's Craftsman and my old (45+years) Dunlap have frogs that end a good 1/2 inch above the bottom of the plane, leaving 1/2+ inch of the blade unsupported kind of like a transition plane. Based on these planes, I concluded that planes were useless on anything harder than white pine. I have acquired a bunch of Stanley planes (and some Sargents) so now I know better. (Since I got my Lee Valley Bevel Up planes, the old Stanley's mostly just sit there and look pretty.)

Jerry

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#9

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Getting an old jack plane and tuning it up is a good way to go. But for what it's worth, I purchased a Veritas Low Angle Jack plane a couple of years ago and I have been very happy with it. Not exactly the same as a standard jack but it performs very well with challenging hardwoods. A little more cost than a used one but it won't break the bank. Like I said...for what it's worth.

Take care,

Tom

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#10

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

ThomD

>All good advice. My feeling on Jacks is that they should be in wood. The reason is that as others have said this is not a terribly fine cutting tool, so nobody should have any difficulty with it regardless of type. I'm not suggesting there will be difficulties moreso with any type, just that any perceived difficulties should not be a worry - an easy plane to get off the ground with. However, it is used for heavier works so a wooden plane will be several orders of magnitude less tiring/ and more pleasant to use than a metal one. If you have lots of tailed assistants you should be able to knock one out in about 45 minutes, but possibly not on your first try. Still easier to make than to rehab in steel.

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

#11

Re: What's a good, used jack plane

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. I think I'll begin with the old Dunlap. I've already sharpened the blade, which came out very well.

The Stanley page is very useful, thanks for that. I see quite a few old planes at antique shows, flea markets etc., nice to have an idea which are worth fooling with.

Dan